3 ms·
Not to derail the thread, but nation-states are about as obsolete as operating systems.
by eli_gottlieb 14y ago
Not to derail the thread, but nation-states are about as obsolete as operating systems.
- sebcat 14y agoThis is so true. The country I live in has about the same number of inhabitants as NYC. Today I read an article in a business magazine local to this country saying something like "we [as a country] need to be able to compete with the world". I mean, if we're supposed to compete with the bio mass of India or China, we're gonna have a bad time...
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoI live in a country with a similarly small population and much smaller land-area. Just because nation-states aren't the forefront of the most interesting stuff going on in the world today doesn't mean they don't perform a necessary function. The psychological problem with a functioning, well-done nation-state is that it fades into the background, and people just suddenly act surprised when they wake up one day after voting for neoliberals and find they've lost their rent subsidies, their child allowance, and half the coverage on their health insurance.
- freshhawk 14y agoSo by obsolete you mean "not trendy to think about but still the single largest contributing factor to every aspect of day to day experience"?
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoNot quite every aspect, but the lion's share, yes. Precisely so.
- crucialfelix 14y agonot to derail your derailing, but "nation state" has a specific definition that I think is different than what you are referring to. China, India and the US are not nation states. Neither is Belgium. Japan is the largest. > The state is a political and geopolitical entity; the nation is a cultural and/or ethnic entity. The term "nation state" implies that the two geographically coincide. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nation_state http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nation_state
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoNo, I'm referring to nation-states in specific. If you asked me for three major examples of why multinational empire-states are a Bad Idea, I would point to China, India, and the United States. Though their are arguments to be made that China is a Han nation-state that simply forces everyone else to go along with what the ruling clique of Han want.
- ansgri 14y agoInteresting topic. There were early operating systems that served as an infrastructure for user's programs, they trusted the user, etc.., as nation-states basically trust their citizens to trust the government. But then too much malicious os simply unsafe software got written (as developmen became easier; life of citizen demanded much less care for the state) and the OS began morphing into restrictive and oppressive systems like OSX and Win8. As these restrictions inflicted real inconveniences on the well-behaved individuals, and voilà, the government's no longer trusted and has to be fought with. AFAIK, in software world the way to deal with this situation is to build a new level of infrastructure abstraction to deal with oppressive OSes (ie webapps) and let the old system slowly die out because its services aren't really needed. Wonder what will become the political analog of the Web. Oh wait, the Web will itself evolve to become oppressive, no new analogs needed. Hegel would be happy, now that's dialectics in action.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoWait, web-apps didn't evolve to get past "oppressive" operating systems. They evolved because centralized IT departments and centralized application deployment were easier than providing adequate deployment support and keeping data closed for desktop applications. They're technologically inferior in almost every other way.