4 ms·
>The average German voter has no idea who Reinhart and Rogoff are No average voter knows who Reinhart and Rogoff are, and no one is making any argument that th
by pessimizer 14y ago
>The average German voter has no idea who Reinhart and Rogoff are
No average voter knows who Reinhart and Rogoff are, and no one is making any argument that they do, or that that matters.
>the actual spreadsheet errors changed their results from growth of -0.1% in high-debt countries to 0.2%; an inconsequential change.
So the 0.3% percent error was caused by incompetence at using a computer, and another 1.9% was caused by economic incompetence (equal weighting for all time periods) and deception (throwing away the first few years of data to create a convenient start date.) Is your defense that they were worse at economics than at Excel?
>the reason nobody looked too closely at the numbers is because they agree broadly with every other paper and model out there.
You've made this up. No one could reproduce their results.
Parent TL;DR: The paper didn't matter, because even though its purported evidence was wrongly conceived and badly executed, its conclusion is still right because it comports with what I have decided is common sense.