7 ms·
Co-founder breakups
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- sreitshamer 14y agoDoes the co-founder term always imply some sort of equality? If so, I think the implication is dangerous. For example, finding someone who works exactly as hard as you do is impossible, so someone's always going to be disappointed. Also, the buck has to stop somewhere, at an individual, not a committee. It's lonely at the top.
- _delirium 14y agoI've generally found that the best case is the buck stopping at a smallish committee (2-4 people) who work well together, take joint responsibility, and appropriately communicate and split expertise. Individuals have a lot of blind spots and tend to get either overwhelmed or overconfident. But it's also true that the "work well together" part has a high failure rate.
- bridgeyman 14y agoThis is helpful. We were fine with even equity splits or a slight difference because one cofounder is funding the venture. Sounds like even is preferred?
- Harj 14y agoIf one founder is putting money in that's different, I'll include that in the post.
- OnyeaboAduba 14y agoI think this article gives some sage advice on what to do before you get to the break-up stage...http://www.businessinsider.com/7-tips-for-picking-the-right-co-founder-2013-4 http://www.businessinsider.com/7-tips-for-picking-the-right-...
- benatkin 14y ago> The relationship between co-founders is usually the single biggest risk to a startup in the earliest stages This doesn't seem true to me. If it were the case, I think going single founder would be a way to improve the odds dramatically.
- abstractbill 14y agoA good co-founding relationship has much in common with a good marriage. Think of the output as being a happy family life. You can create that all by yourself, by adopting one or more children as a single parent. But it'll most likely be a lot harder than if you find a good partner.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- benatkin 14y agoI don't buy this. I'm not sure I'll do a good job at explaining why not, but it's more of a hunch than anything. The reason I don't buy it is because two average people can get married and have a happy family life simply by cooperating. Cooperating is not enough to succeed with a startup, they must also have a good enough idea, good execution of the idea, and some luck. Often nothing short of brilliant execution of the idea will make a startup work. And they probably need exceptional people, not average people. Another thing is that a happy startup life, most of the time, is unsustainable. People at the startup can be happy and get along with each other right until they run out of funding. I've watched it happen. They often still get along after they've stopped working on it, but the startup has failed.
- TheLegace 14y agoYou know what my opinion was always that finding competent, smart, interesting and passionate people are impossible to find, at least around me. I have just gotten use to completely relying on myself. In a lot of ways other people can negatively impact your creative process by being a distraction. But at the same time, if you find someone where you can happily communicate with then maybe the ideas can pour out.
- jordn 14y agoI'm actually a little surprised that an equal equity split is apparently the default and preferred option in the valley. It's quite an unspeakable topic in my experience so I'd appreciate if someone could confirm this. I remember being told explicitly in one startup focused class at MIT that it was highly advisable to decide one way or another who would have the majority of shares. We even played a role playing game where an equal split was the only wrong answer. The idea was that not everyone will be sacrificing and committing equally and that it was better to figure that out upfront than have it play out down the line.
- maaku 14y ago> The idea was that not everyone will be sacrificing and committing equally and that it was better to figure that out upfront than have it play out down the line. If you think you can figure out ahead of time who will be "less committed" or otherwise less deserving of equity, then either (a) you're fooling yourself, or (b) that person shouldn't be a founder.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- derefr 14y agoI have friends with great skills who I want to work with at my startup, but none who I would really expect "founder" levels of commitment out of. It seems that they agree: what we both really seem to want is that, after I get the business off the ground on my own, I just hire them for cushy jobs as employees. :)
- johnrob 14y agoI'm an advocate of even splits. IMO the logic behind having a dominant founder derives from classic corporate management where you have a boss and a team. I don't see that as a good baseline for a team of founders.
- jordn 14y agoI think I agree. I don't believe a startup can work if the focus is on equity grabbing or if any agreement leaves one founder feeling less committed to the project than the other. A sense of ownership is one of the big motivators that helps you to fall in love and commit to an idea. So if there's something on paper that makes it like the idea is less yours than the other co-founder, I think it will cause less commitment as a result. Better to own less of successful company than all of nothing.
- spartango 14y agoThese are excellent observations. I think one of the big challenges, though, is that seeing these issues coming can be very challenging. Subtle commitment or personal priorities issues can lurk under the radar and only come up when the going gets rough. I think the last point, regarding candor, is super critical for this reason; if your team is transparent about everything, then there's a good chance you'll realize things aren't right before things explode.
- smoyer 14y agoA must read article ... I've seen instances of each, but didn't really recognize them at the time (I'm also sure I haven't seen as many as Harj). I think I'll be more aware now. One little nag - It might not be a great time to use the analogy of an exploding pressure cooker.
- Harj 14y agoDidn't think of that, edited.
- edouard1234567 14y agoNice post. You give an example of un-even equity split when one founder had the idea, built the first site and got some traction. When do you stop being a co-founder and become a founding employee instead?
- USNetizen 14y agoThis is a spot-on post. I just recently broke up with a co-founder, mostly because of the uneven equity split like you stated (i.e. I was doing far more work and contributing far more expertise than what my equity showed). It was also due to a number of other factors, but that was primary. You hit the nail on the head with this. Great post.
- vnorby 14y agoThis can turn out not to be a problem if the startup hits some reasonable growth (growth is usually a solution to such ails as long as it continues). This is the important line in the article. Co-founder breakups probably happen more because the startup is not doing well, and not vice versa. I'm not sure if it makes sense to try and optimize for not running into co-founder problems as much as just optimizing for your company's success as normal. If your company is killing it, and you're a co-founder and you've got 10% and you want to be the CEO and your grad school dropout grace period is ending and you'd rather be working on technical problems, you're most likely going to stick it out regardless.
- _delirium 14y agoAnother way of thinking of it is that doing things to maximize success is far more important than what percentage of a hypothetical future success you get: 10% of billions is much better than 50% of millions, which is better than 90% of nothing. So really the percentage only matters insofar as its psychological impact might influence chances of success.
- jmtame 14y agoI hadn't thought about that perspective before. It's possible that many co-founders that wouldn't stick together are merely together because of the perceived success. Makes me even more grateful for co-founders that stick around even when things are bad. I don't think you can hack 100% of those situations where things look bad and make them look positive.
- robotjosh 14y agoI cofounded a startup that had all of these issues! I was the technical founder along with 2 non-technical founders, they offered me 10% equity to develop a hardware product. Seemed like a good deal, nearly finished my work over 6 months. Then we get into techstars and I have to shut down my independent contractor practice and come on full time with a shitty salary to keep my equity. Also, I had to redesign the product in a way that added several magnitudes more work. Another problem was that one of the non-technical cofounders started calling himself the CTO and started ordering me around on technical issues that I have an education in and over a decade of experience on. After demanding to be an equal partner and CTO, I was kicked out with no equity and no nothing.
- philwelch 14y agoIn the eyes of your cofounders, you weren't the cofounder. You were the mark.
- robotjosh 14y agoI may not have been considered a real cofounder but I was there at the first brainstorming and had all of the technical ideas. I had a lot more ideas since and am building another team to start the business again. Forced to bootstrap and then move to another city because all the investors here have invested in my original company!
- borski 14y agoBe careful and make sure you don't have a non-compete with the first company; if you do, check whether it's enforceable in your state. Sucks, dude.
- _delirium 14y agoIf they fired him, that often renders agreements unenforceable, or at least difficult to enforce outside of rare circumstances. Even in states which otherwise recognize noncompetes, courts tend to be hostile towards companies that try to enforce them against employees where the company themselves terminated the relationship (though not all states are equally hostile). For example, here is some pretty direct language from the Montana Supreme Court [1]: We agree that an employer normally lacks a legitimate business interest in a covenant when it chooses to end the employment relationship. [...] An employer needs no covenant to protect its business in these circumstances as the employer sits in the best position to protect itself simply by maintaining the employment relationship. [1] http://www.noncompetenews.com/file.axd?file=2011%2f12%2fWrigg+v+Junkermier.pdf http://www.noncompetenews.com/file.axd?file=2011%2f12%2fWrig...
- thomaspun 14y agoGreat post, Harj! I went thru two breakups. This struck me the most. You're doing yourself a disservice if you don't bring up what's on your mind. If you feel like you can't, then you should probably question whether you have the right co-founder. Startups are stressful and not talking about founder issue early up would only make it worse and slow you down even more. If anyone needs someone to chat about founder issues, feel free to reach me from my HN profile.
- gvr 14y agoI think doing proper personal due diligence up front can often help you avoid a breakup; it can also help avoid starting a company together in the first place if the fit isn't there, and make breakups easier should they happen. I wrote a blog post about my own experience doing this with the co-founders of Otelic. We have since lost one co-founder in a completely undramatic way - which I largely attribute to talking everything through in great detail prior to starting. Many times you're so excited about working together on a cool product that you neglect to do this; it's happened to me before and it's a costly mistake to make. http://gigaom.com/2012/01/26/the-questions-every-founder-must-ask-themselves/ http://gigaom.com/2012/01/26/the-questions-every-founder-mus...
- killermonkeys 14y agoALL these tensions exist in a startup. In the 3 I have been in, all these issues arose to varying degrees. In my second we went to the coffee shop on Monday morning and talked really openly about what we thought of last week. It was great. We were positive and honest people but nearly all issues including a serious equity issue were dealt with. It is you v. the world so treating you cofounder with suspicion is dangerous.