2 ms·
"and indeed, many past and present SCOTUS justices interpret the second half as barring any restrictions on gun ownership, including restrictions on felon owner
by hga 14y ago
"and indeed, many past and present SCOTUS justices interpret the second half as barring any restrictions on gun ownership, including restrictions on felon ownership."
Name one, let alone a few, who seriously put that forward. No right is absolute, just like the sainted freedom of speech famously doesn't extend to falsely shouting fire in a theater.
I also fail to see how the plain language restricts the first phrase to the goal as opposed to a goal. You think the Founders didn't believe in personal self-defense???
- gamblor956 14y agoScalia, Thomas, and Alito have voiced such opinions at some point in their careers. Scalia and Thomas made these comments at various Federalist Society gatherings. It's genuinely scary how they interpret the second amendment. I should have been clearer: the first phrase, as currently construed, is just a preamble, and as such has no legal weight. It lets us know what the Founders wanted the 2nd Amendment to accomplish, but it places no limitation on the actual grant of rights in the Amendment. That could change in the future with a different balance of justices, but that is unlikely to happen anytime soon.
- hga 14y agoCould you be a little more specific, and point me as specifics how they were "serious". Serious is District of Columbia v. Heller which Scalia wrote and was joined by the other two. The opinion acknowledged the traditional restrictions on gun possession. (My Google fu wasn't up to the task, e.g. "federalist society" Scalia OR Thomas felons possession gun or firearm, and limited in time to before Heller came out.) Also, were they talking about the serious traditional felonies, vs. the Three Felonies a Day (http://www.amazon.com/Three-Felonies-Day-Target-Innocent/dp/1594032556/ http://www.amazon.com/Three-Felonies-Day-Target-Innocent/dp/...) that as the book description puts it, "The average professional in this country wakes up in the morning, goes to work, comes home, eats dinner, and then goes to sleep, unaware that he or she has likely committed several federal crimes that day." ? As for the preamble, it was a sop (in modern political terms, a blessed compromise) thrown to those who preferred militias to regulars; they lost that argument in the Constitution (Article I, Section 8: "The Congress shall have Power ... To raise and support Armies...), in large part to the opinions of those like George Washington, who's professional opinion on this had particular weight. He was again the indispensable man, without his influence the 1787 Constitution would have been a non-starter, but that said, the Bill of Rights was a condition by the Anti-Federalists for accepting it. And in turn the Federalists were right when they said the Bill of Rights would just end up establishing high maximums to Federal power, as you acknowledge in your last sentence.