5 ms·
If you are going to try to account for the costs of "externalities" you also need to make at least the same effort to account for the benefits. How many people
by ams6110 14y ago
If you are going to try to account for the costs of "externalities" you also need to make at least the same effort to account for the benefits. How many people live longer, healthier lives due to the availability of cheap, abundant energy?
- spenrose 14y agoThe benefits are accounted for by GDP. You are right that GDP doesn't measure well-being directly, but if anything it is normally over- rather than under-credited for well being.
- rayiner 14y agoThe difference is that the benefits of electricity are generally priced in, either through taxes (for public lights and whatnot) or through utility bills. Here is an illustration. Would you rather live next to a coal plant or a solar farm? Would you rather get electricity from a coal plant at 2 dollars, or a solar plant at 3? Note how in the first case, the price of electricity is irrelevant because the external effect of the plant on you is the same no matter the price of electiricty. You can't decrease it by using less. In the second case, price is the only relevant consideration. The coal electricity doesn't have any positive benefit to you not accounted for in the price. "cheap" by definition can't be a positive externality because the definition of externality is costs and benefits not accounted for in price.
- robrenaud 14y agoI pay $50/month for electricity in my apartment. If I had no other options, I am pretty sure I'd be willing to pay something like $5000/month for that electricity. The economic surplus for electricity is enormous, the price comes no where near measuring the utility it provides.
- rayiner 14y agoWhat you're talking about is consumer surplus, which is the difference between the vslue of a product to you and the price you pay. It is not an externality, because you don't benefit unless you buy (at presumably a market price). We're not talking about the value of electricity, we're talking about the value of "cheap electricity." Attempting to assign a value to cheap electricity beyond its price is just double counting. There is no value to "cheap electricity" that isn't accounted for in the price and therefore it's not a positive externality. Put another way, the value you get from one unit of electricity is the same no matter whether it comes from coal or wind power. Any difference between the two is merely the incremental benefit of getting it at a cheaper price, which is entirely accounted for by the price.
- crusso 14y agobenefits of electricity are generally priced in The societal benefits of cheap electricity are no more "priced in" than the negative environmental externalities of coal use. You can't put a benefits dollar value to society on all the women in the work force who would otherwise be preparing a lot more meals from scratch. You can't put a benefits dollar value to society on the productivity gains from all the people who would have died of childhood diseases that we have cures for thanks to western medicine. You're obviously in favor of accounting for one factor in the cost/benefit analysis of coal power and ignoring the others. I think it's hubris and folly to do so.
- rayiner 14y agoThe exercise here is accounting for costs and benefits external to the power producer/consumer transaction. Any costs and benefits arising from the transaction are factored into the price of electricity. If electricity allows women to participate in the work force instead of making meals from scratch, that presumably increases demand for electricity, which affects the price. In theory, the benefits that stem from people having electrical service should be reflected in the price of that service. Accounting for externalized costs is a wholly different exercise. It's an accounting of the costs that do not arise out of the producer/consumer transaction and thus cannot affect the price of electricity through bargaining. Health costs of coal are one such cost. People bear that cost whether or not they even have electric service, and their level of usage does not affect the level of the costs they incur. This kind of cost is not priced into the price of electricity from coal. The benefit that would be relevant in this accounting is a benefit from electricity that you get whether or not you directly or indirectly pay for electricity. Your wife being able to work is not such a benefit--you only get that benefit if you pay for electricity. Note the wiggle word both you and the poster above use: "cheap electricity" not just "electricity." It's not "electricity versus no electricity" its "cheap electricity versus more expensive electricity." The benefits from cheaper versus more expensive electricity are entirely internal to the producer/consumer relationship an are thus priced in to the price of electricity. They're not the same as external environmental costs which are not priced in to the price of electricity.
- crusso 14y ago
- gamblor956 14y agoExternalities are economic items that are not reflected in the market price of a good or service. Thus, there are both negative and positive externalities. A proper discussion of externalities discuss both types, however, positive externalities are usually factored into the cost of goods or services relatively easily and quickly, and so are generally not ripe for discussion in mature markets.