5 ms·
Things that Americans find incomprehensible about the UK
- pointyhatuk 14y agoWe have proper beer in the UK :)
- dcminter 14y agoWhile we don't have a written constitution we are signatories to the European Convention on Human Rights enacted under law in the UK as the Human Rights Act. That's amounts to the same thing for many purposes. Couldn't agree more about the problems with freedom of expression in the UK. Something the US should be proud of in comparison.
- talkingquickly 14y agoI'd also stress that not having a written constitution is totally different to not having a constitution. More accurately the UK doesn't have a codified (single reference document) constitution but does have strong constitutional case law.
- TamDenholm 14y agoPretty interesting and i agree with all the points. One thing about the monarchy is the argument that they cost a lot. CGP Grey did a video explaining the true cost of the monarchy. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhyYgnhhKFw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhyYgnhhKFw Also, check out his channel, he does loads of amazing videos. http://www.youtube.com/user/CGPGrey/videos http://www.youtube.com/user/CGPGrey/videos
- junto 14y agoI'm ambivalent towards our Royal Family, but god damn this man makes a good argument for them!
- TamDenholm 14y agoYep, i'm of the same opinion. Because of this i now think they're worth keeping, however i'd like to see all the Royal cling'ons booted, the cousins and third uncles etc etc.
- citricsquid 14y agoFirst, jwerpy is right to point out the ubiquity of surveillance, not only in London but in most British cities. Part myth, part over reaction. The majority of CCTV in the UK is privately owned (92%) and the government owned is relatively small in number: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_surveillance#United_Kingdom http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_surveillance#United_Kingdo...
- petercooper 14y agoThis is one of the interesting things about CCTV in the UK. Not only is it owned by a myriad of entities but it's monitored by a myriad of entities too. Other than national networks for things like ANPR (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Police-enforced_ANPR_in_the_UK http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Police-enforced_ANPR_in_the_UK) tying together people's movements through a town, into a nightclub, out onto a motorway, etc, would involve working with numerous organisations, including the local council, the owner of the nightclub, the county council, etc. This lack of cohesion means that, currently, intrusions into privacy are hard to automate and such footage can only be collected together into a complete narrative with some serious effort on the part of the police. (Bias disclaimer: I'm very much pro CCTV.)
- lucaspiller 14y ago> would involve working with numerous organisations To elaborate: Which means about six months of red tape just to find which car park the guy went to after he left the club. (Also pro-CCTV)
- nicholassmith 14y agoI'd be pro CCTV but it often seems an expensive boondoggle as the net effect is pretty slim.
- Osmium 14y agoAs long as the government isn't paying for it, then what's the problem? Private CCTV is great: it's difficult to abuse by the government for mass surveillance, but can be subpoenaed after a crime's been committed so we still get the benefit in that regard, and at no cost to the tax payer.
- jules 14y agoOne of the things I find incomprehensible is the clothes and makeup that a minority of young girls are wearing that from my perspective makes them look like tiny 20 year olds that are planning to go to a nightclub. Or do I remember incorrectly and is that an American phenomenon?
- simonh 14y agoI have two young daughters and my mother is always on about this. It's her contention that most of the young girls that end up abducted and murdered were inappropriately dressed, and that this attracts sexual predators, so she's keen that our girls are dressed well. Honestly, since she pointed this out and I started paying attention to descriptions of what victims of this kind of crime were wearing, I have to say she's got a point. Not to blame anybody but the perpetrator, of course.
- smtddr 14y agoBe careful there, that logic doesn't hold for a lot of things. It might not be the clothes per se, so much as the activity and/or location they were at and the clothes just happened to be appropriate for the activity. Example: Maybe girls are attacked at nightclubs a lot. You can't blame the clothes. The reason is probably because nightclubs are usually open at night. And(at least in the bay area) some of the cooler nightclubs for younger people are in sorta-questionable locations in terms of safety. And finally, if you're a young lady going to a nightclub you're probably going to dress to look attractive. The whole nightclub environment, young ladies dress up attractively... guys being guys(TM)... add alcohol... shady-looking people wandering about directly outside the nightclub... a lot of things to blame there, but clothes wouldn't be top of the list.
- simonh 14y agoOh sure, you're quite right. I'm not really making any statistical clams. Just an anecdote. You can't legislate about appropriate clothing for young women, this isn't a political issue it's a matter of private choice.
- 14y ago
- tomp 14y agoHow about the ancient technology of the separate cold/boiling hot water pipes? I'm not an american, but that's the most odd thing I find about the UK.
- arethuza 14y agoHowever, we get to laugh at your wildly under engineered electrical plugs. [And yes, I know that we have crazy plugs because of our strange ways of wiring up houses. However, of all the places I've been the US has by far the worst plugs.]
- AndrewDucker 14y agoHow do Americans do that? If you want to get both hot and cold water to somewhere?
- felxh 14y agoI think he is talking about the separate water taps/faucets for hot and cold water instead of separate pipes
- lucaspiller 14y agoThat seems to be more a Britain vs everywhere else thing. All my European friends always have a go at me about that.
- junto 14y agoI second this. Living in Germany I am blessed with the best of German water heating technology, which includes mixer taps (faucets). Whenever I go back to the UK to visit family, I end up scolding myself on the hot tap. My theory is that Brits either don't wash their hands, or if they do, they have a limited amount of time before the hot tap becomes too hot!
- summerdown2 14y ago
- ColinWright 14y agoSister post: Things that Brits find incomprehensible about the USA http://reprog.wordpress.com/2013/04/18/things-that-brits-find-incomprehensible-about-the-usa/ http://reprog.wordpress.com/2013/04/18/things-that-brits-fin...
- simonh 14y agoCheer-leading I can at least understand. Even if it might be inadvisable due to the sexualization issue, you can fully understand why young women want to do it and it's a lot of fun for everyone involved. The guns and healthcare issues have me stumped though. As a conservative voting Brit, Thatcherite and Reagan admirer, you'd think I would be a natural republican sympathiser. I listen to 'right wing' american naratives on these issues and they just make no sense to me at all. I understand the history behind how America got into the situation it's in with these issues, but the justifications for blocking credible reform are just incomprehensible to me.
- protomyth 14y agoWhy would we want to "reform" gun laws when the crime statistics (you know, the facts I hope politicians use to make laws) show a continued decrease? The media's continued harping is not the actual problem. We have 15 categories of killers of American's that we are not addressing, never mind the damn budget, while we are doing something foolish in the Senate. It is so foolish because it would not have stopped anything that actually happened. If we spent the same political capital on cancer and heart disease, we would save more lives. Beyond actual limited government conservatives basic belief system, a lot of people have experience with actual government run health care and have found it lacking (google "don't get sick after june" for the IHS side). Plus the massive bill no one read (with so many things set to be decided by the bureaucracy in rule making and RFPs[1]). If the government had passed a bill that said, people on welfare would be added to the government employee's health care plan or perhaps some looking at what makes medical costs so high, conservatives would have supported it. I would have been overjoyed with some basic tort reform, more medical scholarships(2), better medical savings account rules, and perhaps a government insurance program like the flood insurance for catastrophes that pays 100% after something like 50K(3). -- 1) yes, I read the whole bill to determine what I would have to change in my life 2) this part is going to be an actual concern given the required number of workers in the coming years 3) this would have also made normal insurance cheaper given a cap on max outlay for a person
- petercooper 14y agoWyrd also suggests that anti-intellectualism may be less ubiquitous and pervasive in Britain than in America. I'd find it hard to call on anti-intellectualism but anti-exceptionalism is certainly a lot stronger in the UK than the US. It even has a special name, "tall poppy syndrome": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tall_poppy_syndrome http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tall_poppy_syndrome
- arethuza 14y agoWorth noting that, as with pretty much everything in the UK that varies hugely depending on social class and location - it is (or at least was) amazingly bad in traditional urban working class areas. Where/when I grew up (a fishing port) exceptionalism was pretty strongly celebrated and everyone knew and admired the most succesful skippers.
- arethuza 14y agoWorth noting that the "libel" laws are not a UK-wide thing.
- jasonkester 14y agoThe thing that I notice most as an American living in England is the overwhelming amount of bureaucracy in every aspect of life here, and how it's just taken in stride as though nothing can be done about it. You go to the swimming pool and try to pay your 3 pounds to go swimming, but they can't give you the blue armband for the 10:00 session because it's only 9:40, but they can give you the yellow armband for the 9:00 session, but that means you'll have to get out of the pool when the 9:00 session ends, but you're free to go upstairs and have a cup of tea until 9:55. Me: "But that's insane. The pool is open all day" Woman: [look of non-understanding, since this is how they've done things for 30 years therefore it is unquestionably correct, and nobody has ever complained before, and certainly one should know not to come to the swimming pool near the end of the hour, and who wouldn't welcome the opportunity to have a nice cup of tea?] Me: OK, I'll take the armband for the 9:00 session, and keep 3 extra pounds in my trunks in case somebody asks me to leave in ten minutes so that I can walk back here and pay you again then. Repeat that experience for every interaction with every business or government entity you deal with ever. You just want to give up and never leave the house. Until the internet goes down and you have to deal with British Telecom, at which point you start looking for property in France.
- colinhowe 14y agoThis is wildly different from place to place... which is almost sadder. Some places have so little bureaucracy it's amazing. Some places are a mess of incompetency. In my experience, bureaucracy is a sign of lots of incompetency to follow.
- arethuza 14y agoI haven't encounted a swimming pool like that in the last 30 years, but I give you British Telecom customer service - it is truly awful. However, simple fix that for - don't use BT as an ISP - I don't know where you are but we have about 20 to choose from.
- hackerboos 14y agoMy recent experience trying to get BT Infinity installed... 1. Initially called and asked for BT Infinity and was promptly told it wasn't yet available on our street. I therefore opted for BT Total (ADSL). All installed no problems. 2. Checked the website a month later. Checker tells me that Infinity is available. I call BT, make the appointment and wait. 3. BT engineer turns up and starts installation. He then goes off to the cab and returns quickly telling me that the cab they have me listed on is wrong. I'm registered as using is about 2 miles away. Far away from this cab. BT engineer tells me he will inform "head office" so they can sort it and get Infinity installed. 4. BT make a new appointment and another engineer is sent out who repeats the same steps as above because nobody has told him and it hasn't been fixed. Engineer leaves. No Infinity. 5. I get a SMS message asking me to rebook my appointment and after calling I talk with a operator who is ready to put me through the whole process again until I protest asking to speak with somebody who knows more. I get on the phone to this person who tells me that Infinity is not available where I live. I'm told to check back in a few months but get this...I'll have to rebook the appointment and get a engineer out before I find out if it's actually available. WTF...
- ry0ohki 14y agoThe only thing I always find shocking in the UK is how racist speech is actually illegal, like serve jail time illegal. They will find surveillance of someone making a racist gesture at a football match or something on Twitter, hunt them down, and prosecute them. I'm assuming there are other limits to speech, but since anyone can say any crazy thing here and not be in danger of jail time, it's interesting to me.
- hackerboos 14y agoNevermind racist speech. You can be jailed for telling distasteful jokes on Facebook... http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2012/oct/08/april-jones-matthew-woods-jailed http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2012/oct/08/april-jones-matthew...
- thisone 14y agoIf by here you mean the US, there are still laws against incitement which could be dragged out depending on the circumstances.
- jongold 14y agoHow about our sane gun control laws and our politicians who—while a bit rubbish—aren't being paid hundreds of millions of $ by BigCorp™ to go against the people?
- dantheman 14y agoSane gun control - you mean the near impossibility to own a gun? How is that sane?
- jongold 14y agoI'm a web designer not a terrorist - why would I want to own a gun?!
- moistgorilla 14y agoWait, so everyone that wants to own a gun is a terrorist? Please, if you want to live in a nanny state I don't mind but don't act like it's any better.
- simonh 14y agoHow bad does it need to be? http://data.huffingtonpost.com/2013/03/gun-deaths http://data.huffingtonpost.com/2013/03/gun-deaths Go on, click on that next button and read some of those names. I dare you. I double dare you!
- moistgorilla 14y agoYou are implying that this is a gun problem and not a sociological problem.
- simonh 14y agoMaybe that is partly the case. For the sake of argument lets say for a moment that it is at it's root a sociological problem. If you know you have this sociological problem where thousands of people are killed using guns on almost a monthly basis, why are you so insistent that these guns must be available to allow that to happen? Why insist that this 'sociological problem' of mass killing be allowed to express itself using as powerful and efficient a means as possible? Are you really suggesting that if the guns went away, that all these thousands of people would all still be killed by machettes or axes or something instead? If other means of killing are just as efficient, why protect your home with a gun? Why not use a machette or an axe? And while we're on this subject, what's with the ban on federally funded research into a problem that's leading to so many deaths? How is that anything other than red handed evidence of the gun lobby making it perfectly clear they're not interested in evidence, or rational debate, or honest discourse, or how many people die on a daily basis so that they can hold on to their favourite toys. Why not just say that the death toll in blood is to an acceptable price they are willing in full conscience to pay so that they can keep hold of their guns? All I see is a pretence at debate. A paper thin fig leaf of argument. Hungerford in 1987, therefore British gun laws have no effect on rates of gun violence. No gun shops in Chicago, therefore banning gun sales nationally can have no effect rates of gun ownership or violence. Maybe it's a sociological problem - oh, well that's all right then. Lets just wash our hands of the whole problem and think about something else. Until the next horrific mass shooting. Meanwhile the body count nationally is quietly rising day, by day, by day.
- zalew 14y ago> I think the American approach to enjoying sport is much better than ours. in Poland we call it 'picnic'. > That is very strange to me; but it’s far from being a characteristically British problem, and is more pan-European. it's more pan-almost-everywhere-except-usa. take f.ex. football violence in South America, in Europe we at least don't spray visitor team fans buses with uzis. throwing stones and knives onto the guests sector is also less popular than in, say, Turkey.
- arethuza 14y agoThere were letter bombs sent to a manager of Celtic: http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2011/apr/20/celtic-parcel-bomb-neil-lennon http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2011/apr/20/celtic-parcel-bomb-... The sectarian element to football (and many other things) in parts of Scotland is bizarre - which football team you support (assuming you support any team - I don't) can be a hugely important indicator in many contexts. [NB My recently acquired interest in watching team sports only extends as far as rugby - where the violence is kept on the pitch].
- zalew 14y agoWell, I don't know about the Scottish scene, but such divisions often have a historical political and cultural background. In Poland many football rivalries are dated around the communism times, but some date up to the beginnings of the 20th century, f.ex. Krakow's holy war.
- arethuza 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sectarianism_in_Glasgow http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sectarianism_in_Glasgow
- zalew 14y agotx. yeah, now I remember this event with our goalkeeper http://www.soccernews.com/boruc-fined-over-rangers-gesture/9377/ http://www.soccernews.com/boruc-fined-over-rangers-gesture/9...
- kalleboo 14y ago> It’s a surprise to me that so many people see the BBC as such an oddity. I know it’s an unusual way to finance broadcasting It's not unusual at all: "Whilst TV licensing is rare in the Americas, half of the countries of Asia and Africa, and two-thirds of the countries in Europe use television licences to fund public television" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Television_licence http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Television_licence
- ams6110 14y agoHere (US) we just take the money from you whether you have a television or not.
- youngerdryas 14y agoIs this a complaint against PBS? They are as close as we get to the BBC and they are excellent, I don't watch anything else except Netflix and sports. Commercials are really mind numbing.
- fossuser 14y agoThis article seems way off point for hacker news (better fit for reddit) - and even if you were to make the stretch that it fit in the intellectual curiosity category, it's a little weak on that too.
- shaydoc 14y agoBureaucracy is rife, particularly in Northern Ireland ( which is a part of the UK ), in fact the entire economy is built on Bureaucracy. Government departments have been the biggest employer here. Some of the bureaucratic things they do is just absurd. For example, I have to purchase annual road tax for my car. Usually its no probs, you can phone a call center and pay over the phone after they do some "background checks". I phoned to renew as usual yesterday, but was told they could not give me road tax because my car is due for an MOT (road worthiness test) in May. Now my current MOT is valid until 30th April, but because they can't predict whether it will pass or fail, they won't sell me my road tax renewal (or let me pay tax to them for the upkeep of the roads :-o )...which they sold me last year no problem with similar circumstances, seems they have just added a little more red tape to be sure :-)... I could list several other interesting bureaucratic nuances, in fact you could probably write a book on it....
- RyanMcGreal 14y ago> The progressive erosion of freedom that the last two points represent arises from a yet more fundamental issue which I’m surprised no-one picked up on: we have no (written) constitution. The Canadian legal system is derived closely from the British system (except in Quebec, where civil law follows the Justinian tradition). The major difference is the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which was ratified 31 years ago. At the time, there was a furore in England over the fact that the Charter would supersede statutes (which, in turn, supersede common law). Some lawmakers considered it unconscionable that the courts could strike down a law for violating the Charter. Apparently the fact that Canada wanted to patriate its Constitution almost triggered a constitutional crisis in England. Since then, Canadian courts have indeed struck down a number of laws, including restrictions on access to abortion, restrictions on religious expression and dress, denial of collective bargaining rights, prohibitions on same sex marriage, and the right of convicted prisoners to vote. The Charter enshrines human rights protection and equality for women, minorities and other vulnerable Canadians - including lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender Canadians, through court decisions that extended the list of prohibited grounds for discrimination in Section 15. The sections on legal rights have also driven changes to the way police services operate, strengthening protections for personal privacy, freedom from unreasonable or arbitrary detainment and seizure, and due process on arrest. In the years since the Charter was signed, legislatures still have the right to pass laws - but thanks to the Charter, those laws must be so constructed that they do not curtail our rights and freedoms. Where they do, courts now have the power to strike them down. I don't think I would want to live in a system where legislators were not bound by a charter of rights and freedoms to ensure that statutes do not violate them.