3 ms·
By definition these 10,000 founders wouldn't be taking jobs from Americans "But, but, but: their companies will compete with and disrupt established American b
by gojomo 18y ago
By definition these 10,000 founders wouldn't be taking jobs from Americans
"But, but, but: their companies will compete with and disrupt established American businesses, destroying American jobs! Why, a 4-foreigner web news or classified startup could put dozens of (unionized, citizen, voter) newspaper employees out of work!"
Of course I don't believe this is true, nor would it even be a good reason to restrict entry if it were true. (Better to have the new disruptive companies here, than elsewhere.) But that's the sort of deranged logic used against broader immigration. The neat trick of limiting the visas to those starting companies will only help a little against anti-immigrant emotions.
They wouldn't all grow as big as Google, but out of 2500 some would come close.
I suspect close-to-Google-scale successes come more like 1-in-100,000-tries than 1-in-2500. There's a tendency to see every startup as a potential little Google -- we could call this 'Google Goggles'. But Google is one-of-a-kind, and it shouldn't require even one success of that scale to make the case for broader immigration.
For example, shouldn't these visas be available to immigrants whose 'startup' is a donut shop, nail salon, or bodega?
(I also suspect such a program could be easily gamed... but as I'd like to see more immigration of anyone ambitious, I suppose that's a feature not a bug.)