4 ms·
As much as I love both Penn & Teller and Bullshit I don't think any of the so called 'experiments' they do deserve the prefix 'science' or have any validity. T
by dagw 14y ago
As much as I love both Penn & Teller and Bullshit I don't think any of the so called 'experiments' they do deserve the prefix 'science' or have any validity. Their goal is to provide entertaining polemics, not to do any sort of hypothesis testing or to put forward anything that might challenge their preconceived notion.
- Scaevolus 14y agoParticularly bad was their episode where they claimed that it's impossible to lose weight.
- eridius 14y agoWhat episode was that? I watched every single episode they aired, and I don't remember any of them claiming that it was impossible to lose weight.
- Scaevolus 14y agohttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dCYvc9F838E http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dCYvc9F838E
- eridius 14y agoI think you're grossly misrepresenting what they said. They didn't say you can't lose weight. They said that genetics dictates your general body shape, and that you're never going to end up looking like Adonis no matter how much you work out. You can certainly lose weight, get yourself healthier, and look better. But, as they said at the end of the video, you're probably not going to end up looking quite as good as you'd hoped, and it won't happen as fast as you hoped.
- eridius 14y agoOf course. I called it a "Bullsh*t! science experiment" because that's what they called it. The word "bullshit" was part of the name, which hopefully gives a clue that it's not actually scientific.