2 ms·
Nobody is saying that government isn't good at some things that the private sector is not good at. You are changing the argument. Your statement was that we owe
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
Nobody is saying that government isn't good at some things that the private sector is not good at. You are changing the argument. Your statement was that we owe the government "A Good Chunk" for some "things" that cause people to be rich. All of these things were "built on the backs of people paying significantly higher taxes than our selfish generation pays today" I pointed out that your examples are examples of private sector and government cooperation at best, and government mucking around at worst.
The private sector is NOT good at some things. Point taken and agreed. However, we have rich people and private sector profitable work all over the globe, in all sorts of governmental conditions. We have businesses that operate without roads or electricity, businesses that work under onerous governmental regulations and no regulations at all. Your thesis -- that rich folks owe the government "a good chunk" is not supported by your examples. Furthermore, countless counter-examples exist. You just can't wave your arms around and say "infrastructure" a bunch of times and make an argument. Infrastructure is not a prerequisite for people to get rich. Even if it was, people should not be indebted to nations for things that their great grandparents did -- the social contract is about here and now, not 50 years ago. Rich people are in no way morally indebted, at least as far as I can tell.
Your case is thus: Infrastructure helps people get rich. Rich people live in a environment with infrastructure. The government is the sole provider of said infrastructure. Therefore, rich people owe the government more.
If I'm not understanding please correct me, but you're not making any sense at all to me. It sounds like just a slogan you're repeating over and over. I'm going to bow out unless you have something truly useful. It's beginning to sound like we're talking past each other.