3 ms·
We've been living in different universes then. With NT4 they moved graphics drivers into the kernel, and these were crashing often. NT3.5 was stable in this re
by beagle3 14y ago
We've been living in different universes then.
With NT4 they moved graphics drivers into the kernel, and these were crashing often. NT3.5 was stable in this regard, although dog slow.
They also added the I/O fastpath in NT4, to combat dog slowness -- and as a result of not thinking hard enough about that, killed the ability to unload storage drivers, which actually mattered to me.
And that's just the design decisions - the implementatin was also abysmal; there were remote exploits published daily in those days, and only half of them were through IE (which had no reason to be bundled into the OS except for MS world domination plans, but as it was and was unremovable, it was a convenient attack vector.
And don't get me started on concurrency bugs that I reported to MS on NT4 and as of Server 2003 were not yet fixed.
- pjmlp 14y ago> We've been living in different universes then. Well, I was doing multi-platform C development across all major commercial UNIX vendors and NT on those days, what about you? > With NT4 they moved graphics drivers into the kernel, and these were crashing often. NT3.5 was stable in this regard, although dog slow. At least they did work, not the same could be said about Linux and BSD distributions with their open source drivers 10 years ago. > And that's just the design decisions - the implementatin was also abysmal; there were remote exploits published daily in those days, and only half of them were through IE (which had no reason to be bundled into the OS except for MS world domination plans, but as it was and was unremovable, it was a convenient attack vector. Windows problems with security were no different than any other desktop operating system before it. As for being the beloved target for hacking, it happens with every system they see value into cracking, as the increase in mobile malware shows. > And don't get me started on concurrency bugs that I reported to MS on NT4 and as of Server 2003 were not yet fixed. Are every single bug fixes you report to open source projects fixed?
- cgh 14y ago> Well, I was doing multi-platform C development across all major commercial UNIX vendors and NT on those days, what about you? HP-UX and AIX for me, and NT (my colleagues also worked on Netware, but I wasn't involved with it). My experiences are different than yours: we had near-daily BSODs and the system was generally regarded as a bit of a joke. We worked closely with MS back then (late '90s) and I met some of the kernel team, who told me about the farce of pushing GDI into the kernel - the worst mistake they ever made in terms of stability, though usability-wise it was great. The Windows UI was silky smooth on the limited hardware of the time. But yeah, in my experience NT defenders were few and far between back then.
- beagle3 14y ago> Well, I was doing multi-platform C development across all major commercial UNIX vendors and NT on those days, what about you? Various Unixes, NT and NetWare 4-6. NetWare was, by far, the ugliest. But NT was really, really bad. > At least they did work, not the same could be said about Linux and BSD distributions with their open source drivers 10 years ago. I've been running a Linux desktop on and off since 1994, (last used anything else in 2005) and never had a problem getting X to work. And it wasn't until my latest Lenovo on Ubuntu 10.10 that I had a single crash because of a display driver. > Windows problems with security were no different than any other desktop operating system before it. Except NT4 was supposedly a server OS. It was bearable as a desktop OS thanks to moving GDI into the kernel, but just barely. > As for being the beloved target for hacking, it happens with every system they see value into cracking, as the increase in mobile malware shows. This is so wrong I won't even try to correct you. > Are every single bug fixes you report to open source projects fixed? About 10 for each one I report to a closed source project, and that's been the experience of everyone I know.