2 ms·
Right. A thorough functional spec would eliminate the "magic" problem and introduce another concern: management. Having the perfect spec and the right talent
by edw519 18y ago
Right. A thorough functional spec would eliminate the "magic" problem and introduce another concern: management. Having the perfect spec and the right talent guarantees nothing. You must still manage every single step of the dev process. Needless to say, this is non-trivial. OP glossed over this part.
I would go even a step further. I think the "management of talent" concern is so non-trivial that, in many cases, it simply doesn't work. The world has plenty of people with the scars to prove this.
For a tech start-up, I'd put a team of quality hackers on the most critical path. Something the rest of the world conveniently seems to forget.
- Alex3917 18y ago"Having the perfect spec and the right talent guarantees nothing. You must still manage every single step of the dev process." You shouldn't have to. Squidoo was completely outsourced. The deal with them was once they handed over the spec the company wasn't allowed to challenge anything. If they had a question about what something meant they were allowed to ask, but that was it. Other than that any communication was forbidden. Because of this the project was done early and under budget. And it seems to have worked; Squidoo is one of the top 300 sites with 91% growth last year.
- edw519 18y ago"You shouldn't have to." Perfect corporate tombstone material. You're right. You shouldn't have to. But you do. Squidoo is the rare exception. For every Squidoo, there are hundreds of companies whose projects failed miserably because someone dropped the ball somewhere. The programming is often the easiest part of a big dev effort. People often overlook the specification, design, project management, testing, scaling, security, etc., etc., etc. In the theoretical world (and mainstream media), these things somehow take care of themselves. In the real world, we know better.