3 ms·
"If you have a 1% chance of destroying the world, you're pretty much going to want to avoid taking that chance in almost every case according to a cost/benefit
by Someone 14y ago
"If you have a 1% chance of destroying the world, you're pretty much going to want to avoid taking that chance in almost every case according to a cost/benefit analysis"
No, you aren't. If that 1% chance is balanced by a 99% chance to increase the world's wealth by 2%, the expected gain is .98%, so anyone using pure expected cost/expected benefit analysis would give the go ahead if the cost of this were, say 0.5%.
The problem, I think, is that those statistical calculations do not handle the case where there are outcomes that imply that one cannot repeat the game often enough to filter out statistical variations. In that sense, it is related to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martingale_(betting_system) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martingale_(betting_system): Yes, you can beat roulette, if (and that is a big IF) you don't go broke in the process.
- AnthonyMouse 14y ago>No, you aren't. If that 1% chance is balanced by a 99% chance to increase the world's wealth by 2%, the expected gain is .98%, so anyone using pure expected cost/expected benefit analysis would give the go ahead if the cost of this were, say 0.5%. If you could actually improve the world by 2% in doing that, maybe you should -- but don't discount what that would mean. You're not talking about a 2% increase in GDP. GDP measures commerce per year, we're talking about everything, forever. You have to account not only for the loss of the economy, but the loss of human life, family, humanity itself and all future endeavors of any nature by anyone. And if the alternative is a gain rather than a competing loss, you have to put a value on our desire to avoid losses as being greater than our desire to make gains. If you still think you can create a gain that would balance that loss, let's hear it. And the fact is that we do as a factual matter make decisions like that. We built nuclear weapons because the risk of blowing up the world was calculated as being a better choice than the risk of fascism taking over. We grow genetically modified food because the ability to feed the population is deemed more important than the risks it entails. You can dispute decisions like these, but then you're just disputing the value we've placed on each alternative, not the process of comparing relative values in order to make the choice. The idea that some risks are insufferable doesn't break economics, it just changes valuations. You have to consider both the consequence and the probability. Otherwise the world should pay me the billion dollars, because there is some risk that the alternative will be world-ending. People object to putting a number on things like life and love, but there is no avoiding it. At the end of the day you have to make decisions. You have to weigh love against safety against money and make a choice.