4 ms·
My views can be summed up thusly: Bitcoin is badly suited to be a currency because deflation is BAD Bitcoin is badly suited to be a payment system because
by Nursie 14y ago
My views can be summed up thusly:
Bitcoin is badly suited to be a currency because deflation is BAD
Bitcoin is badly suited to be a payment system because chargeback is GOOD
Basically. I can go into detail if you like but I'm sure everyone's heard it before. I expect many bitcoin enthusiasts disagree.
- StavrosK 14y agoAh, I see. I agree with the deflation part, but the chargeback part is just one downside. There are also many upsides, it's exactly like cash. There's nothing preventing escrow services from popping up, like credit card companies do now for cash.
- Nursie 14y agoSure, sure, it is like cash, which is why I don't think it's a great online payment system. By the time you add in escrow services (which you have to trust and will likely want fees) and other layers... well we already have credit cards and I like the legal and conventional consumer protections provided by them. I can see the use-case for stuff like wire-transfers, though TBH there are already good, low-fee services for that too. --EDIT-- obviously there is a silk-road use case too! Though I still think there must be a better scheme waiting in the wings or even just lurking in someone's brain, that expresses crypto-currency differently and manages to balance scarcity without deflation, or even just weights the allocation curve such that early adopters don't stand to become a new aristocracy if it takes off.
- maxerickson 14y agoIt's funny, if some big player were interested in there being a pseudonymous transaction system with low fees, they could step in as a centralized exchange, putting their reputation up in place of all the issues around trust and bootstrapping and currency risk. That is, Wally-bucks could operate on an open blockchain and still be exchangeable at your local Walmart at fixed rates.
- gluczywo 14y agoAny facts to support these claims? As a counterargument: Deflation can solve number of problems like eliminate the debt spiral, restrain evergrowing unproductive governments, restore the right to have savings for people and protect their future. Currently with centrally controlled inflation we are deprived of this fundamental right. This is from the merchant perspective: because of chargebacks my customers pay about 7% more for the service. 7% is to compensate direct cost of chargebacks, I don't count my time and cost of software I had to write to reduce fraud. The most painful however is that chargebacks are horribly immoral - the extra percent we all pay for everything goes to thieves who abuse the system.
- Nursie 14y agoRestore the right to have savings? What are you on? In a deflationary economy, holding cash (unproductive) enriches you off the back of the productive economy. It also values work yesterday more highly than work today, favours entrenched interests over newcomers etc etc. It's a great recipe for stagnation. Not to mention that, were it to go country-scale, the way BTC were allocated quickly at the beginning would create a new aristocracy that the rest of society (and future generations) could never aspire to joining. And chargebacks are not immoral. They are a fundamental part of the structure of trust built around ecommerce. Without that facility I would never trust a small vendor like yourself and you would be making $0
- gluczywo 14y ago"In a deflationary economy, holding cash (unproductive) enriches you off the back of the productive economy" It's a common misunderstanding. People confuse money with wealth. Holding cash does not enrich anyone. Money is useless if you can't spend it, so at some point hoarders will say: enough, it's time to use some life. At the end of the day, money is just numbers with the potential to convert it to comfortable life. My selfish side says: I wish more hoarders who collect numbers and don't convert it, so they don't use real world resources. They leave more for me! "values work yesterday more highly than work today" What's wrong with that? You can also say: values work today more highly than work tomorrow Most genuine credit card users are not aware of chargeback possibility and they rely on vendor reputation anyway. I wish you have to handle credit card payments so you realize how big burden it is and how it cripples the whole economy.
- leoedin 14y agoI agree with the first point, but the second is fairly redundant. Bitcoin is a value transfer system much as the banks have value transfer systems in place between accounts. Chargeback on a credit card is implemented at a higher level, based on a system of trust between the card processors and banks. There's nothing stopping you implementing an escrow service on top bitcoin or a similar irreversible cryptocurrency which is functionally identical to the current credit card system. It requires users to trust you, but then so does the current credit card system.