3 ms·
I'm curious as to your reasoning here. You seem to be saying that the explanation of need somehow changes the answer someone would give. So if you robbed a ban
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
I'm curious as to your reasoning here. You seem to be saying that the explanation of need somehow changes the answer someone would give.
So if you robbed a bank because you needed the money, that would be different than if you robbed it because you hate bankers?
- CWuestefeld 18y agoNo, sorry, that's not what I meant to suggest at all -- I'm far from a moral relativist! My point was that absent any further discussion, a "yes" answer to the question seems to imply that we should take more money from the rich simply because it's there. I imagine some Congresscritters saying "oh cool, we got another billionaire; let's see if we can find something else to spend this guy's money on". Contrast this with "we've got a war on our hands, and need to pay for our defenses somehow; if we absolutely must have that money, perhaps it should come from the rich". (note that I'm not supporting, or even referring to, any particular war here, this is a thought experiment) I personally do not believe that having a need makes it OK. But framing the question next to a need changes the nature of the question. As it was stated, it appears to be purely envy and class warfare; with a balancing need in the equation it changes to the philosophical question of moral relativism -- which I disagree with, but it is a defensible position.