4 ms·
There is a similar argument against AI. That a computer can't "feel" or experience any of the sensations we do. If you type 'emotional_state = "happy"', does th
by Houshalter 14y ago
There is a similar argument against AI. That a computer can't "feel" or experience any of the sensations we do. If you type 'emotional_state = "happy"', does that mean your computer feels happiness? Even if you have a complex simulation of neurons, if you zoom in, all you will see is little electrons bouncing through various logic gates and ending up in some kind of pattern.
But the thing is, the exact same thing is true for your brain too! If you zoom in on your brain you will find nothing more than electrical impulses and neurons that strengthen or weaken their connection to other neurons. If the neurons were suddenly replaced with little computers that performed exactly the same, you wouldn't feel any different. You would still experience emotions and feel sensations and have no idea any parts had been swapped under the hood, unless you looked.
I don't know why but this idea is confusing to me. This XKCD http://xkcd.com/505/ http://xkcd.com/505/ is a good example. My consciousness could be a bunch of static rocks and a man placing new rows based on simple rules. I find this thought disturbing, but there isn't anything fundamentally different between that, a computer simulation, and a world of a bunch of atoms hitting each other, following simple physical laws.
Different beings could exist in all three universes. And each would feel emotions and sensations and all that. And each would argue about how beings just like them in the other universes "don't really exist" like they do.
So how is this different from a character in a novel or a variable in a computer set to "happy"? I honestly don't know. The character in a book is completely static. Whatever is written in the pages, it isn't changing, it isn't taking input and producing output. But the rows of rocks are static too after all. They don't take any input from the outside world either. They change over a dimension of space, each new row one foot to the right of the last. As do the characters in a book. Each paragraph moves the characters forward through their own dimension of time. Maybe the process that creates the rows of rocks, the man following simple rules, is what makes it conscious. But the book is created by a writer following a process too, does that make it conscious?
The only thing I can think of is that the character in the book is far simpler than a human. Words that say "john is happy" is similar to setting a variable on your computer equal to "happy". Happiness in a human is far more complex, involving tons of interactions between neurons. But this answer isn't satisfactory to me. Complexity isn't what makes something intelligent or conscious after all.
- randallsquared 14y ago> The only thing I can think of is that the character in the book is far simpler than a human. Words that say "john is happy" is similar to setting a variable on your computer equal to "happy". Happiness in a human is far more complex, involving tons of interactions between neurons. But this answer isn't satisfactory to me. Complexity isn't what makes something intelligent or conscious after all. This is the difference between a running program and a short description of the program. The short description isn't runnable, and isn't running. The reason the program itself is doing what we want it to do is not because it's more complex than the short description (though it is), but because it's actually executing the algorithm. We could imagine more and more detailed descriptions of the program, specifying more and more closely how it works, and eventually it's so detailed that you could run the program from that description. At that point, the description is still not a running program, unless and until you run it. Being conscious is a process -- a running algorithm -- not a static description.
- Houshalter 14y agoWell I'm not really claiming the book is sentient, just trying to come up with a criteria that excludes books and everything else except for people, without being completely arbitrary. Anyways you can think of time as a dimension. Each moment of time exists, connected to the ones that came before and come after it. You can represent the every state that a turing machine goes through all at once. Just like those rows of rocks. What does "running" even mean in a universe where all points in time can exist at once? But regardless of that, you can still say the book is "running" when it is being written or when it is being read. The characters don't just exist in the book, but literally in your mind. Though I still wouldn't call them conscious or even intelligent.
- randallsquared 14y ago> What does "running" even mean in a universe where all points in time can exist at once? If they all exist at once, then in what sense are they connected? Certainly not a causal sense, which I would argue matters quite a lot. > The characters don't just exist in the book, but literally in your mind. Though I still wouldn't call them conscious or even intelligent. If your mind was able to simulate the actual process of consciousness in the brain of the character being read about, then I would argue that the character could be conscious. Of course, brains don't have that much additional processing power. :)