9 ms·
It would be great if this helped but I sure hope "the internet" doesn't decide it's someone who turns out to be the wrong person, because the vigilantes will no
by ck2 14y ago
It would be great if this helped but I sure hope "the internet" doesn't decide it's someone who turns out to be the wrong person, because the vigilantes will not stop even if the discovery is "corrected".
The media did that with the Atlanta bombing and it destroyed a guy's life.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Jewell http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Jewell
- nostromo 14y agoOr more recently Steven Hatfill from the 2001 anthrax attacks.
- ck2 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steven_Hatfill http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steven_Hatfill Or even more recently Ryan Lanza at Sandy Hook http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ryan_Lanza#Investigation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ryan_Lanza#Investigation The media doesn't learn and doesn't care to learn.
- jamesrcole 14y agoI think it's worse than that, as there are incentives (ratings, readership, etc) for them to jump to conclusions like that.
- sssk 14y agoThe very fact this post has made it to the top of HN/Reddit/4Chan, is incentive enough for similar communities to start searching for needles in those haystacks of photos. I guess we can expect more such "observations" from the crowd :-|
- n3rdy 14y agoI think there is a big difference between the news saying "THIS IS THE GUY! THIS IS THE MONSTER!" and people on a forum speculating that "this may be worth looking into further". The people who turn it into a witch hunt are likely not the people actually using their heads enough to know what to be looking for in the images.
- kayoone 14y agoJust wait until the media finds this
- parasight 14y agoThey already have. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/04/16/mystery-man-on-roof-boston-bombings-photo-_n_3091189.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/04/16/mystery-man-on-roof... Edit: It's another picture though.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mootothemax 14y agoI think there is a big difference between the news saying "THIS IS THE GUY! THIS IS THE MONSTER!" and people on a forum speculating that "this may be worth looking into further". The problem is that all it takes is one group to start quoting the other, and the effect starts to snowball: "Internet detectives on the popular website Reddit have identified three possible suspects..." "[Rival news organization] tonight reported on three new leads. The suspects, Joe Bloggs, Susan Smith and Bill Stickers..." "Ask Reddit - who of the three suspects do you think is most likely to be behind the attacks?"
- tezza 14y agoUK: Colin Stagg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Rachel_Nickell http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Rachel_Nickell Christopher Jeffries http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2012/mar/16/christopher-jeffries-tabloid-frenzy-joanna-yeates http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2012/mar/16/christopher-jeffrie... Oz: Lindy Chamberlain http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindy_Chamberlain-Creighton http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindy_Chamberlain-Creighton Countless others, and one of the reasons why death-penalties can kill the wrong person
- kitlas 14y agoThe Central Park Five https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_Park_Jogger_case#Convictions_vacated https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_Park_Jogger_case#Convi...
- mattmaroon 14y agoMost of these didn't end with lives ruined. With Ryan Lanza, the media corrected the suspect name very quickly. Hatfill got a multimillion dollar settlement from the government, and Jewell ended up on SNL. In all cases the media did learn they were wrong and publicly admit. Certainly they jumped the gun and caused injury, but they did learn and do the right thing eventually.
- umsm 14y agoThe media learned as in "became informed" but did not learn in the sense that they "improved".
- mattmaroon 14y agoI don't think that's fair to say either. "The media" reports hundreds of names in various capacities every day. Of course they blunder occasionally. You just don't hear about the 99.999% of the time they don't. I don't think they needed to learn anything. They know it's bad to jump the gun. You still see "Dewey Defeats Truman" jokes. They just make mistakes. It's easy to criticize a nameless faceless concept like "the media". Individuals in the media are largely upstanding people trying to do the right thing.
- yekko 14y agoReally? looks like Richard Jewell died a pretty horrible death...
- googletron 14y agonatural causes?
- chc 14y agoYou can't blame "the media" for a man's kidney problems.
- yekko 14y agoHaving your life destroyed and the depression must have added to it.
- officemonkey 14y agoIt wasn't the media that decided that Richard Jewell and Steven Hatfill were "persons of interest," it was the FBI. With recent news about someone "watching a race while brown" (an injured Saudi's home is searched while he's being treated for injuries) I don't hold a lot of hope for accurate and careful policing.
- TheCondor 14y agoThe FBI very much leaked those names though. It wasn't an accident.
- kjackson2012 14y agoOf course this is helping. They aren't convicting anyone, they are tracking down leads. I'm sure the police would be engaging in this exact same exercise if they had the manpower. Luckily, there are hundreds or thousands of motivated volunteers who are willing to sift through this data and hopefully something really good is in there.
- brazzy 14y agoThe problem is that if those "leads" are made public and point at specific people, then some people will let their outrage over what happened blot out all doubt that the "leads" are not conclusive evidence and take what they believe to be justice into their own hands.
- VLM 14y agoAs a counter example look at the arab guy. You can read about him in wikipedia and somewhat online (its intentionally not being discussed much by the media). Immediately after the blast a bunch of people tackled an arab dude for the crime of "running while Arab" and turned him over to the cops who tossed his apartment upside down. The latest I've heard was an official police spokesman said the arab dude had nothing to do with the event other than being another victim. I would say this is an absolutely worst case heat of the moment outcome. Can't claim its unrelated or irrelevant. Its a sad outcome that lots of americans automatically equate being arab with being a criminal, and its sad he got tackled after nearly being blown up, and its sad the cops trashed his house, but in the long line of human injustice, its not that bad, no one shot him or lynched him or ruined his reputation. In a somewhat slower paced, more methodical, less emotional situation like looking at pictures of backpacks online, I think the likely outcome compared to the poor arab dude would be immensely more likely to tend toward rational wise justice than uncontrolled rabid injustice.
- auntienomen 14y agoI confess to being strangely comforted that no one in Arizona has shot a Sikh yet.
- 14y ago
- analog 14y agoThere have been a few of these cases, but they all (iirc) have been started by traditional media rather than the internet mob. In fact the mob in this case seems to be showing a lot of common sense with top voted comments like the parent here urging caution.
- kmfrk 14y agoAnonymous also digitally lynched a guy assumed to have thrown a puppy off a bridge. Turned out they had the wrong guy. Vigilante justice is reckless and comes with big risks, as romantic as it may sound to some to sit in the comfort of your desk chair and bring about digital justice.
- sdoering 14y ago> as romantic as it may sound to some to sit in the comfort of your desk chair and bring about digital justice. Isn't this romantic notion, bringing justice with a click the driving force of nearly every online-petition, and things like this. Isn't this romantic notion the reason why the new demo is so often practiced? New demo = to ddos someone to mars or jupiter, and rationalize it with: I could just as easily have gone to their headquarter and demoed there? Well most people could not have done it - and would not have done it in rain, snow, wind, driven 500 miles just to demo there, and so on. As a lot of psychological studies showed, people saying they would do something and people doing this thing in the real world (not in their imagination) are two totally different things. So there you have your real, underlying problem, a psychological problem, with this kind of digital activism. It is so totally different from real activism, and at the same time so new, that we really do not have proper ways as a society to deal with the dark sides of it.
- Klinky 14y agoOne or a few people defacing or denying a target's digital presence gets everyone's attention. One or a few people picketing outside of the target's physical presence doesn't get any attention. The ability for one person to have that much power is either scary or empowering depending on your point of view.
- tripzilch 14y agoYou mean "both". And/or, it's definitely not an either/or thing.
- 14y ago
- bargl 14y agoYeah this seems like it could turn into a witch hunt very quickly. The right way to get this information out there would be to privately send it to the police.
- Evbn 14y agoHoly cow. If you said to me "How is Richard Jewell related to the Atlanta Olympics?". I would not have guessed the correct answer: "rescued hundreds of people from a bomb." I would have guessed the libel, which I will not repeat here. Memory sucks.
- tomjen3 14y agoThe authorities could prevent this if they had been more forthcomming with information. Not telling anything for days isn't acceptable anymore -- the government used to get away with these kinds of things because it used to control the narrative, but it can't do that anymore.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y ago>The media did that with the Atlanta bombing and it destroyed a guy's life. The media? No the FBI did that. "The media" ought to have known better, and still hasn't learned better.