4 ms·
That and the Finely Tuned Universe Paradox (the Goldilocks Enigma) is why I can't easily consider myself an atheist. I mean, chances are, this universe is "inte
by visarga 14y ago
That and the Finely Tuned Universe Paradox (the Goldilocks Enigma) is why I can't easily consider myself an atheist. I mean, chances are, this universe is "intelligently designed", in the most literal sense. I call it the "Alien God Hypothesis". It's probable that a race of aliens has mastered the "world creation mechanism", either by simulation or by physical hacking (who knows, maybe they can control black holes and create baby universes inside with just the right conditions for life).
At some point down the line there must be a purely physical universe though, but we're probably not there, but in one of the branches. So while I am not atheist in a pure sense, I am not a theist either. Nice, isn't it? Science makes almost full circle to religion. The IDers are almost right.
- jerf 14y agoI have often thought that if 20th century science tried to ram home the logical necessity of atheism, 21st century science rams home the logical necessity of agnosticism being the ground level, so to speak. If we, tiny as we still are, can even conceive of a practical way to simulate a universe (and what is truly the difference between "simulate" and "create" in the end?), how can we in good conscience fully rule out the idea that we are in fact in a simulation, and that whoever it is that is simulating us is in every reasonable sense a lower-case-d deity? They may be leaving us alone, ignorant of our existence (perhaps they only care about the large-scale results and we are but a blip), etc etc the entire well explored set of possible philosophical deities, but how can we confidently proclaim that none of them exist? In the 20th century, one could be ignorant and scoff at the idea that Mankind might ever create a universe, and therefore scoff by extension at the idea that anyone or anything else could either... but now we know better. We've got universe prototypes already in production as ongoing commercial concerns (far more than mere theory!), at various stages of incredible primitiveness, but prototypes nonetheless. Rather than a massive leap, it is now merely logical progression that something, somewhere in some reality may actually have the knowledge and the resources to have "created" our universe, for some value of the term "created". (I speak here of science in the vague philosophical movement sense. As much as it would like to claim total philosophical neutrality, there are certain Opinions that are Had.)
- XorNot 14y agoAgnosticism has nothing meaningful to say about this situation, because it claims to give equal weight to totally unfounded claims ("it's definitely yahweh"). Atheists would rightly consider the evidence, conclude there was a creator, but give it no due reverence because they would conclude (rightly) that none is morally due.
- jasonm23 14y agoI think you're conflating anti-theist/philosophical anarchists with atheists. Concluding there is a creator, simply transforms one from being an Atheist into something completely separate.
- jerf 14y agoA-theism is generally understood to mean the confident proclamation that there is no deity. "Agnosticism has nothing meaningful to say" is, frankly, my point; we thought we could confidently proclaim the impossibility of a deity in the 20th century, and now we can not honestly. As for the 'correct' conclusion that none is due, that is itself an awfully confident statement about a deity you know little about, even whether it exists. Some might consider the fact that we are left alone, rather than driven like puppets in some manner, to be a positive factor on its own, after all. You may not like that we are not handed a life of total goodness and light and luxury, or whatever your ideal universe looks like, but it could also be a great great deal worse.
- XorNot 14y agoSomeone running a simulation you're in is not a deity, just another person in a position of great power.
- moens 14y agoMeritocracy just broke all to pieces I guess.
- hcarvalhoalves 14y agoThe alternative explanation is that the universe just is, and we humans are the ones who seek reason in it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic_principle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic_principle