4 ms·
Haha. I thought to my uninitiated mind: "What's the difference between categories and sets?" and found this: Some attempts have been made by category theory to
by contingencies 14y ago
Haha. I thought to my uninitiated mind: "What's the difference between categories and sets?" and found this: Some attempts have been made by category theory to usurp the foundations of mathematics from set theory. That is, rather than taking sets as the most fundamental building block of the mathematical world, give that role to categories. Sets themselves form a category.
http://www.connections.xamuel.com/Category+Theory-vs-Set+Theory.html http://www.connections.xamuel.com/Category+Theory-vs-Set+The...
Sounds to me as an uninitiated programmer like set theory had issues when wielded in the nether regions of modern mathematical theory, and category theory is the kludge that followed.
Maybe I should have done maths; yet when most fascinated by its theories under the influence of a three letter traditional psychoactive, a former IBM employee and multi-decade pure mathematics researcher literally begged me not to, declaring it an enending path that wastes decades of people's lives. Ho hum.
- nilkn 14y agoA category is a collection of objects with a notion of morphism between said objects. Morphisms are really not defined much beyond that; it is all left rather abstract, though there are some basic laws that must be satisfied. Categories are relatively uninteresting without functors. Functors are more or less mappings or transformations between categories. Category theory by some accounts initiated in the foundations of algebraic topology. In that subject, one wishes to codify some of the aspects of a high-dimensional shape or geometric object in algebraic terms. The hope is that the algebraic image of the shape is easier to understand than the shape itself. The mapping of shapes into their algebraic "shadows" is a functor. For instance, you can take a torus and look at the collection of all closed loops drawn on the surface of the torus. Now identify two loops as the same if one can be smoothly deformed into the other by moving it along the surface of the torus. Long story short, this gives the set of such loops a structure known as a group. There is a very extensive theory developed around groups, so you might surmise that you could partially classify shapes by looking at this associated group (called the fundamental group or first homotopy group). This mapping from geometric objects to groups of loops drawn on them is a functor from the category of topological spaces to the category of groups. This is the beginning of homotopy theory. As for your comment on sets, there is the category Set which consists of all sets. That is, the objects of Set are sets and, given two sets X and Y, the morphisms between X and Y in Set are simply the functions f : X -> Y. An interesting technical point here (which is related to your quote) is that Set itself cannot be a set, as there is no set of all sets within Zermelo-Fraenkel set theory (the most common axiomatic formulation of set theory). Rather, there is a notion of class, and one says that the collection of all sets forms a class rather than a set.
- otoburb 14y agoDid the pure math researcher beg you to stay away from pure, applied or both types of math?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]