3 ms·
>if you can borrow at 5% and use that money to make an investment that will provide risk-adjusted returns of 15%, then it always makes sense to borrow... No, I
by fauigerzigerk 14y ago
>if you can borrow at 5% and use that money to make an investment that will provide risk-adjusted returns of 15%, then it always makes sense to borrow...
No, I think if we have learned one thing in the recent crisis it is that highly leveraged entities carry cumulative risk that is more than the sum of the parts. Also, the government is not one company of many. It is a monopoly that must be in a position to act countercyclically even when everyone else decides based on risk adjusted returns that it is best to sell everything, fire everyone and hide in a hole in the ground.
If the government is levered up like everyone else and therefore exposed to the same self reenforcing global dynamics when things go wrong, it will not be able to do its job in a crisis. The government must invest when no one else does and that means it has to invest less when everyone else does.
>All public spending is an investment of sorts
Not all of it, but even for the part that is, you have to ask whether that investment has a higher return than if the private sector made those investment decisions. That's obviously a highly ideological question. My own opinion is that it depends on the type of investment. I think we have good examples either way.