3 ms·
Ultimately? Really? If you are going to deconstruct that way, why stop there, why not bags of water? Or a random assortment of atoms? By that reasoning a work
by ars 14y ago
Ultimately? Really?
If you are going to deconstruct that way, why stop there, why not bags of water? Or a random assortment of atoms?
By that reasoning a work of art is just random colors and there is no reason to admire it.
But in actuality the whole is greater than the parts, and that applies to people too.
- mikeash 14y ago"By that reasoning a work of art is just random colors and there is no reason to admire it." I disagree. There is no conflict between admiring the organization of the fundamental particles and realizing that stuff is ultimately just big collections of fundamental particles.
- ars 14y agoYes, but "realizing that stuff is ultimately just big collections of fundamental particles" is probably the ultimate in pointless activities. (Unless of course you are studying particle physics.) By that measure every single thing that exists is exactly identical to everything else. If nothing is different, then nothing matters, and nothing has value. Let's just short circuit that entire pointless line of thought and look at the whole, not just the parts.
- mikeash 14y agoI'll consolidate the conversation here. "By that measure every single thing that exists is exactly identical to everything else." Where do you get this idea? "X is ultimately just a big collection of fundamental particles" and "Y is ultimately just a big collection of fundamental particles" does not imply "X is identical to Y". It's like saying you should never call anybody a "person" because you're implying all people are identical. I mean, what?
- tekacs 14y agoI would add to my sibling comment here that one should note that a particular characteristic of the engineer (or software developer) is the ability to internalise all of the layers of a system and to be able to treat it as whichever subset of the layers are relevant at any given time. Doing so hardly means that one considers all such systems equivalent or indeed that one doesn't think of a reductionist view as just the most reified (though pretty damned vague) possible view of the system.
- mikeash 14y agoThat's a great point. All layers are correct, but most won't be useful for a given problem. If you're thinking about, say, crowd reactions, then you don't want the "meatbag" model. Instead, you need a higher-level psychological model. However, if your problem is "what kind of injuries result from a bomb", then the "meatbag" model is right on. Thinking of the body as a loose confederation of fundamental particles is fairly useless when trying to decide how much to charge for a product, but it's an excellent model when e.g. figuring out how much radiation a person will absorb from a source. No layer denies the usefulness or reality of any of the others.
- ars 14y agoWe can agree here. And note that I had no issue with the use of the word meatbag to describe bomb effects. It was your use of the word "ultimately" that I objected to.
- pyre 14y ago| why not bags of water Already been done: "Ugly bags of mostly water" http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Home_Soil_(episode) http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Home_Soil_(episode)
- vacri 14y agoIronically you're using 'a work of art' in your defense while attacking a statement made in an artistic style.