10 ms·
There may not be empirical evidence for the magical 90% level, but we don't need empirical evidence to know that at some point interest payments will require hi
by fauigerzigerk 14y ago
There may not be empirical evidence for the magical 90% level, but we don't need empirical evidence to know that at some point interest payments will require highter tax revenues which will reduce disposable income and hence consumption.
Obviously someone is on the receiving end of those repayments, but if that someone is not putting money in the pockets of those same taxpayers and instead decides to finance a power plant in Thailand then GDP will inevitably suffer.
I'm not a government deficit scaremonger by any means. I think Krugman's (and others') argument that the U.S. government can borrow very cheaply and should therefore act in a countercyclical manner for the common good is plausible. I'm also convinced that the crowding out argument is bogus in an economy that suffers from too little demand whilst corporations are sitting on tons of cash.
But we should not lose sight of the fact that interest rates are a highly psychological affair. Once trust in the ability to repay debt gets eroded things can get out of control very quickly. So we should be scared at least a little bit.
That said, the U.S is probably the one entity on this planet that is furthest away from that point. Even Japan with it's 245% debt/GDP ratio can borrow at 0.5% for 10 years whilst their currency is crashing and the central bank is announcing a massive QE program twice the size of the U.S one.
But if the U.S ever gets to the point where Japan is now, that's when I'm starting read up on agriculture or the hunter-gatherer diet.
- podperson 14y agoThere's obviously some point where having too much debt is bad, but if we go back to the classical "country as household" oversimplistic analogy, I doubt you'd find evidence that people who have mortgages over some magic value relative to their income suddenly start getting smaller annual raises.
- kzrdude 14y agoIf you reinvested your household's profit into the company that pays your salaries, it might?
- fauigerzigerk 14y agoAnnual raises are not analogous to GDP. Spending is. If interest payments grow faster than income then spending will go down. Also, if a household's interest payments are rising faster than its income then it will not be able to invest, say, in the education of the kids. So if you count the kids as part of that household over their lifetime, annual raises will indeed be smaller because better educated folks get bigger raises.
- podperson 14y agoSpending isn't a good analogy to GDP either. We should probably just dispense with the analogy altogether... The bigger point is that debt is often the lubricant of growth. E.g. we're FAR better off borrowing money to educate our kids than saving money and raising kids with no knowledge or skills.
- wonderyak 14y agoIf households could print currency it would be analogous. The US Federal Government can not ever run out of money because it controls the currency. This is not to say that bad things can't happen (inflation for one); but in most cases its a balance sheet equation - Federal Debt is Private Credit.
- podperson 14y agoIf anything this makes Federal Debt more useful and attractive than private debt. The problem isn't that households can't "print currency" (in a sense they can) but that their debts aren't denominated in the currency they can print. Thus, the US government is in a relatively unique position that, for example, Cyprus and Greece do not enjoy.
- dragonwriter 14y ago> If anything this makes Federal Debt more useful and attractive than private debt. A theoretical observation borne out quite well by the observed market characteristics of federal debt (e.g., the federal governments cost of borrowing.)
- ajscherer 14y agoI prefer we not go back to any oversimplistic analogies. That's part of what makes these debates so insufferable. A nation's economy isn't a household budget. A company isn't a person. A nation isn't a person. I don't really see much value in someone's axiomatic understanding of all of economics premised on the belief that they are smarter than people who study economics (even if they are; probably they are!). I'd much prefer to hear from someone who is less smart, but who admits the subject is too complex for them to fully understand and who can be bothered to go out and actually attempt to measure something (rather than telling me what it must be). I guess I'm saying I think I can learn more from an honest person than a smart one. Now I'm questioning why I am wasting my time reading hacker news again.
- jbarham 14y ago> I doubt you'd find evidence that people who have mortgages over some magic value relative to their income suddenly start getting smaller annual raises. Tell that to the people who are underwater on their mortgages and are therefore severely handicapped financially because it's punitively expensive for them to move to find a new job if they become unemployed. When I was living in the US in 2009 I was laid off as a part of a company wide restructuring caused by the recession. Because I rented I was able to relocate to a new job in 6 weeks. Colleagues who were underwater on their mortgages and therefore had to find a new job within commuting distance of their house took much longer to find new jobs.
- cma 14y ago"If there is a high debt twilight zone effect as R&R claim, then we can just buy back bonds at steep discounts and send our debt-to-GDP ratio plummeting." http://www.cepr.net/index.php/blogs/beat-the-press/how-much-unemployment-was-caused-by-reinhart-and-rogoffs-arithmetic-mistake http://www.cepr.net/index.php/blogs/beat-the-press/how-much-...
- fauigerzigerk 14y agoGreece tried that. But to buy back bonds you have to sell assets and very quickly. That turns out to be very difficult politically. Forced assets sales will also cause the price of the asset to crash.
- bubbleRefuge 14y agoUm Greece cannot issue currency in the way that the US can.
- fauigerzigerk 14y agoNo, but the linked article says the government could sell assets to buy back bonds instead of getting into a money printing debt monetization sprial.
- cma 14y agoNo, it said it could buy back debt by reissuing new debt at a higher rate and using the proceeds; net interest burden would remain the same, but the debt GDP-ratio would change.
- nhaehnle 14y agoThe point is that appropriate action can always be taken when needed, and unemployment is never necessary. To elaborate a little bit: A monetarily sovereign government really only needs higher tax revenue to stave off demand-driven inflation. But in the case of demand-driven inflation, something has to be done anyway due to real constraints. Now you might ask whether austerity now could help future real constraints in any way. The answer is typically no: austerity means that less is consumed today, but at the cost of less production today. Austerity does not cause stockpiles of real resources to be built for the future. If you actually wanted to build real resources for the future (and such a plan would be dubious at best, because predicting future needs is tricky, especially in the face of changing technology), you would actually want to do the opposite of austerity: you would want to spend more now, in order to buy the real resources that are stored away in the stockpile. It is only these real considerations that matter for a monetarily sovereign country. Monetary constraints only matter for countries that are not sovereign, e.g. the various members of the Euro area.
- spikels 14y agoI wish you were right but there is a big difference between research not being able to show that large debts slow growth and banishing unemployment forever. For starters there will always be some unemployment due to natural turnover: companies sometimes have to reduce their workforce and not every hire is a success for either the company or the employee. People need time to find the next job and companies need time to fill the position. This is often called the natural rate of unemployment. However it is much more than that. Suppose the government could just spend lots more. What does it spend on? Or does it just hire every unemployed person? Are these permanent government jobs? What do they do? What are the long term effects? Sadly I am not aware of any country that has managed to solve unemployment (except perhaps some totalitarian regimes like the former USSR and these were not sustainable solutions). You would think that is it was just a matter of spending as much as you want that this solution wold have been found long ago. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_rate_of_unemployment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_rate_of_unemployment
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- varjag 14y ago> But we should not lose sight of the fact that interest rates are a highly psychological affair. Once trust in the ability to repay debt gets eroded things can get out of control very quickly. So we should be scared at least a little bit. This is one thing an overstretched fiat currency has strikingly in common with Ponzi schemes.
- cantankerous 14y agoSame with any paper-based security as well. Any fiscal instrument can look like a Ponzi scheme if you pick the right angle.
- varjag 14y agoThat's why I wrote "overstretched". I'm not opposing the idea of fiat currency in general. At essence of any Ponzi scheme lies debt that inherently can not be repaid, and public disclosure of that acts as tipping point.
- SilasX 14y agoI find it a convincing argument that, of all the times for the US government to borrow, now is about as ideal as it gets by conventional measures. People will loan to the federal government for pitifully low rates. And yet ... I have to ask: If not now, when? If we can convince ourselves today that we can keep putting off the eventual cutbacks until tomorrow, as we have been for ages, how will next time be any different? If we can't justify cutbacks when the outlook is grim, how will we be able to when people are optimistic instead? If not now, when? If not our generation, which? If the current state does not move us to make the hard calls, then what state would so move us?
- JumpCrisscross 14y ago"we don't need empirical evidence to know that at some point interest payments will require highter tax revenues which will reduce disposable income and hence consumption." We always need empirical evidence. For your example, no, we don't know that, e.g. when the debt is monetized by the central bank. A bias towards sovereign debt elimination may be more dangerous than a bias towards sovereign debt accumulation - empirical evidence, not intuition, is how we validate the models that guide our trade-offs.
- fauigerzigerk 14y agoWe will never have empirical evidence (with any predictive power) for what really happens if the biggest economy in the world, the one that provides the reserve currency, the preeminent military power, goes bust, because the sample size is 1. [Edit] And about your counter example: We do know that sovereign debt accumulation will eventually become impossible, so it's not relevant whether or not it would be beneficial. Once domestic lenders (who can be forced to lend) are exhausted, the government will have to borrow from foreigners in foreign currency under foreign law. So debt accumulation is only possible as long as foreigners are willing to lend.
- mattmcknight 14y agoMonetizing debt would not change the fact that more debt would mean higher nominal payments, inflation would reduce real income and real consumption.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoCorrection: 74% of the American population carries net debt, even if it's "good debt". Inflation would act as a mini-jubilee to rebalance the economy between producers and financiers.
- encoderer 14y agoIn the long-term, sure, it may have some wealth transfer effects. But in the short term it's tragic for most people. Interest rates through the roof. Inadequate incomes. Etc. Or to borrow a meme, "periods of high inflation have been great for the middle class" said nobody ever.
- nkoren 14y agoThere's always a lot of voodoo in economics; doubly so when partisan politics are involved. But to believe that there is a ceiling beyond which more debt should not be accumulated requires a special type of magical thinking. Businesses evaluate decisions based on whether the rate of return is greater than the rate of finance. Eg., if you can borrow at 5% and use that money to make an investment that will provide risk-adjusted returns of 15%, then it always makes sense to borrow that money and make that investment. Doing so will always make your financial position better, regardless of the level of debt you are carrying. Of course opportunity costs must also be taken into account: if you have cash in hand which you are are servicing debt at 15%, and have an opportunity to make an investment that returns 10%, then making that investment will worsen your financial situation; you should pay down the debt instead. Once again, this is true no matter how much debt you are carrying. All public spending is an investment of sorts. Infrastructure, education, R&D, public health -- all of these produce measurable returns. Where those returns are greater than the cost of debt, your society will be better off for financing them by debt. Where those returns are lower than the cost of debt, it won't be. This sounds like an over-simplification, but isn't: accurately measuring those returns is no easy task even after the fact, much less predicting them beforehand. But that is what the public debate and decision-making process needs to be about, because that's what really matters. All this handwringing over imaginary debt ceilings and such has been nothing more than an incredibly destructive canard.
- fauigerzigerk 14y ago>if you can borrow at 5% and use that money to make an investment that will provide risk-adjusted returns of 15%, then it always makes sense to borrow... No, I think if we have learned one thing in the recent crisis it is that highly leveraged entities carry cumulative risk that is more than the sum of the parts. Also, the government is not one company of many. It is a monopoly that must be in a position to act countercyclically even when everyone else decides based on risk adjusted returns that it is best to sell everything, fire everyone and hide in a hole in the ground. If the government is levered up like everyone else and therefore exposed to the same self reenforcing global dynamics when things go wrong, it will not be able to do its job in a crisis. The government must invest when no one else does and that means it has to invest less when everyone else does. >All public spending is an investment of sorts Not all of it, but even for the part that is, you have to ask whether that investment has a higher return than if the private sector made those investment decisions. That's obviously a highly ideological question. My own opinion is that it depends on the type of investment. I think we have good examples either way.
- kaonashi 14y ago>but we don't need empirical evidence to know that at some point interest payments will require highter tax revenues When interest rates on bonds remain at or below the rate of GDP growth, this is not an issue. For the U.S. (and other countries which issue floating-rate non-convertible currencies) interest rates on bonds are a policy variable of the central bank. http://www.cfeps.org/pubs/wp-pdf/WP53-Fullwiler.pdf http://www.cfeps.org/pubs/wp-pdf/WP53-Fullwiler.pdf