3 ms·
oh dear. I may be reading too much between the lines, but thy post, and the logo-page, are corporate, goal driven projects (maybe top down) that are then wrapp
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
oh dear.
I may be reading too much between the lines, but thy post, and the logo-page, are corporate, goal driven projects (maybe top down) that are then wrapped up in nice fluffy words.
Its not the same as nice fluffy ideas, getting thrown out and tested, with maybe as much attention from lawyers as aspell.
Of course it happens, but this is the time github went from that nice sparky startup, to the long slide into corporate beige.
In many ways its a triumph, startups just don't succeed like this. And I would wish success and money and more success on them all - but my antennae twitched.
Still paying monthly for it though. Octocat will cry all the way to the bank
- logn 14y agoWho cares. Lone founders are apt to redesign logos too. The fluffy language was probably added because a simple, "here's our new logo cause it's better" is probably a little too brief, especially for companies who may have incorporated those marks into their own assets, and need a little justification for re-work.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoBut that's it. Back in the day, it would have been "here it is because it is better". It worked. Be careful changing a winning formula. And yes that's rose tinted glasses perhaps.
- tptacek 14y agoUh, what? Github is still run by its founding team. They're big because they sell something that is extremely awesome compared to the market substitutes. The good guys don't always win, but they did this time. Spare us the anti-corp agita.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoThey are stretching past the ability of a founding team to be intimate with everything - which in many many ways is fantastic - top 1% of startups only. But I read an outsourced rebranding that came in nicely wrapped up, even with legalese in appendix A. And then octo-goodness sprinkled on top. This does not feel like a move and an announcement with GitHub DNA at is heart. It feels added on. Done well, but my antennae twitched. The move from scrappy startup to 100m in funding is fantastic - real poster-boy stuff. But losing your identity in that move, what makes that team great, is so common it should have a name. I want Preston-Warner et al to succeed. I want them to leap the chasm into a functioning corporate body that does whatever they have planned. But this one feels like the huge difficulties in running a fast growing high profile company might just be stretching them. I don't know - all I have are inferences and hunches. Maybe they have time each day to think and ruminate on what GitHub needs to become, have time for creativity. Or maybe they run from one to another meeting exhausted at days end. Who knows. But like I said, if they even read this, they can wipe the tears away with bunches of Benjamin's. good for them, good luck. Think of it commenting on growing pains, not diagnosing terminal cancer Anti-corp agita? I used to take over the college buildings in student protests, then sit up all night arguing market driven solutions beat socialism everytime.
- thedaniel 14y ago"But I read an outsourced rebranding that came in nicely wrapped up, even with legalese in appendix A." I can assure you, your read is wrong. This work was done by GitHubbers collaboratively and painstakingly.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoThank you, then I stand corrected. My antennae will have to go back to the shop. :-) Good luck with the rebrand and the (I suspect) avalanche of new stuff to be doing. cheers
- davidu 14y agoThe negativity and bitterness (even when wrapped in the veil of a nice comment) on HN continues. The only difference between a sell-out and a not-sell-out is the presence of a buyer. That's it. How you treat your customers and your employees, the work you put into your products, and the service and loyalty that you engender in continued business is all that matters. GitHub does all those things extraordinarily well, and more. Changing a typography and logo a tiny bit signifies nothing more than they wanted to change their brand's typography and logo a tiny bit. Providing the usage scenarios for their marks is not needed at worst, and really useful at best.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoNegative and bitter? Really? Come on, they are at an inflection point that has ruined many many other companies before - and I want this one to succeed. Bitter because I did not do it back in 2006? Nah- the litany of "if only" is boring even if I am the one saying it. Negativity. Well ok, yes but that's what the pills are for
- nollidge 14y ago> I may be reading too much between the lines Yeah, maybe a little.