4 ms·
From the first article: Let’s be generous and assume that the overall multiplier on tax cuts is 1. Then the per-year effect of the plan on GDP is 150 x 1 + 2
by mikeyouse 14y ago
From the first article:
Let’s be generous and assume that the overall multiplier on tax cuts is 1. Then the per-year effect of the plan on GDP is 150 x 1 + 240 x 1.5 = $510 billion. Since it takes $300 billion to reduce the unemployment rate by 1 percentage point, this is shaving 1.7 points off what unemployment would otherwise have been.
Finally, compare this with the economic outlook. “Full employment” clearly means an unemployment rate near 5 — the CBO says 5.2 for the NAIRU, which seems high to me. Unemployment is currently about 7 percent, and heading much higher; Obama himself says that absent stimulus it could go into double digits. Suppose that we’re looking at an economy that, absent stimulus, would have an average unemployment rate of 9 percent over the next two years; this plan would cut that to 7.3 percent, which would be a help but could easily be spun by critics as a failure.
The math is obvious... if the economy was going to 9% unemployment without stimulus (which we now know was too optimistic), with the same composition of tax cuts : spending, $1T would be called for. Since we peaked at 10% unemployment, even with ~1T in stimulus (which should've had a ~4% impact on the rate), with this math, $2.25T could've been about right.
The CBO looked back at real output / unemployment and made the following estimates.[1]
- http://www.usnews.com/dbimages/master/29996/GR_120620_gdprecoveryact1.jpg http://www.usnews.com/dbimages/master/29996/GR_120620_gdprec...
Which shows the impact of the ARRA. So it seems that between 2-3% reduction in peak unemployment with ~1T. So again, something like $2.5T would've been close.
The point all along is that too little stimulus is far more damaging than too much, and with unemployment still above 7.5% five years later, that point seems to have some evidence.
[1] http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/attachments/ARRA_One-Col.pdf http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/attachments/...
- kevinskii 14y agoYou're missing the point. Yes, the math is obvious. The correct coefficients to use are not, and those are what make all the difference.