10 ms·
Buyer sued for posting factual negative review on eBay
- DigitalSea 14y agoTo be fair the buyer sounded like a big douche. Med Express immediately offered to reimburse the buyer for the $1.44 postage fee they were charged, it's a minor mistake that the buyer overreacted about. I find it kind of silly Med Express thinks they have a case here though, they probably have more money and will end up settling because the buyer won't be able to afford to fight.
- bdfh42 14y agoTrouble is - you have to stand up to the bullies - even for those with whom you are less than sympathetic. Bullies must be stopped as if they succeed it will be you who they will come after next.
- efdee 14y agoBut who is the bully here? I'm not sure.
- xarien 14y agoWhen is the last time a bully offered to buy you lunch because he accidentally took yours by accident?
- Drakim 14y agoAnd after you blog about your negative experience of having lunch taken away by accident, the bully sues you for slander. In my book everybody acted within acceptable reason until they sued him for leaving a true review on ebay.
- xarien 14y agoLet's put things in perspective. The post was short under 2 bucks and the seller was more than happy to cover it. So at what point does one think to themselves, hey let's go ahead and leave a negative feedback because there was a kink with the transaction? Hell, if every transaction had to work without a hitch, the majority of us wouldn't even be able to ship a product not to mention release an MVP...
- bdfh42 14y agoYou have probably focused on the true problem. It looks like any negative element to the rather simplistic feedback model represents an issue for the seller. Why is that? - an issue ultimately fixed should be viewed as neutral - unless it is repeated too often.
- Drakim 14y agoAnd how often can the mistake be repeated before I can blog about it without being sued? Two times? Three times?
- kls 14y agowhich is why in my opinion the buyer should have probably left neutral feedback with an explanation of what happened. This way other buyers can read the neutral feedback and see if there is a trend with a seller. That is really what neutral feedback is for, it's a way to say hey everything did not go smoothly but I don't think the seller did it with malice, you as another future buyer should know about this, and if it seems to be a trend then you should leave negative feedback.
- rlpb 14y ago> hey let's go ahead and leave a negative feedback because there was a kink with the transaction? That's exactly what feedback on a per-transaction basis is for, isn't it? If a seller has a habit of sending things with underpaid postage, then a potential buyer will be able to see the pattern in the feedback history and choose not to buy. If it's a one-off, then a potential buyer will see that. The feedback history just represents fact. If, on the other hand, buyers do not post negative feedback for such incidents, then a a seller habitually sending items with underpaid postage will appear the same as a more reliable seller. This renders the feedback system useless in this kind of case. It also makes it hard to find reliable sellers, and encourages less reliable sellers to remain in the system.
- claudius 14y agoSo I can take people’s lunches as long as I offer to buy them a new one some time later? Sounds about right.
- emitstop 14y agoI'm okay with this.
- afhof 14y agoSo if the buyer just left a bad rating, but no words, could she still be sued? One one hand voting seems like an extension of free speech, but on the other it feels that online voting shouldn't be counted as slander / libel.
- OGinparadise 14y agoThey would win but after going to court and spending money. The main problem is that anyone can file almost any type of lawsuit
- pacaro 14y agoAnd (in most jurisdictions) the tort of barratry[1] is no longer recognized. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barratry_(common_law) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barratry_(common_law)
- jvdh 14y agoThis seems like a very unfair situation for the company. Think about what would happen if this were the other way around. For example, buyer returns an article, sends it through the post, and for some reason it ends up at Med Express door with postage due. They leave a negative feedback on eBay about the user. The Internet would then also be up in arms about the company, 'abusing' its position to harm an underdog user.
- lowboy 14y agoPeople aren't up in arms about a negative review, they're up in arms about suing someone over a review. I think the reaction would be the same against the plaintiff if the roles were reversed and she sued Med Express for an negative review.
- jvdh 14y agoI agree, but the negative review does hurt their business, as much as it would hurt the reputation of the user in the other scenario. Of course, the user would not sue the company, but just use the Web to do some "swift justice" by spreading the word.
- qb45 14y agoThe buyer was indeed an assshole, but by filing a meritless lawsuit to force settlement the seller proved to be one as well. I couldn't care less about them. Until they went to court, that is. At this point the buyer should win because between these two assholes she's the one who did nothing illegal.
- joahua 14y agoThe notion that negative feedback ought somehow only be posted in event of egregious misdescription is a bizarre, Ebay-centric one. It was a bad customer experience - of course her response is negative! eBay have designed it this way, but many users probably aren't aware of the consequences of leaving feedback. You'd write a complaint card in a hotel with nary a second thought and no ill consequences. To be sued for what appears to be the same thing online is at best a gross overreaction.
- xarien 14y agoPeople need to look up from their computers / phones once in awhile and tone down the passive aggressive nature that pseudo anonymity has instilled in the lot of us. How hard is it to work things out without escalation?
- kls 14y agoAgreed this is becoming a huge problem in today's society. People interact with one another in a completely different manner than they do in the offline world. It is like when you remove the human interaction, the humanness of the other party is somehow diminished and that is a scary reality. Because when we as humans loose our association of another person being human, the worst of our nature rears it's ugly head.
- lucaspiller 14y agoI'm guessing his comment is a bit more like "THESE GUYS SUCK!!!!1111111" than "I had to pay $1.44 more for postage". IMO that is fair enough, he is in the wrong. OTOH I'm sure eBay have a process in place for this - I think suing him is a bit much. They could also just leave him negative feedback...
- ZoFreX 14y agoThe actual feedback is not only linked, but quoted in the article. Your guess was wrong.
- ultimoo 14y agoBuyers and Sellers leaving feedback for each other doesn't necessarily carry the symmetric property of equality. A Seller has more to lose or gain from feedback than a Buyer does.
- adamors 14y agohttp://feedback.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewFeedback2&userid=med_express_sales&iid=-1&de=off&items=25&which=negative&interval=180&_trkparms=negative_180 http://feedback.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewFeedback2&...
- Deestan 14y ago> I'm guessing his comment is a bit more like I cannot fathom why people prefer guessing things that are publicly available and only takes a few seconds to check.
- klearvue 14y agoBoth parties don't come off well here - the buyer could have given the seller the benefit of the doubt before posting a negative feedback over a trivial amount and the seller managed to turn an unjustified, in my opinion, negative feedback into a terrible publicity for itself.
- ultimoo 14y agoI think there is more context to the situation than what is discussed in the original post. Is the company generally an honest entity who always put their customers in front of everything and this was a one-time mistake? Or do they routinely "forget" to pay for postage and hope no one noties. etc.
- madsravn 14y agoDid the seller try contacting the buyer explaining the situation and offer to reimburse for problems etc? This could have been the first step in solving the situation, in my opinion.
- goostavos 14y ago>Both parties don't come off well here Glad someone is at least acknowledging that both parties are acting ridiculous. Granted, the seller has now taken it to a whole other level by getting litigious, but still, both are coming off like giant children. For whatever reason, either accidental, or deliberate, the postage was short $1.44. Not a big deal. The Med company offered to make it right, but the person left negative feedback over it anyway. Imagine if this was just an error. To have someone drag your name down even after offering a remedy has got to be beyond frustrating -- especially in an ecosystem like eBay's.
- tunesmith 14y agoBoy, if Ebay's policies are such that someone has incentive to sue someone else just for one negative feedback... I'm glad I don't use Ebay.
- pointyhatuk 14y agoMed Express is being an asshat. The buyer is being an asshat too. Med Express have a supposed reputation to defend which they have obviously really shown here i.e. sue anyone who says anything bad. The buyer also has a trigger finger for leaving negative feedback. Having been on the end of import duty having to be paid AND on the end of negative feedback for misquoting postage I understand both sides. However, eBay is a feedback battle ground these days to the point the feedback system is worthless. Buyers bend over and take anything from sellers who threaten them with fraud reports to PayPal, retaliation for leaving negative feedback and occasionally physical violence. Sellers bend over and take stuff from buyers who make false claims, leave negative feedback for terribly minor things and don't send payment. All of this results in a stalemate where both sides are forced to leave positive feedback. If you dare do anything else, shit will hit the fan, even if the service is a POS. It's a form of mutually assured destruction. All of the above is why I don't use eBay any more. There isn't an honest feedback rating anywhere on it. Let them fight - they are as bad as each other.
- Aardwolf 14y agoI think this is a problem with eBay. For some reason, sellers desperately need and want your good feedback, and a single bad feedback, even for something as tiny as a $1.44 postage stamp, seems to have a very bad impact on the seller. In real life, one bad review about something like this on someone with a good track record doesn't hurt the slightest bit. Why does it hurt so much in the eBay review system, and can't they improve that? (So that I don't have to feel guilty when not saying "super awesome 5 stars" to a seller who was just "good").
- DanBC 14y agoI've just started using ebay. I look at the feedback because I realise (from years of reading Amazon reviews) that people sometimes give bad feedback for something outside the seller's control, even if the seller tried to correct the error. So this bad feedback wouldn't have bothered me. But I guess some / many people don't check the details. When you have two sellers listing the same item with similar 'buy it now' prices and packaging I guess feedback is the only other metric someone can check. Since ebay sellers cut costs and profits as far as possible having similar prices is pretty common.
- shiftpgdn 14y agoIt actually expands far, far beyond that. eBay is extraordinarily merchant hostile and just a few back feedback over the course of a thousand auctions can trigger automated blocks that prevent you from listing more than a handful of auctions at a time[1]. For a major eBay seller this is basically a death sentence. Additionally your detailed seller rating or DSR determine how much of a discount you get on the extremely steep eBay feed[2]. Again for major sellers, especially people selling ultra low margin items such as phone accessories the 20% discount on ebay's final value fee will mean the difference between being able to competitively price their product and simply going out of business. [1]http://www.aspkin.com/forums/ebay-suspensions/29924-ebay-account-limited-please-help.html http://www.aspkin.com/forums/ebay-suspensions/29924-ebay-acc... [2]http://pages.ebay.com/services/buyandsell/powerseller/benefits/discounts_faq.html#4 http://pages.ebay.com/services/buyandsell/powerseller/benefi...
- 14y ago
- jakejake 14y agoI'm surprised eBay's term of service don't have something that would prevent suing over feedback.
- dagw 14y agoA ToS can never prevent you from being sued. At best they can help you get the case thrown out.
- entropy_ 14y agoWell, if the seller relies exclusively on eBay for sales(as appears to be the case here) then the threat of having their account terminated over ToS violation would be a huge deterrent against doing so. It still won't prevent you from being sued but it would definitely reduce the chances of it happening to near zero.
- jnardiello 14y agoI work for a popular brand selling accessories on eBay and Amazon. One of my duties is replying to customer care inquiries. We are a small start-up, our team is small, therefore happens quite often to spend hours every day replying to customers having a number of problems (postage problem, usage problem, etc..). I do totally understand the seller, they have done everything they could to make the buyer happy. The buyer, instead of giving a chance to the seller to make things right just left a bad feedback. I guess anybody can see how unfair this is. Feedbacks and reviews are supposed to give a hint to potential buyers about the service or product they will get. The truth is that more than often they are a "weapon" for frustrated buyers to revenge and damange the seller, without being anyhow responsible for it. This is unfortunate becouse bad reviews and bad feedbacks damage sellers not only with their reputation but also kill sales. Having a bad review on Amazon means to simply not sell that very particular product, doesn't really matter if the bad experience was due to inexpertise of the buyer or from a delivery problem (all things that are completely out of the sellers control). When you are a young company, it's hyper-frustrating to be damaged and see your sales killed or importantly reduced by a customer that was unhappy because of something you couldn't control in any possible way. While in such a situation the company must anyway step-up and take action to mitigate the problem (and they did as they offered a refund) the buyer must be responsible for actually damaging their business. It requires experience to understand that sometimes customers are just trolls spoilt by life and to just let it go. If you have a great company providing excellent products and services you'll make it up with future orders :)
- cjg 14y agoI think you are projecting your extensive experience with the review system onto the everyday buyer. eBay asked the shopper to review her transaction: overall her experience was negative (not enough postage) so she gave a negative review.
- cm2012 14y agoAs someone who runs ecom for a jewelry company on Amazon and eBay, I know that you mean.
- vacri 14y agoAll that being said, how can anyone think suing a customer over a single review is going to be a net PR win?
- CHsurfer 14y agoPersonally, I think lawyers should be dis-barred for bring a frivolous claim to court solely on the hopes of winning because the defended cannot afford to defend themselves. It is an abuse of the power they have been given with their right to practice law.
- robryan 14y agoeBay has one of the tightest set of rules of any marketplace sit on what constitutes something that they will remove. The guidelines pretty much state that legal action is your only option. Someone can for example leave a feedback stating 'item fake, seller a fraud' without the slightest piece of evidence (item may simply be from a different batch the customer is used to or defective) and there is nothing you can do, no process. Also when you want things from eBay such as a higher selling limit they raise individual negative feedbacks in an accusing way despite them being 0.1% or less of total feedback. I don't think this seller would have been effected by the feedback but I can certainly understand their frustration. The negative press from the case will do far worse for the seller. What buyer will feel safe buying from them?
- Kiro 14y agoI've never understood why it's so easy to sue people or companies in the US. What are the positive aspects? For me as an outsider it only seems to create fear and ridiculous warning labels.
- nnnnni 14y agoIDEALLY it's so that "the little man" has some course of action against negligent entities.
- oblio 14y agoAnd ideally, too, "the little man" should also have a gun, for a course of action against aggressive entities. I'm an European, I guess we just don't get it (the US legal system or the gun laws).
- zero_intp 14y agoStreisand effect incoming. Clearly the only answer is to engage in business with this entity for lowest value items available and then post negative reviews of their legal behavior.
- sdfjkl 14y agoI stopped using eBay when they canceled my auction because I had included a link to the PDF manual (on the manufacturer's site) of the phone I was selling. This was around 2006 and I assumed their idiotic policies would quickly see them replaced by a better platform, but for some reason this has never happened.
- devcpp 14y agoThe power of ebay resides in being able to find any product that comes to mind on auction at virtually any given time. Therefore, no one I know bothers to check the competition (if it even exists) before they bid. The same known problem occurs with Facebook regarding friends. I don't see any solution, this ease of use is more important to most customers than ToS.
- dustingetz 14y agothis is called http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly and is well studied
- photorized 14y agoDepending on where they are in their fiscal year, eBay seems to alternate between favoring buyers, or favoring sellers. I've used them through several pro-buyer and pro-seller cycles, and their actions were often unexpected, much like your PDF example.
- pi18n 14y agoThis is the sort of frivolous lawsuit that makes a complete mockery of legitimate torts. There needs to be some way to make courts award damages to the defendant in ridiculous cases without making it difficult for small parties to sue large ones over legitimate grievances.
- yebyen 14y agoFrivolous like posting a 1 star rating because the seller required you to pay $1.44 in shipping to complete the transaction? I'm not sure it's the lawsuit that's frivolous.
- pi18n 14y agoI'm fairly certain yours is not an objective opinion.
- yebyen 14y agoI think they will probably go down in court. Having done Amazon business in the past, and knowing what bad mojo it is to try to change the terms adding extra charges after the deal is signed, personally I would have just eaten the $1.44 fee. Then again, I never made a dime at Amazon, only just lost money and collected positive ratings... EDIT: I am being downvoted up the thread for taking a position that is not popular. I agree with Med Express that Ebay is culpable for this, as much as this must put me in the wrong legally. Where are the metamoderators? A 1-star review is the lowest rating that you can give. The seller took the item to the post office and mailed it, postage paid. For some reason it arrived with postage due. Now Med Express will probably be required to keep a reserve on their Ebay account for the next 6 months. Maybe it gained weight in the mail? Maybe buyers should post reviews that are fair and balanced. Was the item as described? Received on time? Damaged in transit? Did you communicate your issues to the seller, did they make an attempt to remunerate your concerns? If the pope hat article is remotely accurate, I would not have given this company a 1-star review. They did everything they could.
- 14y ago
- Karunamon 14y agoNegging someone on eBay for a buck in shipping is a pretty crappy thing to do, but then taking the other guy to court over the feedback is even worse. There are no winners in this situation.
- ScottWhigham 14y agoThe seller made sure that there would be no winners in this situation when they sent the item with insufficient postage. If that doesn't happen, the rest of this likely does not happen. "Negging someone on eBay for a buck in shipping is a pretty crappy thing to do" That's just not true - that may be your opinion but that's the opinion of a very small number of people. The majority - an overwhelming majority - believe that it one valuable part of such community feedback systems to provide a way for buyers to notify other perspective buyers of potential problems.
- Karunamon 14y ago>That's just not true Yes it is. I can forgive someone for being ignorant of the way the eBay feedback system works, but when you push that button, you are not just "notifying other perspective buyers of potential problems". It hasn't been that way for years. Not since eBay removed the ability to leave negative feedback for buyers, anyways. If I were the seller in this case, rather than going to court, and negative feedback was still around, I'd have left them the same with something like "PITA buyer, - feedback for being off $1 in shipping. AVOID." What you are actually doing when negging a seller is deciding "This seller made me so mad that I am going to cost them large amounts of reputation, raise their fees, restrict their ability to list, and possibly help drive them out of business". This is not an idle threat. Feedback is calculated over a 12 moth period, meaning if you only sell a couple things a year and get a single neg, you'll trip over all of the eBay restrictions and fee increases. Now let's get some perspective here. The seller delivered the item, as described. There are no complaints about the item itself, so we can assume the buyer is happy with it. Buyer's willing to mark the whole transaction as terrible over a freaking dollar? There are some levels of shenanigans to which this is an appropriate response. $1 is not. The more I think about it, the more I think there may be some merit to this case. If the seller offered to make the problem right and the buyer hit them anyways, given the effect that hit will have, is it possible they have a case?
- mnarayan01 14y agoThe feedback in question [1] appears to be a one star rating on a $175.00 item where $1.44 postage was required. I would guess that the seller's complaint is on the one star rating, not the message content (and on this I tend to agree with them -- the buyer is being a huge ass). That said, the one star is clearly an opinion, and thus not subject to slander laws. 1: http://feedback.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewFeedback2&userid=med_express_sales&iid=-1&de=off&items=25&which=negative&interval=180&_trkparms=negative_180 http://feedback.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewFeedback2&... Edit: I would also note that while generally I think popehat does good work, the part around "Mr. Amodio responded with an open, contemptuous, and contemptible threat to abuse the legal system" is...not so good; the following quote does not come from Mr. Amodio and does not contain anything obvious that would indicate either an open or contemptuous threat to abuse the legal system.
- downandout 14y agoThe case is clearly without merit. They almost certainly sued her hoping that she doesn't have the resources to respond to it, which would result in a default judgment against her. If she is able to get an attorney, she will wind up being awarded her legal expenses and potentially other damages since the case was pretty clearly filed in bad faith. The choice to include eBay as a defendant in the suit, however, is clearly not well thought out. Med Express has filed a precedent-setting, must-win case against a company that effectively has unlimited resources. eBay will eviscerate this company in court and almost certainly ensure that they never do business through the site again. Since no attorney in their right mind would have advised such a move, this sounds like a misguided individual that managed to borrow enough money for the filing fee rather than a serious attempt at litigation.
- Vivtek 14y agoFrom the article, it would appear there is in fact an attorney in the loop - who doesn't appear to know that this is a mistake.
- DannyBee 14y agoThey know it is, they either don't care, or their client doesn't care.
- will_brown 14y agoAgreed, unless eBay's terms of service includes a grace period for sellers to cure these kinds of breaches of the sale terms. Otherwise it does not bode well that the plaintiff's attorney admitted the review was truthful(as truth is a defense to defamation/libel claims). I tend to agree Defendant should not only win but recover her attorney's fees and costs for Plaintiff's "failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted".
- anonymous 14y agoHe admitted that the words in the review are true, but is the "negative" flag on the review true or deserved? From what I understand, just a few negative reviews can ruin someone's business on ebay and posting a negative review over 1.44$ and threatening their business sounds like a rather severe over-reaction.
- hluska 14y agoIn the last twelve months, Med_Express_Sales has received two pieces of negative feedback. The negative feedback in question read: "Order arrived with postage due with no communication from seller beforehand." To which Med_Express replied: "Sorry- no idea there was postage due. This has happened alot from USPS lately." In August 2012, another user posted the following negative review: "Items were listed as new and they were used, they worked good but used" In this case, Med_Express replied: "They were new, but you can return them. We'll even pay return shipping!" Looking at this wholly from a customer service perspective, I think that the two replies are dramatically different. In the first case, their reply passed responsibility over to USPS and made no mention of any compensation. In the second case, the reply specifically disputed the buyer's allegation, but also promised to make things right. I think that most buyers are sophisticated enough to weigh the negative feedback with the seller's response. And, in this case, I think that Med_Express_Sales damaged their own brand with a less than satisfactory response.
- kabdib 14y agoA guy sold me an HP calculator, advertised as "in perfect condition" while in fact keys on it were broken, it was badly warped, and cigarette ashes were falling out of it. I gave him negative feedback and he went ballistic, saying "You should have sent me a message privately, rather than give me bad feedback! I've been on eBay for ten years with no bad feedback. I would have made it up to you." I explained that his kind of behavior was exactly what bad feedback was for. eBay feedback is badly broken if people aren't supposed to actually use it.
- fooie 14y agofor $5 you can leave your own opinionated first amendment protected review: http://www.ebay.com/sch/med_express_sales/m.html?_ipg&_from&_nkw&_armrs=1&_sop=15 http://www.ebay.com/sch/med_express_sales/m.html?_ipg&_f...
- ryanmarsh 14y ago"Med Express immediately offered to reimburse Nicholls for the postage due amount. Despite this offer, and before giving Med Express a chance to reimburse her, Nicholls on February 26, 2013..." It looks like Med Express didn't have the opportunity to fix their mistake before Nicholls started posting negative reviews. I don't understand why everyone is hating on Med Express. Imagine a similar hypothetical: If I made a mistake and offered immediately to correct it but instead was blasted via social media before I had the chance to correct things how would I feel? I'd be pretty upset. This is what the system is for, actors that are personally unknown to each other, not a part of the same small scale geographic community, seeking a resolution to a perceived wrong. Who on HN thinks Med Express should have been compassionate and understanding of Nicholls response without regard for the fact that repuation is critical to the survial of Med Express on eBay?
- darkarmani 14y ago> Who on HN thinks Med Express should have been compassionate and understanding of Nicholls response without regard for the fact that repuation is critical to the survial of Med Express on eBay? The feedback only commented that they had to pay shipping costs and that it wasn't mentioned by the seller up front. What is the problem with truthful statements using a system designed to give feedback? > If I made a mistake and offered immediately to correct it but instead was blasted via social media before I had the chance to correct things how would I feel? I'd be pretty upset. And that would give you the right to use any means to get back at the person? This wasn't social media. This was a forum designed for feedback.