4 ms·
I am from a country(India) where reservations and quotas are as rampant as breathing. Quotas and reservations are disastrous to any community over the longer ru
by kamaal 14y ago
I am from a country(India) where reservations and quotas are as rampant as breathing. Quotas and reservations are disastrous to any community over the longer run.
The only place where reservations make any impact is areas where there are too many good candidates and somebody from the lesser privileged sections of the society who is equally good can't make it due to the limited availability of opportunities. In such cases it makes some sense to offer the minorities a degree of reservation as the culture is unwelcoming to a meritorious minority person.
Any thing apart from this and what you will see is, the social problems remain totally unchanged. Reservations and quotas means some one from privileged class who is deserving of a position will be denied the opportunity, and some one oppressed class who is not deserving will get the opportunity instead. The net result is the whole system will be poisoned. Work never gets done, more and more hard working people are denied opportunities. At the same undeserving people get the same opportunities and make a big waste out of them.
If some one is good, they will win anyway. If they are not, they can't and won't.
Our job is to create a level playing field. So that anybody who want's to, can deliver.
- anthonyb 14y agoAh, right. No women in tech because they're not very good at it. Gotcha.
- kamaal 14y agoSorry, where did I say that? I only say there must be a level playing field so that hard working women get same chances as men. Reservations create a scenario where you are lower the entry bar for A group of people. While keeping it high for B group of people. Net result is there will no motivation for A set of people to try anything extra since they are guaranteed an entry anyway. At the same a certain set of people from B will stop doing any good work because regardless of their work, A's are going to get their chances. The whole system collapses. India has tried this for the past 60 years. The situation has only gone worse. Work should be done to help women win without reservations.
- anthonyb 14y agoYou dance around it, but that's what you're saying. What else would explain the < 5% female speaker rate at conferences? Obviously the good women are making it, and the rest... just aren't very good. "Reservations" or whatever you want to call them are lowering the bar to the same level as other people, but of course the "B"s are going to scream blue murder because they now have to work instead of cruising.
- woah 14y agoDoes anybody know the proportion of women in tech? If there is a lower proportion of women speaking at conferences than in the industries that the conferences are about, you may have a point.
- klipt 14y agoOr maybe there are just more men than women in tech to start off with (in which case it's hardly surprising there are also more men at conferences). The problem needs to be fixed at the middle school level (or earlier) where girls are discouraged from technical subjects.
- kamaal 14y agoThe worst I've seen is Mechanical Engineering course in my engineering. In all my four years of Engineering course. There wasn't one single girl in all four batches of Mechanical Engineering branch.
- gnarbarian 14y agoWomen do not constitute 50% of the people in tech it makes sense for them to be a minority when presenting. Why are they a minority in tech in the first place? Well video games got me and most of my friends into tech, and when I was in high-school in the mid 90s most girls abhorred games and considered them childish and geeky. It was a serious social faux pas to be a tech geek who loved hacking around with computers and playing video games. I never met a single girl in the 90s who was into it beyond playing an occasional game of Mario Kart. Who are we to blame for that?
- icelancer 14y agoHave we considered the underlying issues that might actually make your strawman argument true?
- belorn 14y agoThat's a horrible comment that deserve being down voted into the ground. Not only is it a strawman argument, but it also reiterates sexist claims about women. At best, your comment gets ignored and worst, the comment will work against creating gender equality.
- anthonyb 14y agoIt's not a strawman, it's called argumentum ad absurdum. If we take his premise as true: > If some one is good, they will win anyway. If they are not, they can't and won't. The conclusion from that is that the lack of women in tech is because they're not very good at it. If women were good at tech, then from his statement there would be more of them (they would "win anyway"). This is clearly absurd - hence he's wrong, or at least needs to support/make his argument a little better. Do I really need to stick </sarcasm> tags on everything?
- return0 14y agoSnarky comments are not constructive. You have to back up your opinion with facts either way.
- anigbrowl 14y agoI know! Why didn't those undeserving people make the decision to be born into privilege when they had the chance?
- kamaal 14y agoThese days due to reservations, people want to be born in lower castes in India. Because there a lot of free perks, reservations and generally people get a lot of things with little effort. Compare this with the general merit category where even true meritorious students are denied their due. In India there are protests by groups asking the government to name them as backwards classes. For more information read examples like : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Gurjar_unrest_in_Rajasthan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Gurjar_unrest_in_Rajasthan
- jim_kaiser 14y ago"These days due to reservations, people want to be born in lower castes in India." Pure unadulterated bullshit or trolling. Er.. I'm from India too.. and kamaal.. you seem to be stuck in the small college student protests about reservation around 7 - 8 years ago. Nobody wants to be born in a lower caste. In the end, such comments are just jokes. India's social playing field is still more important to the ordinary people. Especially when castes play a big role in marriages in India, the next most important thing after society as a whole. So, i have to ask... whats your angle kamaal. Convincing HN that reservations are bad is going to make no difference on the politics of India. You seem to be ranting about it every chance you get (and against poor people from the last comment i read). Also, your rant here is only against the backward sections of society, which have been denied equal opportunities for ages and have now become a political pawn in the reservations fiasco. I question this, because India, as you know has reservations for women too, already in many educational institutions, pending in the parliament. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Womens_Reservation_Bill http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Womens_Reservation_Bill So, instead of quoting something relevant like the impact of various reservations the country has implemented for women, you seem to just pout out your own agenda. Don't wanna make the world a better place? Please don't try to make it worse.
- shabda 14y ago(I am from India too.) There is a provable, significant difference is earning/wealth between different castes in India[1]. If you believe that there is no difference between people depending on their caste, this is situation you want to remedy. If there has been systematic discrimination against a class of people, spanning centuries, they can not compete without providing affirmative action. Quota's are a way to level the playing field. "If some one is good, they will win anyway. If they are not, they can't and won't." Not if the means of productions, wealth and power is hoarded by a few. [1] http://www.ras.org.in/income_inequality_and_caste_in_village_india http://www.ras.org.in/income_inequality_and_caste_in_village...
- FlyingSnake 14y agoThis. I was born and raised in rural India and have seen numerous Dalits benefit from reservations. Reservations in India is a complex sociological arrangement and deeply linked with Casteism and systematic repression for centuries. Just citing few examples of candidates from non-deserving backward castes is not enough to invalidate reservations. There have been attempts to hijack the issue for political political gains, but that's the problem with the political class, not with the Reservations.
- kamaal 14y agoA: Number of people who benefit from reservations. B: Number of people who suffer because of reservations. Over the years B has been far too larger than A. Thanks to the IT boom in the 90's. One of the biggest reasons best people from India left to the west was because their much deserved opportunity went to some one who didn't do 1/10th the work they did.
- shabda 14y ago[Citation Needed for the B > A claim]
- FlyingSnake 14y agoPulling numbers out of thin air is not advisable at a data driven and citation based forum like HN.
- brador 14y agoInteresting. So you're saying have an extra seat reserved for minorities only, and the minority on the seat must have the appropriate qualifications. That way no one is disadvantaged by the new system. That's actually a great way of doing things and i'm surprised it's not used more.
- anuraj 14y agoYou are speaking with a sense of entitlement which is vain. Backward castes and Dalits constitute 75% of the population of India. So if the electorate decided they need affirmative action as even after 60 years of independence, their representation remains below 20% in white collar jobs, then it is their prerogative. Since when do the minority dictate terms to a majority in a democratic polity. Grow up dude, and be thankful that you still have 50% seats in general category and that is given to you by the will of the majority.
- rdl 14y agoThe whole point of constitutional systems is that the majority can't infringe the rights of a minority even by majority vote. I'm not as familiar with the Indian political system as with the US and Europe, but there's a reason no one does unrestricted democracy without limits on state authority.
- anuraj 14y agoThere is an unprecedented case in India where 75% of population was subjected to persecution for thousands of years in the name of caste and one generation is not enough to get back the ability to compete in general category, especially for people who were regarded as untouchables. How will ensuring 50% of jobs for 75% of the populace, by their elected representatives infringe on minority rights? This is called social justice - opposite of which is fascism.