3 ms·
I blogged [1] about Detroit (I grew up just north of 8 mile for a time) recently and my solution to the overarching problem of the city was/is: a tax holiday f
by mgkimsal 14y ago
I blogged [1] about Detroit (I grew up just north of 8 mile for a time) recently and my solution to the overarching problem of the city was/is: a tax holiday for residents of Detroit.
The biggest problem Detroit has is declining population of income-producing people. Yes, there are issues of businesses for people to work at being in the city, but let's face it, people will drive to work wherever they are, at least until there's much better public transport there.
Businesses get tax breaks to locate in particular areas - why don't residents? Michigan could/should introduce a 10 year state tax holiday for residents of Detroit. If you live in Detroit the city, you pay 0% state income tax (or... a reduced sliding scale or something like that).
People will move there. People will relocate there. Supporting businesses will follow - more restaurants to serve local residents - residents who are earning, not the left-behind/leftover residents of a hollowed out city. Almost everyone who can get out of Detroit has already.
Efforts of entrepreneurs to turn things around are good and should be applauded, but the problem is of a bigger scale than most people realize, and imo should be tackled at a state level via tax incentives (a great social engineering tool). One rebuttal I got to this is many in surrounding areas (Royal Oak, Ferndale, Easpointe, etc) would object because they'd be losing residents to Detroit. It probably would happen some, but the entire area has lost a lot of population as more people leave the region (and state) than move in.
As companies try to lure people back - I've heard from more than a few people that Ford is hiring aggressively - "no state income tax if you live in Detroit" would be a nice extra incentive.
[1] http://michaelkimsal.com/blog/solution-to-detroits-current-problems/ http://michaelkimsal.com/blog/solution-to-detroits-current-p...
- elmuchoprez 14y agoThe median US household income is something like $50k/year. Probably lower in Michigan, but we'll call it $50k. Michigan has a 4.25% income tax, so eliminating that would be a savings of $2,125. But you have to pay federal tax on that. Let's just say you're paying 15%. So now we're talking a savings of about $1,800. $1,800/year isn't chump change, but it's also not a life altering amount of money. For me personally, it's nowhere near enough money to put up with all the negatives that come with Detroit.
- mgkimsal 14y agoPeople that earn more would save more, and would have more incentive to move there, especially if you can get larger tracts of land to have a bit of privacy. Yes there are negatives, but the solutions are going to need to come from getting larger numbers of working/earning people living there day in and day out. Adding another casino or ballpark will do pretty much 0 for Detroit as a whole - it'll make the few square miles in downtown prettier, but people will just continue to drive in and out, nothing more. People jumped through hoops a few years back to 'save' a few thousand for the 'new home buyer tax credit', which basically landed them with a mortgage. And that was a one time event. A family saving $2k+/year for, say 10 years, would be, if not life altering, certainly a modest incentive. Individuals making a decision like this won't be enough - it needs to be large groups who have enough purchasing power to attract other businesses/jobs to Detroit as a whole.
- gopi 14y agoActually Michigan tax free areas are already there in a small scale for both business and people. They are called Michigan renaissance zones -http://www.michiganadvantage.org/Renaissance-Zones http://www.michiganadvantage.org/Renaissance-Zones In my opinion MI income tax is low a tax holiday will not move the needle for most people but if Federal taxes are eliminated that may be effective. Also i am not sure its constitutionally legal for our federal govt to give tax preference to some states/cities.