7 ms·
Paul Krugman (1998): By 2005 Internet will have no more economic impact than fax
- rayiner 14y agoWhile he missed this particular one, he's not wrong (and note that he's wrong for social reasons more than technological ones). People generally overestimate how quickly technology will change in the future. In 1998, I was fretting over the 333 MHz processor that had just come out rendering my 300 MHz processor obsolete. Today, I'm happily using a 2010 MacBook Air with a processor that was already almost three years old when the thing was brand new. I don't think I saw that coming in 1998. What people generally get wrong is the shape of technology curves, which are generally S-shaped rather than exponential. Low-hanging fruit yields exponential growth at first, then advancement becomes difficult and capital-intensive. The amount of capital being spent to e.g. keep up with Moore's low is breathtaking. So if a technology is advancing rapidly now, it probably won't look all that different 30 years from now. It's the unexpected technologies that you have to watch out for.
- JamesArgo 14y agoOne of the reasons Moore's law seems to be slowing more than it is, is Intel is putting most of their new transistors into integrated graphics.
- rayiner 14y agoMoore's law as a practical matter has been dead for awhile. If you hold capital expenditures to achieve a given level of improvement constant in real dollars, the pace has slowed dramatically since say the late 1980's. What's been hiding the extent of the slowdown is exponential increases in capital expenditures.
- rdl 14y agoIt is kind of interesting to think self aware AI, under certain assumptions, and thus possibly the "singularity", could be an issue of an extra decade of Moore's law or not.
- grannyg00se 14y ago"It's the unexpected technologies that you have to watch out for." Some would argue that the unexpected technologies are what keep technology curves exponential rather than S-shaped. (I'm thinking of Kurzweil here). Once advancement starts to slow something else crops up and re-energizes progress, keeping the exponential growth curve intact.
- rayiner 14y agoIt doesn't make a lot of sense to think of "the technological curve" as opposed to various technological curves. If you look at things like power technology, aerospace, medicine, etc, improvements have not been exponential in the last 5-6 decades.
- gregschlom 14y agoSo he was wrong, no doubt about that. But I'd be interested in an analysis on why he was wrong? What assumptions he made to reach his conclusion proved out to be untrue?
- nl 14y agoThat's a really good question. After thinking about it a bit, I'd suggest it was technological naivety - he didn't see ecommerce coming (!?) or thought that there was some reason it would fail. I suspect he was deliberately being contrarian and pessimistic too.
- flipcoder 14y agoHe wasn't wrong if you consider he was talking about macro. He appears to be addressing the claim that the standard of living was going to shoot up so high that we'd all be able to live cheaply and not work as much. He predicted instead that demand would stay high since more tech would cause us to keep wanting more. Sometimes I think there are more anti-Krugman people than actual economists... disclaimer: I only read a small part of the article
- podperson 14y agoHis comment about WordPerfect 5.1 for DOS suggests he missed the significance of the GUI too. I think he didn't realize the web and email would see truly widespread adoption versus merely being another thing that made the tiny minority of people who (really) used computers slightly happier.
- nl 14y agoI think his predictions were consciously pessimistic, designed to underline the title of the article Why most economists' predictions are wrong. I figure he scored 2/5 (The American triumphalism lasted until 2001, and the raw-material crunch happened multiple times).
- coldtea 14y agoNot to mention the pace of tech change (computing-wise) seems to slow down, unless we can do something about Moore's law that doesn't involve 2000 cores, battery life, and such.
- nl 14y agoI don't understand your comment. The pace of tech change doesn't seem to be slowing down to me. The iPad was only released 3 years ago and yet now even government websites are optimizing for tablets.
- coldtea 14y ago>The iPad was only released 3 years ago and yet now even government websites are optimizing for tablets. So? The tablets are not a leap as not having computers -> having computers, or mainframes -> personal computers, were. It's a small incremental update.
- nl 14y agoEverything seems like small incremental updates when you are too close to it. If we expand it to "mobile" (ie, tablets & smartphones - and don't forget how recent smartphone usage is) then it's pretty easy to argue that mobile is a bigger leap than anything you listed given how it has made computing resources usable by the vast majority of the worlds population.
- coldtea 14y ago>Everything seems like small incremental updates when you are too close to it. Not really. The jump from "computers are for banks" to "everyone has one" and from "no internet" to "full world wide web" seemed like full-blown updates to me, and I was close to both. The same can be said the jump from EGA 1988 IBM PC to 2000 full blown multimedia PC. The jump from PC to tablet? Not so much. The jump from 2000 PC to 2013 PC? Not so much either. Heck, a huge percentage of people still use XP, which was out in 2001.
- guylhem 14y agoWhat is the point in beating a dead horse ? Krugman is often wrong. He got a nobel prize, good for him, but we should not take his opinions - or the opinion of any nobel prize or other authority figures - as words from the gods. Remember, past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results - and this is as good as an example as it gets. At least I reckon he made a testable prediction this time. We are all human and faillible. What authority figures may provide is better calibration - ie not being humble or arrogant, but say how good their prediction is, and not be wrong too often (http://yudkowsky.net/rational/technical http://yudkowsky.net/rational/technical). At least, we should hold them to that standard since their past declarations are available to the public and can be tested against current results.
- stcredzero 14y ago> Krugman is often wrong. He got a nobel price, Being wrong now and then is excusable, clearly.
- guylhem 14y agoAs someone else said, "He's gotten remarkably good at not making testable recommendations or predictions." With a bad spirit, one could say he got medal for that. Yet his work on new trade theory in international commerce, and how the european union data contradicted standard HOS theory is quite interesting. He should have kept to that. But when your self proclaimed intention is to be a voice from the left (or the right, or anything) and have political impact instead of academic impact, you may have to take distance from reality :-/
- stcredzero 14y agoMy main point was the spelling error.
- guylhem 14y agoOops. I stand corrected! 11pm and going to bed here, but I fill fix the typo first. It could make a bad taste joke, since it's obviously not for sale ;-)
- martythemaniak 14y agoFYI: Digging up old, unrelated things Krugman has said that are wrong isn't going to make your bitcoins worth more. For those of you confused why this is a top item, Krugman wrote a bitcoin piece today: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/15/opinion/krugman-the-antisocial-network.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/15/opinion/krugman-the-antiso...
- guylhem 14y agoI'm sorry, but how constructive is your comment really? Do you think it's and ad-hominem on Krugman? He's not popular with me, but even leaving that aside, there's something more here. Some say love and passion are two sides of the same coin, and the only separate sentiment is indifference. He sure seems to hate bitcoin with a passion now. Today's article is at least not as bad as his last piece from only 3 days before, krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/04/12/adam-smith-hates-bitcoin/ that was discussed here. At least this time in the article he properly acknowledged bitcoin as the "ultimate fiat currency", that's an evolution. Yet he still sees nothing wrong with quantitative easing and the greenback, and compare that situation to the goldbugs. Poeple who are too optimistic about gold do not necessarily have to be right to make a good investment - if the fiat currencies are doing down, that alone would make gold an interesting investment (I for one would not place a single cent in a heavy precious metal the US government has already confiscated in the past following executive orders) Just notice how sentimentally charged his article are - look at the keywords in the titles, "hate" or "antisocial". It would be interesting to grab them all and feed them into a sentiment analysis software, to see how he positionned himself on other topics in the past, and if these position evolves over time. Still, it's weird and funny. Does he intend to write a bitcoin article a day when the $300 cap is reached? He should post them on bitcoin related sites and rename his blog.
- martythemaniak 14y agoHe is a prolific blogger (2-3 items per day, about 6-7 days a week) and he has written about bitcoin a grand total of 3 times over the 3 years. The feelings he seems to have for bitcoin are much worse than hate - it's bemused indifference, which must be what drives bitbugs so mad.
- gojomo 14y agoAs much as I'd like to Krugman-bash, with respect to the implied context of his prediction -- the Internet's effect on the macroeconomy, overall income growth, and standard-of-living -- it wasn't that bad of a prediction. The Internet has massively changed many industries and our ways of living and communicating, especially those of us active on HN. But, the impact in the macro statistics is still.. meh. See also Peter Thiel's laments and Tyler Cowen on 'the great stagnation'. Personally, I suspect there's been a lot of qualitative improvement that doesn't show up in the time-series statistics. (For example, we're taking a lot of the benefit of the Internet in economically-unmetered leisure/shirking.) Also, I'd guess much of the benefit of new computer/telecom efficiencies has just helped offset continuing losses to outdated and parasitic arrangements by entrenched incumbents. (That is: the Internet's boosts-to-growth have somewhat hidden the continuing losses-to-growth from festering things like anti-competitive regulations, socially-broken education and medical incentives, and income-sapping entitlement program financing/payments.) Net-net, we're still on the same (or even a slowed) long-term income trend, whereas if we fully addressed these older things, we'd be seeing the full bonanza of Internet technology.
- guylhem 14y agoI strongly disagree about a "qualitative improvement". facebook may be fun, but not that fun if you can't put a dollar value on it or the surrounding ecosystem. The great stagnation is a real issue. There is a visible disconnect in the growth rate of OECD countries. It's not just reaching Solow long term equilibrium - it happened too fast. It's just weird and troubling. Hopefully the "rest of the world" will keep growing and improving the human lot. Too bad for OECD countries.
- gwern 14y agoI pointed this out on Reddit http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1bl0jd/in_2011_paul_krugman_said_bitcoin_was_stupid_in/c983uq7 http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1bl0jd/in_2011_paul... (that Krugman was merely making a well-known point in the academic literature that 'you can see the computer age everywhere but the statistics'). Didn't get much of a reception.
- crazy1van 14y agoAll this talk of Krugman reminds me that there's an awful lot of scientism out there today -- beliefs masquerading as science. The scientific method has been thrown out the window in this regard. If someone is going to propose a theory they claim is proven in someway, I want them to also identify the specific event that if it occurs will disprove their theory. The whole economics profession is filled with scientism, but my two pet peeve issues on this are stimulus spending to fix the economy and man made global warming. For them to be viable scientific theories, there must be an observable event that if actually observed would disprove the theories. Without that, they are just beliefs. Nothing against beliefs, but let's not call them scientific theories.
- snowwrestler 14y agoGlobal warming is disprovable at numerous points of evidence. - Disprove the absorbtion and emission spectra of greenhouse gases like CO2, methane, and water vapor. - Disprove correlations between measurements of fossil fuel usage and measurements of rising CO2 atmospheric concentrations. - Disprove measurements of changing carbon isotope ratios in the atmosphere. - Show that the oceans absorb CO2 more quickly that currently estimated. - Show that insolation has recently increased more than previously thought. - Show that measurements of recent global temperature rise are wrong. etc.
- pcvarmint 14y agohttp://library.mises.org/books/Helmut%20Schoeck/Scientism%20and%20Values.pdf http://library.mises.org/books/Helmut%20Schoeck/Scientism%20...
- parasubvert 14y agoThis is wrong, though I empathize. Social scientists come up with useful models that help explain events and behaviours, that aren't disproven by empirical evidence. There are plenty of ways to falsify a social science theory: wait long enough, or study enough data, and you'll amass enough empirical evidence to determine whether your theory holds up or not. Of course, this does not mean it is proven - there may be a falsifiable data point some day. But that's why we call it a theory. Environmental science is somewhat harder because the timescales are much longer than we have existed. But we also have well established ways of estimating the climate of ancient eras. This is why global warming is considered a scientific theory. In economics, there is, for example, a lot of evidence these days in favor of the standard Keynesian IS-LM model for a macroeconomy in liquidity trap conditions, and a dearth of evidence supporting neoclassical models and Real Business Cycle theory. This is almost a paradigm re-shift, in that a previously abandoned paradigm (by many), thought by some to have been falsified, is actually proving more predictive with respect to actual events than previously recognized. Unfortunately economics is closely intertwined with politics and ideology which doesn't mix well with science -- thus the profession is in crisis. An alternative, I suppose, is to go "full Austrian" and presume economics is an inherently unfalsifiable subject, based on fundamental logical truths. Thus it is justified to ignore all empirical evidence and mathematical analysis in favor of deductive praxeology. This is what Von Mises and Rothbard (founder of the US Libertarian party) believed, and they've been a common source of contra-Krugman arguments.
- snowwrestler 14y agoI tend give more weight to what people say when they are in their area of personal expertise. Krugman on economics, I give a lot of credit. He's demonstrably an expert on that topic. Krugman on the Internet or politics, less so.
- ashamedlion 14y agoWhat happens when the topic of discussion is the intersection between the Internet and economics?
- cromwellian 14y agoKrugman isn't perfect, but he actually has been one of the more accurate prognisticators (http://www.poynter.org/latest-news/mediawire/130485/claim-krugman-is-top-prognosticator-cal-thomas-is-the-worst/ http://www.poynter.org/latest-news/mediawire/130485/claim-kr...) More importantly, Krugman actually admits when he is wrong based on new data, as he has done on several occasions in his blog and the NYT. To me, that is the mark of a scientist, one who is able to be swayed by data. Very few of the Austrians and Chicago types seem to admit to being wrong, and often, contradictory data is simply waved away as conspiratorial (inflation, econometrics). The whole notion of praxeology turns their conclusions into untestable pseudo-science. It takes on the air of a religion rather than geeky engineers willing to hold their ideas to fire of real world tests. There are two issues at play here: the deep desire of technolibertarians for "free money" and decentralization, and moral arguments surrounding the function of the state and application of force, and the real world where their predictions often fail. It's possible to love Bitcoin, but also admit Krugman is right about it. Bitcoin is a magnificent creation of cryptography. In fact, the entire field of modern cryptography, from one way functions, zero knowledge proofs, oblivious transfer, to high level schemes involving money, voting, homomorphic encryption, et al, is staggering beautiful. When I first read of Broadcast Encryption, despite its use in DRM, my mind was blown. I love all this stuff, and have a deep affinity for subversive systems. But Bitcoin isn't the anarchocapitalist utopia enabler that converts the world into Galt's Gulch, because the deep beliefs about how a totally free economy would work in practice don't have to be any more true than the beliefs about how anarcho-syndicalist communities would work when scaled up. The real world is complex, and a mixed set of strategies is more adaptive and stable than a set of purist ones.
- nateabele 14y agoAh, Krugman... love that guy. He's my favorite comedian! > But Bitcoin isn't the anarchocapitalist utopia enabler that converts the world into Galt's Gulch [...] I think the Austrians would be the first to admit that the world is complex.[0] ;-) To be fair, BitCoin has come extraordinarily far in an incredibly short period of time. Just imagine trying to explain its present-day state to almost anyone two to three years ago. It seems to me, the whole point of this posting is that trying to judge BitCoin as a technolibertarian savior today is a bit like judging the internet's equivalence to a fax machine in 1998: it's just too early to tell, especially if (like Krugman), you have so little vision. Who knows, maybe BitCoin is only cryptocurrency's ARPANET. Just give it a minute. [0] http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/102966-the-curious-task-of-economics-is-to-demonstrate-to-men http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/102966-the-curious-task-of-e...
- egsec 14y ago"Sometime in the next 20 years, maybe sooner, there will be another '70s-style raw-material crunch: a disruption of oil supplies, a sharp run-up in agricultural prices, or both. And suddenly people will remember that we are still living in the material world and that natural resources matter. " Very true, in consideration of the article on the Rent seeking economy recently posted (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5548730 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5548730). Vanity, thy name is apps.
- cpursley 14y agoHas anyone ever listened to Paul Krugman? Well, yes, unfortunately. 'Krugman's Call for a Housing Bubble" http://mises.org/daily/6372/ http://mises.org/daily/6372/
- ChuckMcM 14y agoI love this prognostication: "The growth of the Internet will slow drastically, as the flaw in "Metcalfe's law"--which states that the number of potential connections in a network is proportional to the square of the number of participants--becomes apparent: most people have nothing to say to each other! By 2005 or so, it will become clear that the Internet's impact on the economy has been no greater than the fax machine's." It hinges on a such a fundamental misconception of humanity. It matters not that people have nothing to say to each other, they will still talk at each other! But more importantly humanity has an endless depth of vanity that can only be treated but never filled by an endless depth of drivel. Never before in our history have so many said so much to so many with so little content. Ok, enough pith for now. :-)