7 ms·
From a purported abridged chatlog with the alleged hacker: > 05:42 < ryan||> credit cards were encrypted, sadly both the private and public keys were stored on
by danso 14y ago
From a purported abridged chatlog with the alleged hacker:
> 05:42 < ryan||> credit cards were encrypted, sadly both the private and public keys were stored on the webserver so that provides 0 additional security
> 06:00 < ryann> They did try to encrypt them, but using public key encryption doesn't work if you have the public and private key in the same directory
http://turtle.dereferenced.org/~nenolod/linode/linode-abridged.txt http://turtle.dereferenced.org/~nenolod/linode/linode-abridg...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jlgreco 14y agoWouldn't doing that be a massive PCI violation? Aren't there extensive audits for this sort of thing?
- tptacek 14y agoExtensive PCI audits. Heh.
- jimktrains2 14y agoLike the "scan" that said our linux boxes were running an out-of-date version of IIS.
- psychometry 14y agoThat compliance web form I absentmindedly clicked through sure had a lot of buttons.
- larrys 14y agoCan't think of the exact word to describe that practice (what you did in response to the long list of questions which I've seen) but on the part of the company requesting you to answer the questions it's more or less a "absence of malice" type of thing that allows them to appear that they are doing the right thing while fully knowing that people are doing what you are doing. It's a "we will look the other way until we need to show that it's not our fault because we have passed the liability to you - look you acknowledge doing all the right things".
- 3825 14y agoIt does not mean anything until they decide you are not compliant and you need to prove you are compliant. (I've never had to but I'd appreciate insight from people who have)
- pointyhatuk 14y agoErr no. PCI DSS is basically farts in the wind. Its beyond useless and the testing agencies are all snake oil salesmen.
- toomuchtodo 14y agoI've done PCI "audits" for several companies I've worked for; it's a checklist you go down yourself. That's why its called a "pci self assessment".
- tptacek 14y agoActually, if you're processing cards directly, you do in fact need to have an PCI-qualified outside firm† (a QSA) audit you for PCI compliance. But those audits are notoriously superficial; PCI audits are a race-to-the-bottom affair. † We are not one of those.
- trafficlight 14y agoEvery one of these reviews that I've been involved in has been conducted by a couple of guys with laughable abilities.
- tptacek 14y agoThe quality of PCI security audits is a continual aggravation to everyone I routinely talk to in my industry. I've told more than one client: if you need a QSA audit, get the cheapest one you can. If you need a software security assessment, don't use a QSA firm.
- flyt 14y agoNote that you hire those firms yourself, and they work for you. They want you to pass the audit and will work to make that happen.
- larrys 14y ago"But those audits are notoriously superficial" Will add that just having gone through an ICANN registrar audit (which by the way were specified and supposed to be done literally 10 or 12 years ago but never requested by ICANN) with a third party company hired (accounting firm) it's total compliance theater. Add: "hired by ICANN after a bidding process". Same happened with data escrow which was just implemented a few years ago and is operated by Iron Mountain.
- FlyingAvatar 14y agoMost PCI audits are not mandatory unless you have had a breech that compromises data. Before that "self-certification" reigns.
- Thebigcheeze 14y agoCompanies are split into PCI Levels based on how much money/customers they handle. Level 1 are big companies like amazon, level 2 are medium sized online retailers generally, and level 3 are smaller retailers. The 'lower' your level, the easier the PCI audits are. If you are level 1 you have mandatory external audits. If you are level 2 you have a 'self assessment' which is basically a checklist which says "Yes, I promise I'm in compliance". If you have a confirmed breach, you are upgraded to Level 1 merchant audit requirements. This is generally quite costly as the external audit is extensive and must be paid for.
- bifrost 14y agoThe audits are toothless and ultimately the audit only happens once (if ever) and people keeping pub/secret key in the same place unprotected... well.... They're just unlikely to get security at all...
- tomjen3 14y agoThe paste-bin link he provided seems to time out for me. But if the things he claim in there is even half way true, nobody involved with linode should ever be allowed to be in business every again.
- Tomdarkness 14y agopastebin is a directory listing of linode.com - trying out a few of the files checks out, including very difficult to guess file names such as: http://www.linode.com/y_key_57284cb2de704e02.html http://www.linode.com/y_key_57284cb2de704e02.html
- jaxbot 14y agoAm I the only one who is more confused about why there are compiled java classes and AMI BIOS updates in the www directory than about the hacking itself?
- 286c8cb04bda 14y ago> Am I the only one who is more confused about why there are compiled java classes and AMI BIOS updates in the www directory than about the hacking itself? Sysadmins being lazy. Somebody needs to get a file from a workstation to a remote machine. There's a firewall in the way somewhere that prevents SSH directly between them or one of them is a Windows box that isn't running an SSH server. The "correct" solution is complicated and takes 5 minutes to setup. So the sysadmin just copies the file to the web server and downloads it with a browser on the other end. Because port 80 is always open.
- nob 14y agoSomething that took me a long time to notice was that you can actually copy files directly over a RDP session from/to the local machine or other RDP sessions using the clipboard.. Even nested RDPs. Has been an absolute timesaver to know about when doing Windows admin work.
- pointyhatuk 14y agoThat's totally shit. Its also why we invoice and take wire payments rather than storing CC details. There's just so much to go wrong. Also PKI is shit for this sort of thing. As demonstrated, the moment that public key is gone, then the whole system falls like a house of cards. For the non believers of this fact, why else would there be a certificate revocation list and root CA updates for windows periodically...
- toomuchtodo 14y agoUsing a processor who stores the card number outside of your infrastructure (ie. Stripe) can also be helpful.
- gbuckingham89 14y agoUntil they have a security breach.
- ricardobeat 14y agoBetter rely on someone who's sole job is securing that info than doing it yourself.
- mrweasel 14y agoStoring credit card info just helps make you a bigger target. If your a small company, better let someone else store card info, let them be the target. Also you're fined by the credit card companies if you lose card information. I believe it's a per card fine, so it get expensive really quickly. Actually I don't get why any company would choose to store credit card information, when most payment providers will do it for you.
- Killswitch 14y agoStripe is amazing... I trust them, someone hacks me, awesome, you got password hashes and stripe customer keys, all worthless.
- dom96 14y agoHere is what Linode replied to me when I asked them about that chat log in a support ticket: Hello, Thank you for reaching out. We appreciate and understand your concerns. At this time the evidence suggest that this activity was targeting a specific customer. We are unable to release any additional details regarding this incident at this time, as there is an ongoing investigation. We have no comment regarding ryan*'s comments in #linode. You are of course free to take any steps you deem prudent or necessary to ensure the integrity of your online presence. I am sorry that we cannot provide more information at this time. As always feel free to contact us at any time with any future concerns. Regards, Quintin
- tomjen3 14y agoWell the steps I would like to take regarding linode aren't exactly legal. Satisfying yes, but not legal. But I just checked and my credit card haven't been used anywhere I didn't use it.
- icelancer 14y agoThis is ridiculously unprofessional.
- gburt 14y agoThese guys are looking totally incompetent at this point. If you believe this Ryan guy, credit cards stored on the same server as the key to decrypt them, Lish passwords stored in plain text, they've known for some time and lied about what actually happened and now they're saying "we won't do anything about it" via email? "You are of course free to take any steps you deem prudent or necessary to ensure the integrity of your online presence." Unbelievable. Edit: not to mention they "made a deal" with the hacker not to tell anyone? What the hell?
- oinksoft 14y agoRegarding the "made a deal" assertion, I wouldn't take the IRC log hook-line-and-sinker. There's probably a mixture of truth and lies.
- noonespecial 14y ago"Don't worry, all the doors are locked." "Where are the keys?" "In the locks."
- antihero 14y agoThere is literally zero evidence to suggest they compromised anything more than a webserver.