3 ms·
1. Deflationary currency encourages extractive businesses, such as property ownership and renting. Inflationary currency encourages people to re-invest their pr
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
1. Deflationary currency encourages extractive businesses, such as property ownership and renting. Inflationary currency encourages people to re-invest their profits in their business, and to grow their business as much as possible. In other words, with a deflationary currency people operating a business are encouraged to keep value in money mostly, with an inflationary currency people are encouraged to keep value in the business. It seems pretty obvious which of these encourage economic growth more.
2. I'm making an argument about deflationary vs. inflationary currencies in the abstract, Bitcoin itself is too complicated to fit into that argument except in so far as people arguing that deflationary behavior is a benefit to bitcoin as a currency. It certainly could encourage purchasing of bitcoins but I'm not convinced it encourages use of bitcoins as currency.
3. This is not a counter-example at all, because goods are not currency, they have an innate value. The cost of waiting for years to purchase some good that you desire (such as a computer or a cellphone) comes at a cost of spending years of your life without the benefit of being able to use those goods. And that cost may be significantly greater than the value of saving money.
4. Bitcoin as an investment only makes sense as a pyramid scheme, in order for it to have value it must be used as a currency. Regardless of the interaction at the edges that means that it must have some core use as a currency, which is currently not the majority use, and that's a bit troubling.
As to downvoting, HN wouldn't let me downvote your reply even if I wanted to so I can't help you there. I suspect someone disagrees strongly with what you've written but doesn't want to take the time to write a rebuttal.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]