3 ms·
Not sure I buy the most persuasive argument, bitcoins are the ultimate fiat currency, with a value conjured out of thin air, paper currencies have value becaus
by tantalor 14y ago
Not sure I buy the most persuasive argument,
bitcoins are the ultimate fiat currency, with a value conjured out of thin air, paper currencies have value because they’re backed by the power of the state
Dollars and yuan are fiat currency. What difference does it make that bitcoin holders aren't back by a state? Is anything going to change if countries convert their reserves to bitcoin? How many bitcoins does the US own?
This seems like an argument that will evaporate given enough time.
- reaclmbs 14y agothe sovereign nations have gold...
- tantalor 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nixon_Shock http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nixon_Shock
- reaclmbs 14y agoyes, but when cyprus defaults, what will the european countries want? gold.
- tantalor 14y agoThey have a lot of rubles, right?
- dragonwriter 14y ago> yes, but when cyprus defaults, what will the european countries want? If history is any guide, they'll want the ability to dictate Cyprus's internal policies. That's usually the international response to default, rather than demands for gold. Concrete power, rather than weak symbolic representation of power.
- venomsnake 14y agoThere was a joke once in soviet time that the dollar is backed by gold, while the ruble is backed by tanks. Currently USD is also backed by the tanks. The US government has the power to extract from every person certain amount of USD per year that it determines. And the US government is the only source. How the person can obtain them is up to them. This makes a big difference.
- tantalor 14y agoThe tax argument is interesting. I suppose a choice to pay US taxes is a "bet" on the state, and the currency. Let me know when some country starts to accept bitcoins for tax purposes.
- venomsnake 14y agoOne tiny detail though - paying taxes is anything but a choice. Unless you are one of the corporation-americans of course.
- tantalor 14y agoI choose where to live, right?
- redblacktree 14y agoIt's a choice in the sense that everything is a choice. You can choose paying taxes or going to jail. Or, maybe you could be successful as a fugitive. Still, you're making the choice to pay taxes, even if that choice is based on likely consequences.
- yungchin 14y agoI believe the thinking behind this is that if a nation state designates a currency as their official currency, that will guarantee a baseline demand for the currency: citizens will need to either hold or obtain the currency to pay their taxes. With Bitcoin, no such baseline demand is guaranteed: if the "faith" in Bitcoin drops in the network, and people stop accepting it as payment, there's no stopping the decline in value. I'm still not sure whether to buy this argument, given that history has more than a few examples of state currencies crashing like there was no bottom, too.
- dragonwriter 14y ago> I'm still not sure whether to buy this argument, given that history has more than a few examples of state currencies crashing like there was no bottom, too. State currencies usually crash when the State isn't doing to well, (not infrequently as a result of losing a major war.) Which is actually consistent with Krugman's point. Ultimately, value of any good used as currency (and, really, pretty much any good at all) comes from two sources: (1) what is it good for without trading it (use-value), and (2) what do I expect I will be able to trade it to others for in the future (trade value). Pure currencies, like common fiat currencies and bitcoin, tend to have no (or virtually no) use value -- sure, you can use pennies to weight something down, or burn banknotes for heat, but that's most irrelevant. Their value is all trade value. Having a government that you expect to have to deal with that expects payment in dollars (or pounds, or what-have-you) for fines, fees, taxes, etc., and which denominates damage awards in civil cases in the same currency, and makes tendering that currency a legal attempt to pay a debt which is given weight in court (what "legal tender" means), provides a baseline demand. Of course, when that State becomes weaker, the support its backing gives currency becomes weaker.