5 ms·
if you stifle the ability for new players to enter a market, easily, and compete with the established ones you direly hurt the economy by creating artificial mo
by sliverstorm 14y ago
if you stifle the ability for new players to enter a market, easily, and compete with the established ones you direly hurt the economy by creating artificial monopolies.
I agree with everything you say, but I think I come to a slightly different conclusion. It sounds like in the special case of natural monopolies, what we need is rather than simply trying not to stifle competitors, we need to work to empower competitors- because of the special nature of natural monopolies.
This is still a form of regulation, so it sounds like regulation is fine for natural monopolies, so long as it goes in the right "direction", i.e. regulation that opens up the market rather than closing it.
- zanny 14y agoI find most natural monopolies are either the result of stupid artificial government regulation (patents, like the article mentions - doctors, farming / food / pesticides, etc) or are infrastructure monopolies. I commented to someone else, but systemically I don't think infrastructure is viable as a privatized good. It inherently has to be public, I think, in the way it acts as a foundational element of society. This includes power lines, rail, roads, and cable / phone / fiber. I don't think these wires under public roads and through private property should ever be private, but should be public, easily plugged into and utilized resources to build industries and tremendous productivity gains upon.
- jacques_chester 14y agoNatural monopolies are, by definition, not created by legislation or regulation. They emerge from the features of a market.
- zanny 14y agoWhat natural monopolies are there then?
- jacques_chester 14y agoBasically anywhere that the structure of costs makes it more efficient for a single firm to serve a market. High upfront capital costs and low maintenance relative to capital make it hard for second entrants to follow, because the incumbent has already paid down some or all of their capital cost and can cut prices to the marginal cost of operation to drive out the entrant -- but the entrant must pay off the capital as well. If the capital costs are low, this isn't as much of problem. With some understanding investors and creditors an entrant can match the incumbent. But when you have to build millions or billions of dollars of stuff just to get started, that's much harder to arrange.
- zanny 14y agoBut I'm asking for a specific example of a natural monopoly that isn't the result of infrastructure (which is best not even done privately and is best a public good) and can't have its prohibitive costs to enter the result of artificial government scarcity (arguing a nuclear plant is prohibitively expensive to build because the designs are all patented, for example, falls into that category). I just can't think of one. Almost any "natural" monopoly (roads, healthcare, power grid, network cable, etc) I think should be done by local government, not private business, because structural aspects of society aren't effective platforms for competition if they just supply the foundations to build markets upon. Actually, I just thought of one - maybe agriculture. While it is structural, it isn't an inherent infrastructure because it has specialized purpose. The post green revolution has demonstrated (though I imagine it is the result of regulation this happens) that megafarms are the most efficient way to organize modern farming. This naturally leads to a few big players because the cost of equipment to properly maximize productivity of land has high expenses (though they aren't at a comparable scale to say, a road network, or laying fiber in a city - one tractor, plow, tiller, etc plus the seed, silos, barns, etc, but these are tools to maximize productivity, not infrastructure). It might be the product of land ownership and zoning, but I'm only familiar with my local zoning code, which has a large Mennonite population, so most of the farmland in the region is restricted from being sold for other purposes. The midwest is a much different story that I'm not familiar with.