4 ms·
Maybe I'm just thick as a board tonight, but while you wrote a lot, you don't really seem to have explained "the solution to rent seeking" as you see it. Can yo
by sliverstorm 14y ago
Maybe I'm just thick as a board tonight, but while you wrote a lot, you don't really seem to have explained "the solution to rent seeking" as you see it. Can you expound?
- guylhem 14y agoReason says rent seeking is improductive and self destructive behaviour. One will engage in such activities only if the expected returns outweights the costs, which include the destruction of the system. A rational person will not come to this conclusion under a system where such inefficiency is discouraged - pure and perfect competition, capitalism. Many people wonder whether capitalism is a good thing. Bring them reason, science, let them work it out and make their own basic decision. Let them fight the bad reasoning themselves, come out of their local optimas if you prefer a math analogy. Racism and religious extremism must have some value, or such behaviours would not have because so widespread. But they seem to be local optimas, or even destructive in the end, just like rent-seeking. Here is another way to look at this - look at the immigration net flows: it seems that more people want to immigrate in capitalist countries than emigrate out of them. If it is reasonable to doubt my deductions, is it reasonable to doubt so many people may have made the same conclusions independently ? Read about how immigrants affiliate politically, which belief system they adhere to. Apparently a lot of them want to be paid for the fruit of their labour, and not for pure idleness, want to be left alone - and many other libertarian values. I'm sorry if that is not a valid explain for you. It is for me.
- bob13579 14y agoHow do you explain government rent-seeking, where there is no competition? Take government pensions or teacher unions for example.
- sliverstorm 14y agoTo make sure we are on the same page, let me try to summarize: you are essentially saying that so long as people take into account negative externalities, rent seeking behavior goes away? I don't disagree with your premise, but I do disagree that this will result in rent seeking behavior going away. One of the classic problems with capitalism is literally exactly this- negative externalities are not properly accounted for.
- guylhem 14y agoWe are on the same page. I wouldn't phrase it that way, but yes, ideally negative externalities should be internalized by individuals to make the problem vasnish. But failing that, if individual parties may engage in negotiations to achieve better outcomes (Ronald Coasce) Less regulation are usually a 1st thing to try in that process, to cause change by voluntary association, naming and shaming. Issues can be mitigated. But regulation is a pandora box. There are whole parts of economics studying that - public policy and industrial organisation.
- brc 14y agoThe challenge for most people is to understand that less regulation results in less rent seeking. Only a large and powerful state can implement the required blocks to form monopolies. Only a powerful state can entrench the class divide between the ruled and the rulers. The solution, then, is to reduce the size of the state and allow for less central planning and involvement. Further to this: the size of the state and those who run it seek to gain more power. Power is delivered through votes. Thus much that passes for political debate is not based on reason, but rather emotions and feelings - people finding and leveraging biases, beliefs and BS. Virtually no modern policy making is done using reason and simple analysis - instead it is done by emotionally trying to sway the argument - the 'think of the children' model. A triumph of reason over emotion and reduction in the size o f the state. This creates the environment where those rent-seeking cannot fool those using reason, and they lack the all-powerful controls to enforce the monopolies.
- PeterisP 14y ago"Only a large and powerful state can implement the required blocks to form monopolies." - now that is decidedly false; if there are any entry barriers (such as capital investments required to start), then free market naturally tends to consolidate (as it's more profitable) towards monopolies or oligopolies, which coincidentally means the end of free market in that industry. Only a powerful state can PREVENT monopolies and keep the free market economy as defined, with many suppliers and buyers setting the prices in a market instead of a monopolistic ultimatum. For real life examples, see the classic USA situations of railway and oil magnates in 19th century - these monopolies weren't caused by the state and regulations, but by lack of it. Of course, states can also create bad monopolies, but the solution is to change government actions, not to "disarm" the state - since in that case the bad monopolies will stay anyway, and even more monopolies will arise.
- thatswrong0 14y ago> For real life examples, see the classic USA situations of railway and oil magnates in 19th century - these monopolies weren't caused by the state and regulations, but by lack of it. In the case of Standard Oil, the consumers benefited greatly from the practices of Rockefeller. Despite controlling 90% of the market at one point, its output quadrupled in a single decade (1880-1890) and prices of kerosene dropped by threefold over the same time period. Standard Oil was simply the best at what it did and succeeded as a result. During the early 1900s, the market shifted away from kerosene to gasoline (thanks to Ford) and there was a large amount of competition entering that market. Its market share in oil production fell from 1898 to 1906 from 34% to 11%. Yet it was only in 1911 that Standard Oil was broken up by the Sherman Anti-Trust Act (which, funnily enough, was passed in 1890: at the end of the decade of massive increases in production and decreases in price by Standard Oil). The fact is that, in this case, the market function properly in spite of government interference, not thanks to it. Funny that you mention the railroads as well. The biggest threat to competition was not the companies in the free market, but instead railroad companies in control of the ICC, created in 1887. It was this government entity which allowed railroad companies, through law, to eliminate competition and screw the consumer by raising rates in a collusive manner.