3 ms·
Right off the bat: > It would really be something if intelligent people chose to invest more trust in a currency system built and managed, in large part, by an
by baddox 14y ago
Right off the bat:
> It would really be something if intelligent people chose to invest more trust in a currency system built and managed, in large part, by anonymous computer hackers than they did in currency systems built and managed by governments of the people, by the people.
Chris Robert doesn't seem to understand the mathematics behind bitcoin. The whole point is that the bitcoin network doesn't require any trust, or rather, it only requires trust that the longest block chain is mostly honest and that the current understanding of cryptography and computational complexity theory is correct.
Then we have Robert McMillan:
> Unfortunately, as those familiar with Paul Krugman’s writings on liquidity traps know, Bitcoin’s known and finite supply dooms it as a workable replacement currency.
This is a common straw man argument. Which bitcoin enthusiasts have claimed that bitcoin needs to be a "workable replacement currency"?
> Furthermore, as it has no apparent use-value (unlike, say, Platinum), this kills it entirely.
Technically, since a bitcoin is a proof that a certain amount of difficult computational work has been performed by or on behalf of the current owner of the bitcoin, there is some use-value. Bitcoin can be thought of as a networked version of Hashcash that allows the work to be performed in advance. Mail servers could be configured to require that a tiny amount of bitcoin be attached to every message it receives, hopefully making most spam unprofitable. This is probably merely an oversight by Mr. McMillan, but does this really even matter? What is the apparent use-value of a government-issued currency like the USD?
Matthew Bishop poses an interesting question:
> But what if a sovereign state was to issue an algorithm-based currency? Would that drive fiat money out of business?
I wonder if it would also drive non-governmental crypto-currencies out of business.
I find the following quote from Brett Gordon humorous. Economists don't seem to agree over whether bitcoin's deflationary nature is a benefit or a drawback. It's almost as if different people value different things.
> Two benefits are that bitcoins are inherently deflationary and transactions are anonymous. Given the recent slew of fiscal crises and increasing concerns about online privacy, these are two strong points in bitcoin’s favor—or whatever future crypto-currency arises.
- sirclueless 14y ago> Two benefits are that bitcoins are inherently deflationary and transactions are anonymous. Given the recent slew of fiscal crises and increasing concerns about online privacy, these are two strong points in bitcoin’s favor—or whatever future crypto-currency arises. This was the funniest thing to read for me. It flies in the face of two of the biggest complaints I see about Bitcoin (the third being the "it has no inherent value, not even status as legal tender"). You mention that Brett Gordon is disagreeing with many people when he claims that being deflationary is a benefit. Even in this same article you see the exact opposite being said: > Unfortunately, as those familiar with Paul Krugman’s writings on liquidity traps know, Bitcoin’s known and finite supply dooms it as a workable replacement currency. So there's two completely contradictory positions on that issue. But also on the anonymous transaction issue. Every bitcoin transaction is quite obviously public, so that right adjacent to this quote is Chris Robert's: > The bubble can just grow and grow, so long as... the fundamental lack of anonymity doesn’t bother anyone. So in the same article we have economists saying built-in deflation and anonymity are benefits of Bitcoins, while others say deflation will kill any chance of viability as a currency and that Bitcoin has no anonymity. What's a person to think, besides that many economists don't really understand Bitcoin and are probably just as speculative as the people buying Bitcoin at $250 several days ago.