3 ms·
Modern dictionary attacks use common terms that have been generated from analyzing the passwords that have been stolen from past attacks. So the dictionary isn'
by laumars 14y ago
Modern dictionary attacks use common terms that have been generated from analyzing the passwords that have been stolen from past attacks. So the dictionary isn't just a list of English words but in fact a catalog of terms that people do use for passwords in real life. This makes them much more effective than dictionary attacks off old.
- dllthomas 14y agoAnalyzing passwords that have been stolen helps you build a better dictionary. The math in the comic assumes an optimum dictionary has been constructed to attack this kind of password by inspecting the algorithm; no dictionary attack is going to do better than that without doing something like attacking the RNG used to generate the passwords (and if that's feasible you're just as vulnerable regardless of what approach you use).
- laumars 14y agoWhile that is true, pen testers are still rattling off ~60% of passwords from dictionary attacks in just 3 weeks. This is why I would rather see emphasis placed on password length and irregularity than simply saying "memorable words can be secure", which is what most people will take away from that comic. So I was never arguing against passphrases per se. Though I appreciate I want very clear on that. (Like I said before, hangover + phone surfing != best platform for a complex discussion. :-)
- dllthomas 14y agoYes. Pen testers are rattling off the ~60% of passwords that were chosen poorly, all of which were chosen by methods other than the one detailed in the comic. Just placing an emphasis on password length and irregularity leaves people still with the question of how they generate that long, irregular password. Asking them to do it in their head in any way is going to lead to much success by way of dictionary attacks. I'm coming to the realization (giving you some credit) that your objection may be to a specific piece of the comic's particular presentation: "random" is often used to mean "arbitrary" and people might think they can do it in their head? Of course I agree that anything people do with their heads is almost certainly insecure - brains are piss-poor sources of entropy. Would your objection be fixed entirely if it called out explicitly that the words need to be picked mechanically (computer, dice, something) with a uniform distribution? Anyway, the thing that I like about the comic is that it presents a specific means of choosing a password that is simultaneously secure and memorable, and the only misconception involved would be from misinterpretation of the comic (which, as noted above, does seem possible). Anything else someone comes up with on their own is likely to be less secure, less memorable, or both, so referring to the comic as promulgating a misconception bugs me. Regarding the last, I don't think we were ever arguing about passphrases in general, but about a particular way of generating them... passphrase really just means "long password", more or less, and that doesn't provide a lot of guidance as to how to come up with one, and leaving people to their own devices is how we wind up with ~60% of passwords being horribly crackable.
- laumars 14y ago> Yes. Pen testers are rattling off the ~60% of passwords that were chosen poorly, all of which were chosen by methods other than the one detailed in the comic. But the crux of my point is that the comic doesn't necessarily teach good password habits. I do happen to work in infosec† and I've lost count of the number of pseudo-techies that rattle off that comic as evidence that obvious passwords can be secure without taking into account that they need to do more than just concatenating two words together. You keep taking about ideal world scenarios (people picking passphrases and sites having sufficient max char limit on password fields to fit any conceivable passphrase), but people are idiots. So I'd sooner see idiots type a 10 char password from a pool of ~70 characters than two guessable words concatenated. So my point was born out of frustration of having to advise and apply security policies for clients. † I'm not just saying that to sound like an authority on the subject by the way. I know how some people "name drop" / lie about such things to prove a point :) > I'm coming to the realization (giving you some credit) that your objection may be to a specific piece of the comic's particular presentation: "random" is often used to mean "arbitrary" and people might think they can do it in their head? YES!!!! You and I might understand the maths behind the comic, but many readers just see "words can be secure" and then just pick their dogs name and their favorite footballer. Randal's message gets lost because (and as with all of his comic) he assumes a certain level of intelligence to begin with. > Regarding the last, I don't think we were ever arguing about passphrases in general, but about a particular way of generating them... passphrase really just means "long password", more or less, and that doesn't provide a lot of guidance as to how to come up with one, and leaving people to their own devices is how we wind up with ~60% of passwords being horribly crackable. I think that's fair to say. Plus as I said before, I'm all in favor of passphrases. I just don't like regular words used as passwords. I know passphrases and passwords generally refer to the same thing, but I make the distinction because the former (passphrase) suggests multiple words, which agrees with your sentiments about how longer groups of common words can be secure and why I keep saying I'm fulling in favor of passphrases. Where as the latter (passwords) suggests something a little more basic (eg the dogfootball facepalm I described above). At least that's how I make the distinction between a password following Randal's advice that's secure, and one that's insecure.
- 14y ago