3 ms·
Using your example, it's equally secure to an 8 character password using base64 characters. Recently a pen tester published[1] that he can crack a 9 char pass (
by laumars 14y ago
Using your example, it's equally secure to an 8 character password using base64 characters. Recently a pen tester published[1] that he can crack a 9 char pass (w/o punctuation, so 62^9) password in 90 seconds by parallel processing across several top end graphics cards. So I really wouldn't argue that a 48bit password is secure any longer.
[1]http://arstechnica.com/security/2012/08/passwords-under-assault/2/ http://arstechnica.com/security/2012/08/passwords-under-assa...
- dllthomas 14y agoRight, the necessary strength of passwords increases. Thankfully, the comic gave us a good method of generating passwords to an arbitrary strength, by increasing either the size of our alphabet (dictionary from which words are drawn) or length of our string (number of words), and shows how to calculate the resulting entropy. As I've pointed out elsewhere, 5 words drawn from alphabetic entries in /usr/share/dict/words (over 62 thousand) is very nearly 80 bits strong, or stronger than a 13 character completely random base64 string (which is going to be quite substantially harder to remember). If 62^9 (54 bits) takes 90 seconds, 80 bits takes nearly two centuries, and computing the hashes for phrases is actually going to take longer for each try to boot.
- laumars 14y agoYou keep thinking of dictionary attacks as being based on a verbatim English dictionary and I keep telling you that they're not. It's a refined dictionary with common terms used in real life passwords. However I do completely agree with your point about adding a number of more words. Passphrases are definitely another option, proving the service in question doesn't impose a restrictive maximum character limit (it's idiotic practice, but some do)
- dllthomas 14y ago> You keep thinking of dictionary attacks as being based on a verbatim English dictionary and I keep telling you that they're not. That has never, ever been my assertion. I keep saying a dictionary attack is a variation of a brute force attack (in that you're not looking at the hash itself), but adjusting the order in which you try words based on a priori guesses about what passwords are likely to be more common. My point has been that Randall's approach ASSUMES THIS KIND OF ATTACK. It, in fact, assumes a much more targeted one, where the dictionary the attacker has is completely accurate. IN THE FACE OF THAT, these passwords have the computed amounts of entropy. (There is a separate discussion to be had of just how much entropy is necessary, but that's obviously going to increase as time goes by.) I couldn't agree more that a maximum character limit (that's anywhere in the range anyone might conceivably type) is idiotic.
- laumars 14y agoSo basically the first part of that argument is tryingto rebuttal an argument I never made (I had already said that passphrases -so long as they are that and not just 2 concatenated words) are secure). And you're last part of that is also agreeing with me. Internet arguments are fucking dumb. Half the time it's just miscommunication lol
- dllthomas 14y agoFSCKING HELL. Okay, at this point I'm inclined to think you're just trolling, but one last swing... Yes, the last bit was agreeing with you; the lead-in with "I couldn't agree more that..." was something of a clue. Regarding the earlier pieces, you said in your original comment: "That's another common misconception as that advice is only true for brute force attacks, which are usually only the last resort for password crackers. Dictionary attacks are pretty sophisticated these days so I really wouldn't gamble on a short list of common words being secure these days." That is what I have been rebutting (in various forms, in various sub-threads), and it is incorrect. THE ENTROPY ESTIMATES IN THE COMIC ASSUME A MAXIMALLY 'SOPHISTICATED' DICTIONARY ATTACK, so "dictionary attacks are pretty sophisticated these days" is inane and misleading AT BEST. If you want to avoid miscommunication, communicate clearly, and either own what you say or say you were mistaken.
- laumars 14y agoI WAS HUNGOVER AND TYPING ON A TOUCH SCREEN PHONE WHILE TRYING NOT TO THROW UP ON A MOVING BUS. Of course I was going to explain myself badly, I did after all appolagise for the confusion and tried to explain myself better but you've been too fucking stubborn to even care about what my point actually was. I really don't know who many fucking times I need to say this before the penny finally drops for you. Or maybe you just prefer acting like a dick online? Perhaps you're the troll?