4 ms·
So Apple has a track record of unilaterally making poor or wholly irrational decisions about what's allowed to be on their store and what isn't, and you decide
by kevingadd 14y ago
So Apple has a track record of unilaterally making poor or wholly irrational decisions about what's allowed to be on their store and what isn't, and you decide that because the one example case being used is a vaguely shady app, obviously the politicians are just bought off by bribes and they're going after Apple because they have friends in high places?
You don't think that it's VAGUELY possible that perhaps Apple exerting their influence to silence speech (in the forms of games, comics, books, etc) and other forms of expression, not to mention outright crushing businesses because they decide they don't like them or because they decide they don't want competition, has upset politicians? You don't think it's VAGUELY possible that perhaps it is actually illegal?
Yeah, sure. Bribery. Got it. Most logical explanation!
P.S. I don't know why you would choose Viagra spam as a point of comparison for an app that people chose to install on their phones. Yes, AppGratis was scummy SEO, almost certainly - but Apple was OK with it being on their store, and approved updates, up until days before it was pulled, and they continue to allow similar apps to operate on their store. They also allow stuff on their store that is BLATANTLY exploitative (IAP-laden games aimed at kids, for example).
- seivan 14y agoYes, that is what I am saying Free speech? So what FREE speech does AppGratis do? Help me out here, has Apple blocked Spotify, Dropbox and etc? Hey, politicians are corrupt by default, so bribery is NOT as shocking as you make it sound like. Not sure why you have a tough time swallowing that pill. Especially EU politicians. Not saying it's a monetary thing, could be a friends or associations thing. Or that they are interested in that 9m revenue in French taxes. As we both are aware of, France needs that money badly. Don't play stupid, imagine if Apple let all apps wait for 2-3 months for thorough research before allowing an app to get onboard. It's easy for you to say that they should have done it from the get go, but things take time. People reported, Apple had research done and finally could come to the conclusion they are on now. I can't believe your arguments, you're actually saying that Apple can't change it's mind after finding more evidence.
- kevingadd 14y agoIf you don't have sufficient reading comprehension to realize that my post wasn't a defense of AppGratis, perhaps you shouldn't post multiple paragraphs criticizing arguments I didn't make. 2-3 months of pre-approval? Who on earth would suggest something that stupid? There are way easier ways to solve these problems; Apple doesn't want to solve these problems. Apple can certainly change their mind. That is not the problem. The problems are, among others: unclear/nonexistent communication, arbitrary and inconsistent enforcement of rules, and anticompetitive behavior. I don't care if AppGratis ever makes another cent, but Apple should definitely be held to account for their behavior and if this is what it takes for that to happen, so be it.
- kostya-kow 14y agoI am not an Apple fanboy, but I fully support Apple's decision to remove AppGratis from the store. It is pointless to argue if it was bribery that caused Pellerin to do this, but it is obvious that she is mistaken. >but Apple was OK with it being on their store, and approved updates, up until days before it was pulled, and they continue to allow similar apps to operate on their store. Allowing it in the App Store in the first place is a bad decision, but there is no reason they should have not removed it now. They also removed similar apps several months ago.
- seivan 14y agoResearching apps take time. Either they let developers wait months in order to get them onboard or conduct more thorough research retroactively.
- kevingadd 14y agoThe removal itself isn't the problem, the problem is Apple's clear and undisputable track record of: * Arbitrary and inconsistent enforcement of rules * Unclear/nonexistent communication with developers * Blatant anti-competitive behavior * Backwards, bigoted censorship bordering on outright oppression * Generally doing things that you won't get away with unless you're the only game in town (which they are) The point here isn't that AppGratis being pulled somehow merits legal action. The point is that you can easily look at it as the straw that broke the camel's back: Apple has been pulling this shit for a while, and will continue to pull this shit FOREVER unless other parties intervene.