8 ms·
This case is getting a large amount of attention on blogs, but as usual blogs are not the most reliable source of information. It may be true that it took some
by cperciva 14y ago
This case is getting a large amount of attention on blogs, but as usual blogs are not the most reliable source of information.
It may be true that it took some individuals calling themselves "Anonymous" two hours to discover the identities of the youth who had sex with Rehtaeh Parsons. While Canadian law prohibits the publication of identities of youth accused of crimes (on the basis that youthful indiscretions, even of a serious criminal nature, should not follow perpetrators for their entire lives), it's not all that difficult to find someone who knows someone who knows who was involved.
The police also knew exactly who was involved, and have known for over a year.
The "lack of evidence" referred to by police was not a lack of evidence of who was involved, but rather a lack of sufficient evidence that the sexual encounter was criminal. Even if they believed that Rehtaeh Parsons had been raped, the bar for laying criminal charges is "significant likelihood of conviction", and the bar for conviction is "proven beyond a reasonable doubt" -- and where the alleged victim does not make a complaint until after facing bullying for what her peers were presuming was consensual, it can easily raise doubts as to her veracity.
(The lesser issue, of producing and distributing child pornography, was the opposite: Clearly an offence had occurred, and they knew whose phone was used; but they had no way to prove which of three suspects was responsible.)
As far as I can tell, the police and prosecutors were entirely correct in their investigation and analysis of the situation. The only officials who did not do their jobs were the school administrators who failed to prevent or stop the bullying which Rehtaeh Parsons was subjected to, and the mental health workers who failed to take Rehtaeh Parsons's suicide threats seriously enough.
- MrJagil 14y agoDo you have any sources for this: "The police also knew exactly who was involved, and have known for over a year. The "lack of evidence" referred to by police was not a lack of evidence of who was involved, but rather a lack of sufficient evidence that the sexual encounter was criminal. " You do seem trustworthy, I would just like to verify and read more.
- Pwnguinz 14y agoYes, straight from the RCMP's mouth: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=at3XG-4ftF8#t=2m http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=at3XG-4ftF8#t=2m "There were insufficient evidence to proceed to charges." That Youtube link is a video of a RCMP officer being interviewed on air.
- analog 14y ago"Even if they believed that Rehtaeh Parsons had been raped" She was under the age of consent, legally there is zero doubt it was rape. Edit: Apparently under Canadian law it may not have been statutory rape. Edit: Also, apparently she was vomiting whilst being assaulted[1]. I'd like to meet the lawyer who could convince a jury that consent was given. [1] "One of the boys snapped a picture on his mobile phone of Rehtaeh vomiting while allegedly being assaulted." http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/the-search-for-answers-amid-the-grief-for-rehtaeh-parsons/article11175714/ http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/the-search-for-...
- Pwnguinz 14y agoNo she wasn't. Do you even understand Canadian law? The age of consent is 14, if the other partner is within 5 years of age. Her classmates at the party would have been, presumably, within 5 years of age. Source: http://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/dept-min/clp/faq.html http://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/dept-min/clp/faq.html "The Criminal Code provides "close in age" or "peer group" exceptions. For example, a 14 or 15 year old can consent to sexual activity with a partner as long as the partner is less than five years older and there is no relationship of trust, authority or dependency or any other exploitation of the young person." Edit to address your Edit: Because after having a lot of drinks at a party ('drunk'), and then having what could be considered strenuous physical activity (i.e. sex) would not induce vomiting if it wasn't rape, right? Look, I'm not at all condoning what the 4 male youth have done, but let's still use logic in our discussions. Further Edit: Also I just want to add, unlike other Commonwealth Nations (e.g. Britain), the Canadian legal system does NOT allow extra charges to be tacked on while the legal proceedings are in motion. So before the RCMP and Crown Prosecutors initiate prosecutorial charges, they need to be relatively certain that they have enough evidence to win as they stand currently. They can't just say "Hey, I charge you with X with evidence Y, Z. Let's go to court." Then 5 days later say "and also A with evidence B, C."
- analog 14y agoNot to be unnecessarily argumentative but do you think a jury would be convinced by that 'she was throwing up due to strenuous exercise' excuse?
- general_failure 14y agoQuestion 1: If drunk boys have sex with drunk girl, is it rape? Who raped who? Some news sites claim that the boys say that the girl _wanted_ to have sex. Question 2: how can minors get access to liquor?
- cperciva 14y agoAnswer 1: If they are sufficiently intoxicated as to be unable to consent, then yes, it is rape. In such a case all the individuals involved could theoretically be charged and convicted -- it is possible to have "mutual rape". Answer 2: In decreasing order of probability: Fake ID, older friends/relatives, theft.