3 ms·
Using that same logic, it's not hard to make the case for imperialism. If the sole goal is to benefit Americans at the expense of others, why not steal everyone
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
Using that same logic, it's not hard to make the case for imperialism. If the sole goal is to benefit Americans at the expense of others, why not steal everyone's natural resources and use them for our own benefit?
- bicknellr 14y ago[insert communism comparison rebuttal here]
- pandaman 14y agoThere are no resources left that you could "steal" for less than you could buy on the open market.
- rayiner 14y agoOne bit of conventional wisdom that I find interesting is the belief that what was responsible for American prosperity post-WWII was the fact that Europe was devastated and the U.S. was the undisputed industrial superpower. To the extent that theory is true (and I'm not saying it is or not, I don't have enough of a grounding in economics to say)--doesn't that suggest that the rational course of American policy should be to bomb India and China instead of trading with them? People trot out this idea all the time, but nobody really thinks through the implication... My point isn't that the U.S. should be imperialist. I don't think it should be. There are lots of good, practical reasons to not just go around bombing everyone, namely that it's an expensive game of "king of the hill" in the long run. But in my mind the idea that we have some greater moral obligation to humanity is not one of those reasons. The American government is instituted to secure the prosperity of Americans. That is the beginning and end of the purpose of its existence. The only moral obligations binding upon it are those that reflect the will of its constituency. If the U.S. refrains from imperialism the only reason it should do so is because Americans want to be peaceful, not out of concern for the well being of non-Americans. It should be noted that, China doesn't subscribe to any such silly notions. If they thought they could get away with bombing us to cripple our infrastructure and that doing so would increase their own prosperity, the Chinese government would do it in a heartbeat.
- eurleif 14y agoSo, just to be perfectly clear: you don't believe that people have any moral obligation not to murder each other. But they do have a moral obligation to follow contracts (the government's contract to do what the people want).
- rayiner 14y agoI don't believe in any super natural bases for morality,[1] so I believe that morality arises out of the social contract. Given that, it makes sense to talk about the moral obligations of individuals within a society to each other, but not to talk about one society's obligation to another. [1] Not just religion, but things like "natural rights" are really supernatural conceptually.
- eurleif 14y agoWhat's the basis for following the social contract being an obligation?
- rayiner 14y agoBiologically? The various chemical signals (shame, fear, regret, etc) that enforce behavioral expectations within groups of humans.
- davidw 14y agoThis is a repeat of the other day's conversation (and about 1343243243232 other similar conversations on the internet, which is why we ought to get rid of political articles), but like hell will I "not talk about my obligations" to other human beings that happen to be born with some other passport. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5533155 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5533155 Edit: looks like someone is sinking these articles off the front page. Good call!
- rayiner 14y agoWhat do you think is the basis for your obligations to humans that you don't share a government with?
- omonra 14y agoDo you really fail to appreciate the difference between: A) Not sharing your family/country resources with strangers (who might well be below your level of economic development). B) Going over to invade another country/family and take away their resources?
- yummyfajitas 14y agoStarting from the premise that "it's morally wrong for the American government, instituted to protect American interests and American prosperity, to make that trade off", I don't see any reason to oppose imperialism. I don't agree with the premise, but that's a separate point.
- omonra 14y agoRight - but I am not asking whether you personally find imperialism as logical conclusion. I am asking if you understand the difference between point A and B?