7 ms·
Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead"
- Retric 18y agoIMO, Sharepoint is Microsoft's next big thing. They are becoming indispensable to midsized and large companies and creating a foundation that helps them keep selling copy's of Windows, and Office while setting up yet another revenue stream. Granted selling to other companies seems to be what large organizations do when they die, but it's still a huge source of revenue with little real competition. So, if you are building a web app you can probably ignore Microsoft, but if you are building an OS, or Office product there is still a huge shark swimming in those waters.
- Tangurena 18y agoSome people like to complain about how companies end up depending on home-brewed Access and Excel applications. The IT guys didn't have the time/resources to do "a proper job" so the business workers just learned stuff on their own and wrote their own apps. My suspicion is that Sharepoint and Infopath will be the next generation of home-brewed company apps. Companies already have them, so they don't need to be buying X, Y or Z to start writing apps to keep their company going.
- qeorge 18y agoCould you explain this: "Granted selling [products] to other companies seems to be what large organizations do when they die" I couldn't disagree more. Could you please elaborate?
- Retric 18y agoI think focusing on selling to other companies is a difficult trap to get out of. After the first sale companies can be milked for an extended period for support contracts / upgrades. Innovation is not really needed and growth / profit are an easy to understand process. You can even make money by bribing middle managers (see: drug companies for an example of this). However, individuals require far more bang for the buck. So the margins tend to be far smaller and you need to sell to large numbers of people constantly to keep up. At the same time selling to companies tends to focus on boring products so most of your innovative people tend to leave. It's not exactly a binary choice, but companies like AT&T often go from selling to individuals, to making money from companies, to making money from the government. In the end the quality of your competition tends to drop the closer you are to working for the government which is why I think it's a death spiral. Overtime the company becomes unable to deal with change and the next round of innovative companies tend to disrupt them. PS: Which is not to say old companies like GM can't sell products to customers it's just they stop being able to make much money doing so unless they can leverage a monopoly.
- andreyf 18y agoAren't services like Sharepoint fundamentally inferior to "cloud computing" (for lack of a less buzzy phrase)? I've heard this for almost a decade, but isn't it about time people see local e-mail hosting like running your own generators instead of "trusting" an electric company for your electricity?
- briansmith 18y agoThat's why Microsoft has two different levels of managed Sharepoint hosting: Office Live (very small businesses), and Microsoft Sharepoint Online (small or large businesses). Similarly, they have Microsoft Exchange Online, which is managed Exchange hosting. They are building caching infrastructure into Windows 7 so they can offer even Active Directory and file sharing as remote, managed services. As far as I can tell, all of their server-side software is or will be offered in a Microsoft-hosted-and-managed configuration. And, it won't be trivial to switch back and forth, but it will at least be possible to do so. Additionally, Microsoft seems to be working with Amazon Web Services since AWS supports Windows Server. If you don't want Microsoft to host your applications then you can do it yourself on AWS or on your own servers.
- nick007 18y agoTechnology startups don't have to worry about what Microsoft is doing? Microsoft is losing in a few fields but is still the world's largest and most lucrative software company. Just because it's no longer the youngest, hippest, and fastest growing company doesn't mean that it is dying.
- swombat 18y agoPut it this way: Fifteen years ago, if you were trying to convince someone to invest in you, the question on their lips might have been "What if Microsoft move into your market?" Now the question is "What if Google move into your market?" Far from being a threat, Microsoft is now an opportunity target... "We're going to steal this market from Microsoft" is a plausible claim. And so, they are no longer a big worry.
- Tangurena 18y ago15 years ago, Stac Electronics was on everyone's mind. Where Microsoft might say they wanted to buy your company, or license your technology, then go on to steal it anyway. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stac_Electronics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stac_Electronics
- allenbrunson 18y agoThis is possibly pg's most misunderstood essay ever, largely due to reactions like this one. He didn't say Microsoft is "dying," just that they're not a threat anymore. And ultimately, it's for their own good! Microsoft's rapaciousness was hurting them, indirectly. Innovation in the Windows space dried up. Who wants to make the next big successful thing on Windows, when Microsoft will surely swoop in and eat your lunch for you?
- blogimus 18y agoHow I understand it is that Paul is saying Microsoft is irrelevant to those trying to build at the forefronts. That it is not going to spot you, the startup, and eat your lunch, because its core business, its competencies are not where you are "feeding" (for want of a better metaphor).
- Herring 18y agoWell I can see how choosing a flamebait title helps get that message across.
- TweedHeads 18y agoIn summary, a retarded article bragging about billions and market share without any substance at all to dispute PG's assertion. M$ is dead, nobody fears them anymore, their products are no longer required, for every M$ product there are many competing products that work as well or better. Like saying IE is the best browser because it has 60% of market share without saying it had 90% a year before. Nobody uses it anymore and nobody cares. That's the real issue.
- ashot 18y agoPlease don't use "M$"
- chancho 18y agoIs Windoze still ok? Internet Exploder?
- TweedHeads 18y agoFrom Wikipedia: M$ (Microsoft): used to emphasize the allegation that Microsoft has business practices that focus on making money rather than producing good products or looking after the end user's needs and interests. Microsoft was convicted under United States anti-trust law of taking unfair advantage of its monopoly position. Also criticized for taking advantage of loyal customers and upgrading products annually for an expensive price, thus "shafting" the people who bought last year's products. I don't see anything wrong with using M$ to imply all of the above in one simple and worldwide recognizable satiric misspelling. See also, satire
- nailer 18y agoAll businesses should primary focus on making money. That's what businesses do. If you'd like to draw attention to Microsoft's illegal behavavior in the market, you have to explicitly state it, a dollar sign won't be enough for most people, who think you might simply be poor and envious.
- 18y ago
- TweedHeads 18y agoI didn't see PG 'revisiting' his post. Did he write a follow-up I missed?
- thalur 18y agoI think it's referring to an email quote in the article.
- mattmaroon 18y agoiPhone apps are a media sensation for sure, but the real money is more in social network apps. The top Facebook app makes every month what the top iPhone app has made in total.
- jasongullickson 18y agoDo you have evidence to back up this statement?
- mattmaroon 18y agoSure. It's actually fairly public. Everyone celebrated iShoot making $700k. It's well-known that Mob Wars and a few other apps make more than that monthly. And as an app developer, I can attest to the sort of eCPMs that requires among Facebook RPGs. To put it in perspective, I'll probably bring in more rev than iShoot this year, and I'm nowhere near Mob Wars in traffic numbers. There have to be hundreds of guys out there bigger than me. And unlike iShoot, I'll keep doing it indefinitely, not just until I fall off of the top 25 (which I never even had to hit). When it comes to third party apps, Facebook is really the leader right now. In fact, I'd argue that in the tech world, they're setting the terms more than Apple at the moment, just in a different sphere.
- jasongullickson 18y agoIs iShoot the number one selling app (in volume or revenue) in the app store? Do you have Mob War's specific numbers? This is what I mean by "evidence". The reason I ask is that most developers (other than publicly held companies) don't discuss these details with the general public.
- mattmaroon 18y agoI don't have any evidence that would be permissible in court, no. Nonetheless I know a lot of people involved in both worlds (including on the monetization angle) and unless there's a wide-spread, concerted conspiracy to trick me into not releasing an iPhone app, Facebook/Myspace ones monetize at least an order of magnitude better.
- neilo 18y agoMaybe "de-clawed"? They're not quite DEAD yet. I think I'll go for a walk...
- yef 18y agoPeople misunderstood PG's essay because he misstated his thesis. "Dead", put simply, was the wrong word to use. Microsoft is not "dead" any more than Apple was dead in the mid to late nineties (and boy, was that a popular statement at the time). Microsoft still has cash, people, and a position in the industry that, with the right leadership, can be turned around to be competitive with Google, Amazon and Apple. Please back up all prognostications with evidence, or submit yourself to wrongtomorrow.com :)
- r7000 18y agoNo it was not the wrong wording at all. "X is dead" is a very well-established rhetorical phrase. The only controversy that resulted was due to the enormously over-literal nature of argument on the net. The "Microsoft" in the title means the "Microsoft as bogeyman of the tech industry". This is implied. That Microsoft "still has cash, people, and ... position" is neither here nor there.
- yef 18y agoTo me, "dead" means something like "checkmated". "X is dead" means that X is in a situation that it can't get out of. Can you please point me to your definition?
- r7000 18y agoYes that is it. Microsoft as the bogeyman of the tech industry (i.e. a factor one must consider). That concept is "checkmated"/dead. It no longer holds true. And there's nothing immediately obvious MS can do to reverse that situation ("get out of it").
- qeorge 18y agoI've never agreed with this PG essay. Granted its a couple of years old, but I think its totally off-base. Specifically: "Gmail also showed how much you could do with web-based software, if you took advantage of what later came to be called "Ajax." And that was the second cause of Microsoft's death: everyone can see the desktop is over. It now seems inevitable that applications will live on the web - not just email, but everything, right up to Photoshop. Even Microsoft sees that now." I couldn't possibly disagree with this more. The idea of being forced to use all software through a browser sounds bloody awful to me. Photoshop through a browser? DO NOT WANT. What we're more likely to see is cloud-based apps, which deliver the portability and connectivity we've come to expect from web apps. I can absolutely see myself using a cloud based version of Photoshop, but it would still be "desktop" software. Not surprisingly MS is heavily invested in the virtualization and server markets. Surprisingly, I think PG forgot this basic point: products succeed because people want them, not because of their underlying technology. Gmail became popular not because it employed AJAX or was based online, but because it solved a hair-on-fire problem: tiny inbox sizes. "The third cause of Microsoft's death was broadband Internet. Anyone who cares can have fast Internet access now. And the bigger the pipe to the server, the less you need the desktop." This statement I also find ridiculous. If anything, increased broadband availability has made computers even more of a must-have product. And I've seen absolutely nothing to back up a claim that of these new computers less of them are running Windows. "The last nail in the coffin came, of all places, from Apple. Thanks to OS X, Apple has come back from the dead in a way that is extremely rare in technology. [2] Their victory is so complete that I'm now surprised when I come across a computer running Windows." Dude, come on. Yes, Apple made an amazing comeback. No, they haven't had anything close to a "complete victory." Now, I say this as someone who makes custom web apps for small businesses, and someone whose father had an app completely ripped off and suffocated by MS circa 2000. A big part of me wants this to be true, but I know it isn't. In conclusion: The revolution in web apps was making them behave more like desktop apps. So why is it surprising to see desktop apps enjoy a renaissance by acting more like web apps?
- axod 18y ago>> "Photoshop through a browser? DO NOT WANT." What you seem to fail to see is that you're an outlier. Most people want photoshop through a browser. Most people already do most of their stuff through a browser. It's funny to even debate, because it's happening/happened for large amounts of people out there already. Ask your parents what they do on the computer, and it's likely to be 90%+ web, with perhaps a couple of desktop apps. If that. Ironically, it's the techie usually early adopters that are lagging here, preferring to stick with desktop software. The people leading the webapp charge are people who don't want the fuss of downloading desktop software, with potential spyware etc, and just go to google and find a webapp instead. The same phenomenon exists when some people discuss advertising. "No one clicks on ads anymore" - it's easy to say, if you install adblock, or just don't click on ads, but this is a total minority. The majority do click on ads. Just like the majority want, and use webapps over desktop apps. >> "Gmail became popular not because it employed AJAX or was based online, but because it solved a hair-on-fire problem: tiny inbox sizes." I think actually the reason it succeeded was because it had ridiculously fast searching, and unlike a desktop app, you don't have to worry about your storage. I don't think the majority of people really cared about inbox size. The fact you could easily search for things in a simple and blazingly fast webapp was key. For most people, it is better than a desktop app. >> "This statement I also find ridiculous. If anything, increased broadband availability has made computers even more of a must-have product." The fact that broadband access has increased etc means there's less need to have a thick client. Where previously you needed to download a video, click on it, watch it, we all now just watch videos streamed to us by a webapp. When we all have 1Gbps connections, why would we need a full powerful computer each? Why would it not be in most persons better interest to just have a very thin power conserving client that connects up to the big servers doing the grunt work. The fact is, it's happening, and will continue to happen. You can't stop it. It's inevitable. You might prefer to stick with your computer and desktop apps, but you'll be a small minority, like the people who still buy records on vinyl. >> "The revolution in web apps was making them behave more like desktop apps." I disagree with that. The revolution in webapps is making them work BETTER than desktop apps. Gmail can search my mail much faster than my computer can. Mibbit can do things impossible with desktop IRC clients. etc etc The reason Microsoft are 'dead' is that they don't get it. They're dead in a similar sense to the music industry IMHO - the market changed around them and they completely failed to adapt.
- c00p3r 18y agoiPhone was changed everything. Facebook and Twitter shows what the people really want. No body cares about OS or PC anymore. Stay connected - it's a trend.
- cubicle67 18y agoPG, if you're around, are you able to post your entire response? This article reads like there's a lot more you said that wasn't printed.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- pg 18y agofrom Paul Graham to Ian Lamont date Wed, Apr 8, 2009 at 9:22 AM subject Re: 2nd anniversary of "Microsoft is Dead" essay - new factors to consider? A lot of people misunderstood that essay, and asked how I could claim a company making so much money was dead. Obviously I didn't mean Microsoft was bankrupt. What I meant was that they were no longer a factor one had to consider when doing something in technology. That's still true today. The big stories in the 2 years since have been AWS and iPhone apps. Microsoft's mindshare has continued to slowly erode. Thanks to AWS, someone starting a startup today thinks more about Amazon than Microsoft. An online retailer! It would have seemed almost impossible to people in 1999 that anyone would be saying that in 2009. --pg
- cubicle67 18y agoThanks
- access_denied 18y agoThe linked to article is weak. Summary: 1. PG wrote that article 2. I called him, and he reinforced his sentiment by giving 2 more incidents for support. iPhone Apps and the fact many web startups use Amazon's services for hostinge ect.
- _bn 18y agono, no, no. Microsoft is far from dead. PG is simply wrong. Just look at the work that Live Labs is producing. No "Web 2.0" company can compete with the brilliance behind photosynth. They are kidding themselves if they think they can. I'll tell you why Microsoft won't survive. It's because Microsoft isn't a leader in innovation. Steve Ballmer doesn't have any balls. He's simply satisfied with being #2 and playing it safe while letting Steve Jobs create new markets and dominating them (with style). Again, Microsoft isn't dead. If anything, this whole "Web 2.0" and Ycombinator incubation thing is dead. If the big boys think that there is any serious competition coming out of these programs then they have another thing coming. The recession has reduced a lot of this noise, and the real animals have been let out of their cage.
- olefoo 18y agoMicrosoft Research is not Microsoft; it's like the Honors College at a large state university a small enclave of excellence set against a larger backdrop of mediocrity. The larger culture at Microsoft is still operating under the assumptions of the 1990's when they were large and in charge. They have been coasting on the monopoly for some time. But, they are not the hundred year computing culture; by their very nature they can't be.
- sscheper 18y agoIn that article, it's hilarious because the microsoft biz dev guy misunderstands what he seeks to establish.
- henning 18y agoHow are iPhone apps a big story when the market is dominated by fart noise programs and games? (Since when do Web 2.0 people give a crap about mobile gaming?)
- jasongullickson 18y agoMost of the criticism of this essay could be eliminated by replacing "dead" with "irrelevant". What has Microsoft done in the last five years that has been copied by a competitor (the sincerest form of flattery and all)
- actf 18y agoWow I honestly can't believe that pg is so short sighted. Let's compare work that's being directly copied by competitors: Microsoft: C#, actually for that matter the entire .NET Framework, Singularity, Gazelle, Visual Studio, Powershell, Office, WPF, Silverlight, Photosynth, the list goes on and on Apple: iPhone Microsoft is by no means "dead" or "irrelevant". Generally I like reading Paul Graham's essays, but I think this one is a bunch of gibberish.
- jasongullickson 18y agoFascinating. What would be illuminating is if you would point to the competitor and the copied product instead of just listing Microsoft products. also, what does the line "Apple:iPhone" have to do with this? (admittedly, Singularity is very, very cool)
- actf 18y agoSure, I'll provide some examples The companies copying Microsoft products: C# -> Novell Visual Studio -> Just about every other IDE out there rips off features that appear in Visual Studio first.Intellisense is the obvious example here. Office -> Open Office, parts of Google Docs Powershell -> Open source projects are directly copying this shell for linux WPF -> KDE 4, Nokia Gazelle -> Google is doing something very similar to this As for the line: Apple: IPhone I was trying to get the point across that this was the only product from apple that I could think of which has been copied by others. Perhaps you could make a case for parts of OSX as well. Either way my main point was that it's easy to find products that illustrate Microsoft's innovation. I find it frustrating when people dismiss Microsoft's products as inferior to the alternatives when they haven't even given them a fair evaluation. I find I encounter a lot of people where I work that immediately dismiss Microsoft's products, just because it's Microsoft or because it costs more than the open source alternatives. In my mind this is nothing more than "software racism". It shows that these people are just closed minded.
- eugenejen 18y agoIMHO if anyone has ever read Freidrich Nietzsche's "Gott ist tot" will understand what PG meant by "Microsoft is Dead".
- shimi 18y agoIf you build a web app you must test it on IE, WM is the third biggest mobile OS for smartphones, and that's before desktops. Sorry PG I can't agree with you on this account.