3 ms·
No! Why more density? What will that accomplish? There are a lot of cities that could use the business. The other side of the Bay. Stockton. Stop cramming p
by raverbashing 14y ago
No!
Why more density? What will that accomplish?
There are a lot of cities that could use the business.
The other side of the Bay. Stockton.
Stop cramming people into a closed space, it will result in a miserable and still expensive place.
- minimax 14y ago"Why more density? What will that accomplish?" The general idea is that more housing supply should drive the cost of housing down.
- jkubicek 14y agoIs there any evidence this wouldn't be temporary? I don't know of any US cities with high density cheap housing.
- rayiner 14y agoIt's temporary in the sense that people just move in until prices go up, but the equillibrium supports a lot more people. E.g. housing prices in San Francisco are approaching those of Manhattan, even though the latter has twice as many people in half the space. In comparison, downtown Chicago is similarly dense to downtown SF, but housing is about half the price (thanks to liberal policies in the 1970's that allowed free development of tons of 25+ story high rise apartment buildings).
- ajross 14y agoThe flip side logic works too: if you want wide open sprawl, move to Stockton or Livermore or wherever. "Cramming people into a closed space" is a way to make it easier for more people to live where they want. People in SF right now are already OK with a high density environment. Lots of people who want to move to SF are, too, but can't because there is no space for them. The idea that "density" is "miserable" is a uniquely post-war american one. It really doesn't work that way.
- sageikosa 14y ago> The idea that "density" is "miserable" is a uniquely post-war american one. Right, once Americans were able to afford cars and could physically remove themselves from urban density, they did, and it became part of the "American Dream". More so on the East Coast, where farm-land for development was cheap and relatively accessible to urban centers of business. On the West Coast where cities are either crammed between mountains and coast, or stuck in the middle of a desert, owning property required paying the higher prices driven by high demand and little supply. > It really doesn't work that way. It works that way for anyone who doesn't want to live in dense urban environments.
- raverbashing 14y agoIt is miserable when architects are trying to cram everything to tiny sizes because of costs caused by real-estate speculation. Yes, I lived in a college dorm, tiny, but not miserable (college helps, of course ;) ). Now, see this: "http://realestate.aol.com/blog/2013/03/07/san-francisco-micro-apartment/ http://realestate.aol.com/blog/2013/03/07/san-francisco-micr... 160 sq. ft. (or around 14m2 for the metrically able, or my favorite measure, this is the size of a square with a side of 3.7m) That college dorm I lived, no kitchen, no shower, was around this size.
- ajross 14y agoThen surely you would support the argument in the linked article which would allow building more square feet of living space by increasing allowed building heights, right? You're equating living space with physical land area, and that's not right at all.
- raverbashing 14y agoI know they are different Increasing build height poses a burden on the road/transport system. Believe me this is a bad idea. You can't do that with either a good investment in public transport and road work (which is usually not possible since you can't reduce the size of the buildings to make roads wider) That's one of the reasons for massive traffic jams in cities like Sao Paulo for example. New York has a higher density, but a very good public transport system.
- bradleyjg 14y agoIf you like the medium size, medium density city experience why don't you move instead of blocking progress? The US has lots of cities like that, and only one large, high density city. We could desperately use a few more.
- spenrose 14y agoIt would accomplish a huge amount. Density makes us richer and smarter: http://www.ted.com/talks/geoffrey_west_the_surprising_math_of_cities_and_corporations.html http://www.ted.com/talks/geoffrey_west_the_surprising_math_o... ... and it is our best hope against climate change: http://www.alexsteffen.com/carbon-zero-2/ http://www.alexsteffen.com/carbon-zero-2/
- rayiner 14y agoDensity can be miserable, but San Francisco is far away from the levels at which it becomes miserable. Midtown Manhattan is probably approaching 100,000 people per square mile, but it seems much denser than that because Manhattan more than doubles in size during the day so the daytime density is probably approaching 200,000 people per square mile (for reference, china town in SF has a nighttime density of 75,000 per square mile). 100,000 per square mile is not at all miserably crowded. I was working here right after Hurricane Sandy when all the commuters were staying home, and it was not crowded at all. My neighborhood in Chicago, which is probably around 50,000 nighttime density, feels positively empty on the weekends. You could double the density of most parts of San Francisco and still not even be approaching "uncomfortably dense" (that would take the CBD to ~100,000 and areas like the mission to ~50,000).
- geogra4 14y agoAgree completely. Density can be wonderful (see paris) or miserable (see kowloon walled city) Like anything else, it just has to be done well.
- mikk0j 14y agoAgain, there are sides to that. Paris is one of the few places more expensive than SF, and the quality of the density can be a subjective one. I for one dislike Paris and the kind of density it creates (comparable to London, just smells worse).
- raverbashing 14y agoYes Not to mention London and Paris have a very good public transport system In the Bay Area you have Caltrain and company shuttles mostly.
- krakensden 14y agoAnd BART and Muni and AC Transit and WestCAT and... But yes, the SF<->SV corridor is Caltrain and company shuttles mostly.
- freehunter 14y agoDoes it make sense to scale horizontally just because you have extra space in the next rack over? Or maybe the servers in the other rack need room to breathe and cool themselves, so scaling vertically might make sense for the servers that can handle it. Doesn't it make sense to keep cities confined to relatively small areas? It helps eliminate the need to travel long distances, waiting in traffic jams.