2 ms·
The author did not realize that the "repetitive dictionary lookup" function is not a 1-to-1 mapping. There could be, for example, multiple words whose definitio
by marcin_kw 14y ago
The author did not realize that the "repetitive dictionary lookup" function is not a 1-to-1 mapping. There could be, for example, multiple words whose definition starts with "a type". All these words map to the same ciphertext, eventually.
The "repetitive dictionary lookup" function is very useful for validating Alice's claims of solving parts of the puzzle, but imperfect for deriving the solution from a ciphertext.
- jgrahamc 14y agoI didn't? Or perhaps you didn't read my blog post where at the end I say... "PS In reality, Alice's one way function is not 'bijective'. That means that some starting words will end up at the same word. For example, when FOLIO, PIECE and WORLD are passed through Alice's one way function they all end up at THINGS. In a follow up post I'll take about this and its implications."