2 ms·
There can be a very real issue if HN accounts have an age or birthdate associated with them which indicate that the user is under 13. In that situation where kn
by orenjacob 13y ago
There can be a very real issue if HN accounts have an age or birthdate associated with them which indicate that the user is under 13. In that situation where knowledge of age is in the hands of the website operator, the FTC has taken notice, and action. See Path's recent FTC COPPA ruling as an example.
So, if HN internally keeps a reference from votes in the under-10 category of this poll to the accounts they came from, and if any of those people are under 13, there may be cause for real concern re: COPPA.
There are sort of 3 ways to approach this safely...
1. don't ask, don't tell (eg: Google's main search page)
2. ask, and reject (eg: Facebook account signup)
3. ask, accept, and get consent (eg: some child focused sites)
HN is pretty clearly not a child-oriented website, but if there is concrete knowledge of age, COPPA can apply.
- icebraining 13y agoDoes it really apply to a user-generated poll? I mean, this would be no different than a user of a forum or chat service asking another their age, with the server keeping some kind of message records. I think it's hard to make the claim that the administrators have concrete knowledge; it's just an anonymous record in the database. Path's case is different, since the form asking for the birthdate was made by them, so they knew they had that information.