3 ms·
> Marriage is already the exception, it doesn't follow that a revision of marriage law would reverse that convention universally. You'd have to legislate to ab
by jacques_chester 14y ago
> Marriage is already the exception, it doesn't follow that a revision of marriage law would reverse that convention universally.
You'd have to legislate to abolish the presumption, otherwise it will continue to be applied. That's how the common law works. And having abolished the presumption, all the law that flows from it is now thrown out and you start from scratch. Actually, worse: some will get thrown out and you will need to make two decisions in all the early cases -- what still applies, and if it doesn't, what is the new rule?
> Marriage laws preventing abuse are redundant and can be cut.. what's the problem?
Her point here is addressed to religious libertarians, who want the state out of marriage so they can impose more onerous terms. She says that they wouldn't get what they want anyhow; if you make it into a contract, then contract laws will come along and void a bunch of religious practices.
The complexity is always going to be there. Moving it from the "family law" heading to the "contract law" doesn't make the complexity go away. It will just jam up the courts while everything is rehashed from scratch.
She often discusses contrasts between Roman and Common law, if that interests you.