4 ms·
Does it even make sense to consider Bitcoin as a separate economy containing "no real value"? I see it more as an alternative banking system, the money it conta
by ricardobeat 14y ago
Does it even make sense to consider Bitcoin as a separate economy containing "no real value"? I see it more as an alternative banking system, the money it contains comes from real-world value and gets converted back into real-word products; it's not a virtual currency.
- samegreatsleeve 14y agoIt's only a separate economy to the extent that it isn't instantly being converted back into some other currency. There is a genuine bitcoin economy, and it is centered around the trade of goods that are illegal: child porn, weapons, viruses, credit card numbers, and most important of all: illegal drugs. The question is not whether there is potential for a non-government backed digital currency. The question is whether bitcoin will be effective in that role given the design of the currency. If a better currency is invented that includes some kind of inflationary mechanism, perhaps the drug trade/etc will take up that currency. In that case bitcoin truly will die.
- matthew-wegner 14y agoI think this is a hugely important distinction. The linked-to analysis seems to assume that BTC are bought with USD, sit around in a wallet, and then come back out as USD. When in fact, BTC's usefulness is its frictionless-but-secure, anonymous transactional nature. Its anonymity is even stronger if you mine coins yourself (or acquire coins directly from a miner for favors or whatever). You can probably make the case that BTC must be deflationary, in order to draw in traders/investors, who actually provide necessary market liquidity to proxy BTC as USD, backing the worth of BTC-for-goods transactions...
- DanBC 14y agoBitcoin is not anonymous. (http://anonymity-in-bitcoin.blogspot.co.uk/2011/07/bitcoin-is-not-anonymous.html http://anonymity-in-bitcoin.blogspot.co.uk/2011/07/bitcoin-i...) (https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Anonymity https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Anonymity)
- Nursie 14y agoIt's not really anonymous though, transactions are publicly recorded for all time. It's also not 100% frictionless. There are fees and though they are currently low, they are there.
- matthew-wegner 14y agoI know there are transaction fees. I meant friction as--once you have BTC in a wallet, you are absolutely free to spend them as you wish. There is no way for anyone to prevent a transaction. Bitcoin addresses are public but anonymous. But yes, you can analyze the public ledger to tie known data (publicly-posted donation addresses, etc) to try to de-anonymize someone. There are coin tumblers/mixers in place in some markets, although it's hard to tell how effective they are.