3 ms·
No such thing: http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/14777/why-isnt-there-a-uniform-probability-distribution-over-the-positive-real-number http://math.stackex
by jerf 14y ago
No such thing: http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/14777/why-isnt-there-a-uniform-probability-distribution-over-the-positive-real-number http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/14777/why-isnt-there...
Get far enough into Reflection on Relativity and the author makes some interesting observations based on this tidbit: http://www.mathpages.com/rr/rrtoc.htm http://www.mathpages.com/rr/rrtoc.htm (But it is quite a ways in there.)
- lmgftp 14y agoAcknowledged. Mostly a facetious comment, as any known distribution could be found (over infinite time) and you'd only become pseudononymous (which is exactly what the original comment wouldn't like!) On the other hand... It would be secure :) never withdraw. Anonymity through one way function/flow.
- anonymoushn 14y agoCould you point out the problem with such a distribution? It isn't immediately obvious that I cannot satisfy both axioms. Edit: The helpful explanation linked in a comment on the question you linked is defective because it applies to all continuous probability distributions.
- krcz 14y agoUsing uniform distribution definition from Wikipedia ("all intervals of the same length on the distribution's support are equally probable") we get P(X \in [0,1)) = P(X \in [1, 2)) = P(X \in [2, 3)) = ... By countable additivity P(\Omega) = P(X \in [0, \infty)) = P(X \in [0, 1)) + P(\X \in [1, 2)) + ... = P(X \in [0, 1)) + P(X \in [0, 1)) + ... And this evaluates to 0 if P(X \in [0, 1)) = 0 and to \infty if P(\X \in [0, 1)) > 0.
- lwat 14y agoThe probability of any finite interval P(a, b) = 0
- jerf 14y agoThe key is the restriction that in the uniform distribution the probability density must be the same at all points, and if it covers infinity, it can be neither 0 nor anything greater than 0 if it's going to sum to 1. It's perfectly legal to have a probability distribution across all the reals. In fact most if not all of the well-known ones are; the Gaussian/normal distribution is defined on all reals, for instance. But it varies, and the integration from negative infinity to positive infinity sums to 1. In fact everything that we refer to as "normal" distributions in the real world technically aren't, as the finite nature of the universe means the probability of the extremes is simply zero (give or take being totally wrong about the nature of the universe in which case all bets are off anyhow) rather than very, very small, and in many cases there's a sharp cutoff at 0, or some other arbitrary boundary, which a true normal distribution doesn't have. But it's often still the best mathematical approximation, with negligible error. (... until it isn't.... caveat emptor.)
- waps 14y agoWhy isn't the answer P = { Inf -> 1, otherwise 0 } ? Axiom 1: P(E) elem N => P(E) >= 0, for all E Trivially satisfied Axiom 2: P(Omega) = 1 Satisfied: Omega = N { Inf } elem N Axiom 3: Sigma additivity. Trivially satisfied since it either includes { Inf } or it doesn't, making the outcome 0 or 1. Where is the problem ? I think it's pretty clear that this is the only possible solution, because since N is not closed, there is no way to keep a uniform density other than 0. This does not seem like it's a very useful solution, but it does seem to satisfy the axioms.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- anonymoushn 14y agoInfinity isn't a positive real :(
- waps 14y agoIn most definitions I've seen of it, it is. In fact, it's a natural number.
- consz 14y ago>Edit: The helpful explanation linked in a comment on the question you linked is defective because it applies to all continuous probability distributions. No, why do you think so?
- anonymoushn 14y agoIt contains the sentence "For any distribution, the sum of probabilities always equals 1" without the caveat that the sum is of a countable number of probabilities. It applies to every continuous distribution using the same argument, but with "the sum across all naturals" replaced with "the sum across the appropriate universe."
- Fargren 14y ago"the sum across the appropriate universe" for Reals is an integral. An integral can go from -Infinite to Infinite and still equal 1. This is the reason, for instance, why Zeno's Paradox of movement doesn't really forbid all movement.
- anonymoushn 14y agoThis comment is more or less irrelevant. The third axiom of probability is about sums of countably many terms: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axioms_of_probability#Third_axiom http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axioms_of_probability#Third_axi...