4 ms·
Indeed: Bitcoin isn't, fundamentally, "a currency, but digital"; it's simply "bits on a computer that have a [market-discovered] spot price" (a unique thing amo
by derefr 14y ago
Indeed: Bitcoin isn't, fundamentally, "a currency, but digital"; it's simply "bits on a computer that have a [market-discovered] spot price" (a unique thing among bits-on-computers.) Any conclusions about its usefulness or lack thereof should be made based upon that fact.
Which is to say, it's not a very good currency--and anyone who is taking a long position that Bitcoin will somehow replace or surpass any real currency is a fool who this bubble is going to bankrupt. But, if you just need some bits that hold a (however-ephemeral) value--not a high value, just any defined value--without any central authority needing to back that value, then BTC seems like a good option.
A good example of a use for "bits that have a spot price regardless of any central authority" might be, say, a market for CPU cycles for agents within a distributed computation mesh (somewhat ironically, a dual to Bitcoin's own mining process.) Picture a version of, say, the Erlang VM, where processes could voluntarily surrender some part of each allocated timeslice to other processes who they "owed." Agent processes would need to create highly divisible units of currency to pay other agents on other (untrusted!) systems in exchange for their time.
"Real money" would be very hard to use in this system--if every single agent had a real bank account, transaction fees would quickly overwhelm the system's usefulness. And "fiat play-money" (machine-hour-tokens or something) would only work if everyone could agree, across the whole distributed mesh, that they were worth something, and either there was a "central bank" with which all transactions had to coordinate (turning the distributed system into a hub-and-spoke design), or all systems could be trusted to allocate agents units of of currency only in proportion to productivity.
Bitcoin is something a machine can make, and which will have a price for long enough for it to use to pay another machine for useful work. Also, it cannot be made without doing work proportional to the cost of making it. This combination of factors makes Bitcoin unusual enough to be useful in some limited cases. Just not any of the ones people are hoping for. :)