6 ms·
So we talked to a few artists who said they thought it was a cool idea. BOOM! Our idea had been validated! Why was that sufficient data to justify spending mon
by minimaxir 14y ago
So we talked to a few artists who said they thought it was a cool idea. BOOM! Our idea had been validated!
Why was that sufficient data to justify spending months and months of your life bringing this startup to fruition?
EDIT: I did not intend to make a sly insult toward the author. I've seen people do startups with similar justifications and I am confused.
- delluminatus 14y agoThe post was clearly meant to be firmly tongue-in-cheek. That part in particular was simply self-deprecating sarcasm.
- dopamean 14y agoExactly. Sometimes when you think your idea is good all you need is one or two other people to tell you they think its good and that's it: it's a good idea. How did Instagram come to the conclusion that their idea was a good idea? Or any other startup for that matter. If Zillionears turned out to be a success no one would have thought that having a few people say "good idea" in the beginning was insufficient to get started.
- nemrow 14y agoI totally agree with that! There are tons of companies that "win the lottery", and build a product with no validation and succeed. It is obviously not the "right" way to do it, but sometimes it does work.
- taude 14y agoYeup. Lots of arm-chair advice these days. It's a business all in itself. It's funny watching people compile lists of "all the mistakes" in hopes that not repeating a single one of them will equal success. Plenty of wildly successful businesses became so without having MVPs or setting up fake landing pages. They spent years building out real product-breakthroughs, maybe with even real technology/science. I'm willing to bet that for every rule that's broken in that StartUpGrave twitter list above (I haven't looked so I don't know what's really there, but I'm going on just the idea of compiling lists of mistakes), there's a company who succeeded while still failing the rule. There's so much retro-active quarterbacking that goes on (especially in the VC-world) that says X company was success because they applied this-thing-I'm-just-now-naming as a rule. Even though, Apple has taught us things like you're users don't always know what they want or need.
- nemrow 14y agoBingo! :)
- LeeHunter 14y agoAnd then the next sentence: "After that moment we basically stopped talking to artists for a year."
- scmccarthy 14y agoIt wasn't sufficient data. OP was describing their foolish attitude at the time.
- whyleyc 14y agoI think that's his point (illustrated with sarcasm) - with the benefit of hindsight he realises it wasn't.
- austenallred 14y agoGetting to the point where an idea is truly validated by unbiased and honest customers is way, way more difficult than we all pretend like it is. I think the idea that you can figure out if your business is viable by talking to a few people can be just as dangerous as it can be helpful.
- hayksaakian 14y agoPPC + Landing page is typically promoted as a valuable tool for validation around here. With launchrock + adwords this has become stupid easy.
- taude 14y agoMaybe this explains so many me-too consumer based websites are de rigueur around here? I'd like to hear more feedback about MVP practices within the enterprise space.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ajross 14y agoThis seems unkind. What data would you want? It's easy to jeer in hindsight, but frankly if focused and professional market research could reliably determine the existence of new markets there would be no need for a startup to find them. This very web site wouldn't exist. They played a hunch and lost. The linked post details lots of mistakes, but this particular one doesn't seem like one to me.
- wpietri 14y agoI agree that was unkind. But treating a little positive feedback as validation is, as the original author now clearly realizes, a giant mistake. You've got a business when people repeatedly exchange value with you. Kind words are validation of a sort, but the weakest kind. To go from there to spending a year building a platform is basically hearing what you want to hear. Better not to ask than to believe what you hear uncritically; if you don't ask, at least you know you don't know.
- saidajigumi 14y ago> What data would you want? The data that was lost right here: "After that moment we basically stopped talking to artists for a year [...]" Find customers as early as possible, engage with them as often as possible, and really really listen to what's being said. This is a huge benefit of bootstrapping. Customer engagement from the earliest possible time is vital to the process of transforming an idea into a product.
- mikeg8 14y agoA cool idea does not equal a business model. That is why I think soooo many startups fail. They build something awesome, amazing, cool whatever, but they don;t stop to ask people, "Will you pay for this? Is this something you think I could charge for?" That is the data I WANT and need.
- locacorten 14y agoAhem... Have you heard of Facebook? Or GMail? Or Hotmail? These are money-losing businesses. As we speak. Real life is much more complicated.