3 ms·
One thing a lot of employers and managers don't realize is that humans aren't cogs. The general model of employment is that you replace a given human in a speci
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
One thing a lot of employers and managers don't realize is that humans aren't cogs. The general model of employment is that you replace a given human in a specific role with another human in the same role, just like replacing cogs. The real world doesn't work that way though. In reality everyone brings a different set of skills and passions to the table. And the way person X does job Y is going to be very much different than the way person Z does job Y. And sometimes this can be significant enough to where you can't actually replace person X with person Z directly. What you're doing is building a machine with parts that are all different, and if you have to replace a key part often times you will need to completely restructure the machine to make it work well again. Meaning, sometimes you might replace one person with several people who do different parts of the job. Or you might replace one person with a new person who now also does the job of current employee person W, who's know redundant.
Teams are complex beasts, and they get more complex the more talented people are in them. Managers need to be very mindful of those complexities when they form or change teams.
- hobs 14y agoThis is why managers are so obsessed with process and documentation, because they have a vain hope that they can replace people by just having someone following a process.
- yardie 14y agoNo, they want documentation because humans are mortal and selfish. Whether you leave the company by your own free will or in a body bag someone has to pick up the pieces and resume where you left off. Documentation means I can take a vacation and know things at the office will be fine. If this also means I'm replaceable, so be it.
- benjamincburns 14y agoIt's both. No documentation is irresponsible. An over emphasis on 'repeatability' through exhaustive process and product documentation (and strict adherence to said process) is a red flag in my book (in most situations). To me it either means that the employer is worried about its employees walking (as you suggested), or that the employer wants to minimize the effects of discarding the employee. In the first case, it's a self-fulfilling prophecy. In the latter case you'll achieve what you're after, but not how you planned. Instead you're minimizing the current value and productivity of the employee, meaning that when you fire him/her, the impact will be minimal. The moral of the story? Limit the scope of your documentation, and place high emphasis on that limited scope. Instead of worrying about how you'll replace someone when they're gone, worry about whether or not you're putting them in an environment where they can perform to the potential of their unique abilities as an individual. (And don't even get me started on the whole "No documentation is better than bad documentation" thing.)