7 ms·
As Big Investors Emerge, Bitcoin Gets Ready for its Close-Up
- tvladeck 14y ago> “We have elected to put our money and faith in a mathematical framework that is free of politics and human error,” Tyler Winklevoss said. Well, I don't even know what to say about that. Bitcoin is pretty awesome tech but I don't think anything can take care of human error...
- illuminate 14y agoI appreciate how poorly researched they are in their investments. "free of politics" made me laugh much more.
- tlrobinson 14y agoCase in point... https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=165309.0;all https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=165309.0;all
- brown9-2 14y agoIt seems like humans are doomed to continually rediscover that the weakest part of markets is always the other humans.
- anon808 14y agowell said. folks tend to forget that there's no entity such as a 'market' that you can deal with, there are only people, just like you with strengths and weaknesses, nothing more.
- SkyMarshal 14y agoIt's free of politics and human error if they keep all their btc in their own wallet.dat. Will look forward to seeing their solution to bitrot, entropy, and hardware failure.
- jbooth 14y agoI don't know how many times this will have to be pointed out before people get it... Currencies don't have investors, they have users. Sure, there are currency traders but the point is to be used.
- tptacek 14y agoI'm not sure what point you're trying to make. As you acknowledge, currencies obviously do have traders, like George Soros. So it's hard to start a comment with "currencies don't have traders". One of the problems with Bitcoin, of course, is that it is intensely speculative; its "users" hoard it, and its transaction volume as a currency is so extremely thin (blog tip jars and "spa powder") that its "exchange rate" (more appropriately, it's spot price) is untenably volatile.
- jbooth 14y agoThe exceptions prove the rules of course. Currencies do not have (>10% of volume of transactions) investors, they have (>90% of volume of transactions) users. Currencies are primarily mediums of exchange and occasionally used as an asset class. Bitcoin is primarily used as an asset class and very occasionally used as a medium of exchange. I don't think you're really disagreeing with me, we're just quibbling on semantics.
- chollida1 14y ago> Currencies do not have (>10% of volume of transactions) investors, they have (>90% of volume of transactions) users. Are you sure about your numbers? from the fx exchange wikipdeia page: > As such, it has been referred to as the market closest to the ideal of perfect competition, notwithstanding currency intervention by central banks. According to the Bank for International Settlements,[3] as of April 2010, average daily turnover in global foreign exchange markets is estimated at $3.98 trillion, a growth of approximately 20% over the $3.21 trillion daily volume as of April 2007. Some firms specializing on foreign exchange market had put the average daily turnover in excess of US$4 trillion.[4] If you are right that less than 10% of fx transactions are traders and there is 4 trillion in fx trades a day then there must be 36 trillion in non trader transactions a day. That seems a bit high to me:) I think if anything you've got your values transposed:)
- deepblueocean 14y agoOh, so that's why the value is crashing... people just wanted to get out once they saw the Winkelvii getting in. Well that explains everything. I can go home now.
- zeteo 14y agoPoor Winklevoss twins keep taking the wrong decision at the wrong time... "This social network idea looks great, let's tell Mark Zuckerberg about it!" "Bitcoin has been rising so fast, we should sink a few million dollars into it!"
- scotty79 14y agoI'd like to make such bad decissions to have few million dolllars to sunk into bitcoin.
- illuminate 14y agoBe born rich.
- OGinparadise 14y agoUnless you know the price they bought in....
- dustcoin 14y agoThe article says they have been buying since the summer, so they are most likely still up a bunch.
- AVTizzle 14y agoIf money is a way to keep score, they're doing pretty well for themselves.
- illuminate 14y agoThey'll always be okay, no matter how poor their business decisions and investments.
- tlrobinson 14y agoIt sounds like they started buying long before this latest hype cycle: "The 31-year-old identical twins have amassed since last summer what appears to be one of the single largest portfolios of the online currency that has caused such a stir in financial and technology circles." Though I do wonder about the timing of them going public with this fact. Perhaps they're trying to dampen the crash.
- tsotha 14y agoYou'd be crazy to put serious money into bitcoins. Not because it's fundamentally flawed as a currency (I don't have the expertise to know if that's true or not), but because if bitcoins ever become more than a sideshow governments around the world will make their use illegal (de facto if not de jure). People left holding the currency will be out of luck. Controlling a currency is a politically easy route to tax everybody who uses it, and governments will not give up that privilege even if it means intrusive new controls on internet traffic.
- jerguismi 14y agoLike goverments banning drugs stopped people from using drugs.
- tsotha 14y agoBitcoins will be much easier to stop than drugs.
- moe 14y agoAnd how exactly would that work? Do you expect all governments of the world to collectively agree on a ban of digital currencies? When was the last time all governments of the world agreed on anything? Bitcoin's future is certainly uncertain, but I doubt its demise will stem from this angle.
- betterunix 14y agoHow hard do you think it would be for the US or Chinese governments to amass the computing power needed to maliciously fork the Bitcoin block chain? You are looking at what, $20 million of ASICs? $30 million? Let's be completely unrealistic and say $100 million. That is less than a tenth of what the government spent on the NSA's new datacenter in Utah. It's pocket change, barely even a blip on the budget of the US government. It requires a very small commitment of personnel and no fieldwork at all, and no real agreement from any other countries. If we called Bitcoin a money-laundering scam, if we attacked under the guise of evidence gathering (just reversing transactions so criminals won't get paid by our cops), I doubt many countries would object even if their citizens lost money in the process. That is just with the known, well-documented polynomial time attack on Bitcoin. Given that there is no security proof and little formal analysis of the Bitcoin protocol, and not even the kind of heuristic analysis we rely on for block ciphers and efficient hash functions, I seriously doubt that an attack would even require that much effort.
- citricsquid 14y agoMaybe this guy will get his wish if the Winklevoss twins lose everything: http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1c525e/ive_lost_more_money_in_the_past_24_hours_than_ive/ http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1c525e/ive_lost_mor... http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1c5m6w/class_action_against_mtgox/ http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1c5m6w/class_action...
- rayiner 14y agoThat second reddit thread is amazing. OP: "Do we have any legal ground to stand on here? Lots of people have had their lives torn apart by this. I remember NASDAQ had to compensate people after the debacle that was the Facebook IPO. Why is this any different? I would appreciate your thoughts. Thanks." Top response: "Well, considering bitcoin isn't regulated by the SEC - no you have no legal ground to stand on." Further down: "So you want your unregulated currency to be.... regulated?" OP in response: "There is a difference between financial regulations and corporate liability/consumer protection laws. It's not about financial regulations." In Bitcoin, we are currently watching a microcosm of how the traditional financial system came to be the way it is. It's really a rare opportunity to see the evolution of complex social systems in real-time.
- minimaxir 14y agor/bitcoin is an interesting subreddit. There was a thread yesterday where someone asked, completely serious: "Theoetically speaking, what would happen if someone bought all the bitcoin? My friend wants to invest and he's concerned that the currency could be completely bought."
- dublinben 14y agoThat's a naive, but not entirely unfounded concern. It's been quite common in the last few days to see enormous trading walls at certain values. If a large percent of the volume is set at an obscene price (200-1000% of the current average) then after a certain point, you effectively can't buy Bitcoin any more. There have already been enormous spreads (50$ difference and beyond) on several exchanges. That is not a sign of a healthy market to invest in.
- 7Figures2Commas 14y agoThe problem the Winklevoss twins have is that they seem to be placing a bet on what they believe will be a long-term secular trend through an instrument that is extremely volatile and better suited to speculation, and that will probably continue to be for the foreseeable future. In doing so, they're taking on a level of risk that is unnecessary given their investment thesis. If the Winklevoss twins truly believe that the future of "virtual currencies" is bright, their investments should be focused almost exclusively on ecosystem companies, not the currencies themselves.
- rdl 14y agoThe OpenCoin a16z invested in is presumably Ripple (where the parent company named itself OpenCoin relatively recently), not the long-standing and more useful OpenCoin.org (which is an open source electronic cash protocol library).
- carbocation 14y agoWow, this bitcoin / Winkelvoss story is front page news on the New York Times website: http://i.imgur.com/rSLLqZz.png http://i.imgur.com/rSLLqZz.png
- epoxyhockey 14y agoI'm completely fascinated with how quickly this bubble inflated and deflated: about 3 weeks. If the bottom hadn't already dropped out, I would say that this news article indicates a good time to hit the sell button.