3 ms·
In a very brief overview, there are limits to the number of skilled immigrants that can enter the US every year. That number is exhausted extremely quickly, lea
by untog 14y ago
In a very brief overview, there are limits to the number of skilled immigrants that can enter the US every year. That number is exhausted extremely quickly, leaving many tech companies (an overwhelming majority of skilled immigrants are tech workers (1)) short-staffed.
It is difficult to say who benefits from this arrangement. At least in theory, it's US workers, because they are more in demand. But at the current time, demand outstrips supply enough that the limit could be raised without significant issues. The reason this hasn't happened is largely that "immigration" has become a politically sensitive topic- skilled immigration and "illegal" immigration from Mexico get bunched up into the same topic. Now that there is an appetite to tackle immigration as a whole, we might see a change.
(1) I had started an overview of US skilled immigration- I currently have no time to finish it, but it does contain an interactive chart breaking down the immigration categories: http://experimenting.alastair.is/immigration/ http://experimenting.alastair.is/immigration/
- rayiner 14y ago> But at the current time, demand outstrips supply enough that the limit could be raised without significant issues. What happens when the tech industry crashes again, like it does every decade or so? Silicon Valley is tremendously cyclical and always has been. It's not a good idea to predicate our immigration policy on the current boom.
- redblacktree 14y ago"Always has been?" I think your data set is fairly small here.
- rayiner 14y agohttp://www.mercurynews.com/business/ci_16969015 http://www.mercurynews.com/business/ci_16969015, http://www.jointventure.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=299:building-the-next-silicon-valley-strategy-and-actions-092003&catid=77:publications-archive&Itemid=348 http://www.jointventure.org/index.php?option=com_content&... ("Today is not the first time that Silicon Valley has experienced a boom/bust cycle. The Valley experienced significant job growth, followed by job losses, in the 1970s, 1980s, and early 1990s. Each time, from these down cycles emerged the “next” Silicon Valley economy. Economic adversity helped stimulate the Silicon Valley habitat to major innovations, including the commercialization of the integrated circuit (1970s), the development of the microprocessor and personal computer (1980s), and the application of the Internet (1990s)").
- redblacktree 14y agoRight. Looks like you have four data points. It only takes two points to make a line, but it may not be best-fit.
- samstave 14y agoAwesome, thanks. I understood the basic premise that any country wants to be able to limit the number of immigrants, in theory, to ensure that their citizens get jobs, assuming the citizenry is skilled enough. It appears to me that at the heart of immigration reform is education reform. Frankly, I think that education in the US is utterly broken. And I think that at the core of this issue is the difficult balance between socially funded services and for-profit corporate motives: If we find that developing a basic level of skill and well being in a society is dependent upon a well educated and healthy populous, then the purpose of a civilized society should be providing education and healthcare to the people who create that society. Then, the ability for the market to build for-profit companies, staffed by well-educated workers seems to be a natural benefit. The fact that the US is at odds with its own people over education and health - while at the same time upholding policies that would prevent well educated workers from being able to enter the country speaks to a much more dark and sinister character of the US government as a whole. And it may just be the sad result of many many complex factors and not some conspiracy of the government out to stifle every aspect of healthy growth of society - but the fact that there appears to be so much active resistance to fixing these sorts of issues surely makes one wonder what the fark is really going on the minds of the government to let these issues fester.